John Graham

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2019-0348
Date of Report 9 November 2018
Coroner Catherine McKenna
Response Deadline est. 7 June 2019
All 1 response received · Deadline: 7 Jun 2019
Response Status
Responses 1 of 1
56-Day Deadline 7 Jun 2019
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Coroner's Concerns
_ Carbon monoxide detectors are not routinely installed in residential accommodation rented by Rochdale Borough Housing Limited which, if unremedied, creates a risk of future deaths.
Responses
Rochdale Boroughwide Housing Limited
26 Mar 2019
Response received
View full response
Dear Sirs Re Death of John Eric Graham (MT) This response is prepared in order to comply with the Notice of HM Coroner pursuant to Regulation 28 of the Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013 Regulations") At the inquest of Mr Graham, the Assistant Coroner expressed concern that carbon monoxide detectors are not routinely installed in residential accommodation rented by Rochdale Boroughwide Housing Ltd which; if not remedied, creates a risk of future deaths_ Response The Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm (England) Regulations 2015 only require private landlords to install carbon monoxide detectors and Registered Providers are specifically excluded from the regulations. Further; the installation will only take place if there are rooms containing solid fuel burning appliances and such detectors are not required when there are only gas burning appliances installed This is re-iterated by the Building Regulations, Part J, which requires that when a new or replacement solid fuel appliance is installed carbon monoxide detector is fitted. However; no mention is made of gas appliances_ On the 30th April 2018 the Government announced a review into the rules that require carbon monoxide alarms to be fitted in homes across England. The review is considering whether there should be blanket requirement to install alarms for all methods of heating, including gas and oil appliances. Until the utcome of that review is known it would not be prudent to consider a wholesale installation programme in the absence the detailed requirements that such recommendation would bring: For example, the most recent changes in Scotland will require smoke and carbon monoxide detectors in specific locations and of specific types. They will also need to be hard wired when those regulations come into force in Scotland in February GET | 202UUH Follow rbhousing: Visit us at rbh.org uk or talk to US on Yopu Tube] 0800 027 7769 or (01706) 274100 Rochdale Boroughwide Housing Limited is charitable community benefit society: FCA register number 31452 R. Registered Office: Sandbrook |louse, Sandbrook Rochdale OLII IRY. Registered as provider of social housing RSH Register nurber 4607. Way ("The Way;

Rochdale Boroughwide Housing will continue to monitor the outcome of the current review and any recommendations which follow will be considered for implementation.
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe each of you respectively have the power to take such action. Way,
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 5th March 2018, commenced an investigation into the death of John Eric Graham
Circumstances of the Death
Mr Graham was a tenant of Rochdale Borough Housing Limited. He was found dead at his home address on 26 February 2018_ Post-mortem and Toxicology evidence suggested that ketoacidosis coupled with carbon monoxide toxicity caused his death. Upon further exploration of the evidence, carbon monoxide was excluded from the cause of death and concluded that he died as a result of natural causes: However, the evidence that heard during the course of the inquest was that carbon monoxide detectors are not routinely installed in homes rented by Rochdale Borough Housing Limited:
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Mark station passages, lifts, staircases, escalators for easy identification.
Fennell Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Investigate passenger flow and congestion in stations, take remedial action
Fennell Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Prohibit alterations to operations rooms that reduce communications and control effectiveness
Fennell Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Fit fail-safe indicator lights and dedicated alarm panel for superstructure doors
Sheen Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Fit closed-circuit television monitoring for all superstructure doors
Sheen Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Alter UK berths to allow ships to shut bow and stern doors
Sheen Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Require approved draught gauges for Ro/Ro ferries with multiple readouts
Sheen Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Adopt and regularly review updated nominal weights for cars and coaches
Sheen Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Require Port Authorities to provide rolling weigh-bridges for freight vehicles
Sheen Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans
Urgently fit approved, watertight emergency lighting units on Ro/Ro ferries
Sheen Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards Emergency contingency plans

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.