21 Accepted in Part

Develop a pilot programme to fund replication studies, learning from NWO's model

Recommendation
Providing adequate funding for replication studies is an important precondition for ensuring researchers have the resources necessary to conduct them. UKRI should learn from its Dutch equivalent, NWO, by developing a pilot programme to fund replication studies.
Government Response Summary
The government partially accepts, stating UKRI will learn from NWO's pilot but does not commit to developing its own. They highlight existing funding mechanisms for replication studies and will consider increasing focus on metascience through a new caucus.
Paragraph Reference
115
Government Response
Accepted in Part
HM Government Accepted in Part
We partially accept this recommendation. 55. UKRI has strong international relationships including with Dutch colleagues NWO and look forward to learning more about their pilot programme, and whether it has brought about intended outcomes. 56. UKRI has a diverse portfolio of funding mechanisms, inclusive of replication studies, meta-analysis and longer-term grants. UKRI requests additional specific information for reproducibility in areas where there is increased concern, such as the use of animals in research where the 3R’s apply (replacement, reduction and refinement). 57. As described above, In June 2023 UKRI launched the £7 million Innovation and Research Caucus20 (IRC) as a world leading centre of excellence to maximise research and innovation funding impact and will consider the case for further increasing focus on metascience. 58. UKRI funds research across all disciplines. The desirability, possibility and practicality of reproducing results varies greatly across the work that UKRI funds. For example, in some areas where experimental cycles are short, reproducibility is inherently built into any project funding, and in many disciplines, robustness is further enhanced by taking multiple different approaches to test the same hypothesis.
Addressee Bodies
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Timeline
Recommendation age 3.1 yrs
Report published 10 May 2023