Laura Parsons
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2020-0170
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 1 Nov 2020
Response Status
Responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
1 Nov 2020
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Coroner’s Concerns
Ms Parsons was prescribed liquid morphine to treat ‘break through’ pain for cancer. It was first prescribed on 9th August 2019. Ms Parsons was admitted to hospital on 10th August 2019 with an accidental overdose of morphine. It appears 180mls were consumed in a 12 hour period. She recovered and was discharged from hospital. The remainder of the prescribed morphine was discarded.
On 31st October 2019 Ms Parsons requested a repeat prescription of liquid morphine from her GP surgery. This was authorised and a 500ml bottle of liquid morphine was dispensed to Ms Parsons. On 5th November 2019 Ms Parsons was found dead due to ingesting a fatal amount of morphine.
At inquest evidence was given that information such as recent overdose would be added to the ‘Active Problems’ section on a person’s medical records and would be prominent when any clinician accessed that person’s records.
It was explained at inquest that when a patient applies for a repeat prescription so far as the request is within the permitted timescale to issue a repeat of the prescribed item, then the prescription would be issued without any further scrutiny and the electronic systems would not take a prescriber to the patient’s medical records and in particular the ‘Active Problems’ section.
On 31st October 2019 Ms Parsons requested a repeat prescription of liquid morphine from her GP surgery. This was authorised and a 500ml bottle of liquid morphine was dispensed to Ms Parsons. On 5th November 2019 Ms Parsons was found dead due to ingesting a fatal amount of morphine.
At inquest evidence was given that information such as recent overdose would be added to the ‘Active Problems’ section on a person’s medical records and would be prominent when any clinician accessed that person’s records.
It was explained at inquest that when a patient applies for a repeat prescription so far as the request is within the permitted timescale to issue a repeat of the prescribed item, then the prescription would be issued without any further scrutiny and the electronic systems would not take a prescriber to the patient’s medical records and in particular the ‘Active Problems’ section.
Responses
Response received
View full response
Dear Mr Thompson Thank you for your letter of 3 September to Matt Hancock about the death of Laura Eve Parsons. am replying as Minister with responsibility for data and technology and medicines and am grateful for the additional time in which to do so_ would like to say how sorry was t0 read of the circumstances of Laura Parsons' death and | offer my heartfelt condolences to her family and loved ones: can appreciate how deeply upsetting Laura's death must be for her family and those who loved Laura and we must do all we can to learn from the circumstances of her death to prevent such tragedies from occurring again: In preparing this response, my officials have taken advice from NHS England and NHS Improvement (NHSEI); NHSx, the body responsible for developing best practice for NHS technology, digital and data; the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and the Care Quality Commission (CQC): First; it may be helpful if | explain that prescribers are expected to take account of NICE guidance when making treatment decisions with their patients. NICE National Guideline 46: Controlled drugs: safe use and management' , gives recommendations on the prescribing of controlled drugs that include: Taking into account the benefits of controlled drug treatment and the risks of prescribing, such as dependency or overdose; Documenting the regimen (dosing and frequency, quantity to supply) in the patient's care record and including dosage instructions on the prescription (with the maximum daily amount or frequency of doses) so this can be included on the label when dispensed; httos Inice org uklquidancelng46
Checking a person's clinical needs and if appropriate, adjusting the dose until a good balance is achieved between benefits and harms; and, Discussing with the person the arrangements for reviewing and monitoring treatment: The guideline recommends that when prescribing a repeat prescription of a controlled drug (such as morphine) for treating a long-term condition in primary care, the prescriber should take into account the person's individual circumstances to determine the frequency of review for further repeat prescriptions; and prescribe enough of a controlled drug to meet the person's clinical needs for no more than 30 days (and if, under exceptional circumstances, larger quantity is prescribed, the reasons for this should be documented in the person's care record): NICE National Guideline 46 also gives recommendations on goverance arrangements and clear lines of accountability, as well as policies, processes and procedures in relation to safe management of controlled drugs. In addition; there are governance processes that should be followed in relation to patient safety incident reporting: For example, NICE National Guideline &: Medicines Optimisation? gives several recommendations on systems for identifying, reporting and leaming medicines-related patient safety incidents. am advised by NHSx that electronic clinical systems have the facility to create alerts or warnings linked to coded problems, conditions and diagnoses that launch when a patient record is opened_ In some GP systems, additional capability enables the use of system protocols to create pop-ups that Iaunch during the prescribing process. It is not clear if a on the risk of overdose was added to Ms Parsons' patient record. However, GP clinical system best practice is that: GP practice staff should ensure all incidences of overdose are added to patient GP clinical system records using the appropriate code; GP practice staff should utilise GP clinical system functionality to create warningslalerts linked to coded entry; Repeat requests for Schedule 2 and 3 controlled drugs; such as morphine, should be subject to a strict Standard Operating Procedure within the GP practice with clear lines of accountability and responsibility for staff; GP practice staff should review all incoming hospital correspondence relating to incidences of overdose against a patients' list of repeat medications and remove the medication(s) to prevent the patient from ordering further repeat prescriptions; GP practice staff should not add controlled drugs to repeat prescribing where clinical risk of an overdose exists; and, https Ilw nice orguklquidancelnge from, flag -
GP practices should carry out an urgent structured medication review of all patients who have taken an overdose_ AII GP practices are expected to have mechanisms in place to review patient safety incidents internally within their practice. In doing so, GP practices should ensure that meet the recommendations set out in NICE guidance as described above. The findings of reviews into patient safety incidents will usually be shared with their local clinical commissioning group (CCG) and reported to NHSEI for the purposes of national learing?. am informed by NHSEI that the GP practice where Ms Parsons was registered has advised that it has reflected carefully on circumstances of Ms Parsons' death and the findings of your investigation. This includes a review of its prescribing processes to confirm comply with NICE guidance, the General Medical Council's Good Practice Guidance on Prescribing and Managing Medicines and Devices', as well as the regional protocol on prescribing Of controlled drugs: In addition to understand that a report on the learning from Ms Parsons' death has been shared with the local clinical commissioning group (CCG) , from which there may be further cascade of learning to the wider GP community. note that you copied your report to the CQC. As you may be aware, CQC is responsible for making sure that health and social care providers, and other regulators, maintain a safe environment for managing controlled drugs in England: part of its responsibilities under the Regulationss, CQC reports annually on its findings through oversight activity and makes recommendations to help ensure the continuing effectiveness of the arrangements for managing controlled drugs in England: am advised by the CQC that it is aware through its analysis of prescribing data, attendance at controlled local intelligence networks (CDLINs) , and its wider inspection and regulatory work; that patients need to be regularly monitored before repeat prescriptions are issued for controlled drugs across all Schedules: In its Controlled Drugs Annual Update for 20196, CQC made the following recommendation to strengthen existing arrangements https:/limprovement nhs uk/resources/reporting patient-safety-incidents general-practice https I gmc-uk orglethical-quidancelethical-quidance-for-doctorslprescribing-and-managing: medicines-and-devices Controlled (Supervision of Management and Use) Regulations 2013, amended on 1 April 2020 to the Controlled (Supervision of Management and Use) (Amendment) Regulations 2020 https Il cgc org uklsitesldefaultiles[The_safer_management_of_controlled_drugs AnquaL_update_ 201 gdf they the they this, As drug Drugs Drugs
The level of controlled drug prescribing continues t0 increase year on year. Unnecessary prescribing for long-term treatment can result in an accumulation of unwanted medicines in patients' homes, which increases waste and the associated risks of misuse. Furthermore, patients commonly do not fully understand the risk of dependence on long-term treatment with many of the scheduled controlled drugs and the importance of returning them to a community pharmacy once they no longer need them: To address this: Prescribers should regularly review patients' clinical needs before prescribing and consider the quantity prescribed, particularly when issuing repeat prescriptions; and, CQC encourage healthcare professionals to fully explain patients' medicines at the point of prescribing and supply: This should include giving guidance and warnings of the potential for dependence and actions to take, appropriate to patient need. CQC will continue to recommend and support measures that strengthen the safe use of controlled drugs in all settings to help improve patient safety: hope this information is helpful: Thank you for bringing these concerns to my attention: With my very best wishes, (5etheM1 LORD BETHELL
Checking a person's clinical needs and if appropriate, adjusting the dose until a good balance is achieved between benefits and harms; and, Discussing with the person the arrangements for reviewing and monitoring treatment: The guideline recommends that when prescribing a repeat prescription of a controlled drug (such as morphine) for treating a long-term condition in primary care, the prescriber should take into account the person's individual circumstances to determine the frequency of review for further repeat prescriptions; and prescribe enough of a controlled drug to meet the person's clinical needs for no more than 30 days (and if, under exceptional circumstances, larger quantity is prescribed, the reasons for this should be documented in the person's care record): NICE National Guideline 46 also gives recommendations on goverance arrangements and clear lines of accountability, as well as policies, processes and procedures in relation to safe management of controlled drugs. In addition; there are governance processes that should be followed in relation to patient safety incident reporting: For example, NICE National Guideline &: Medicines Optimisation? gives several recommendations on systems for identifying, reporting and leaming medicines-related patient safety incidents. am advised by NHSx that electronic clinical systems have the facility to create alerts or warnings linked to coded problems, conditions and diagnoses that launch when a patient record is opened_ In some GP systems, additional capability enables the use of system protocols to create pop-ups that Iaunch during the prescribing process. It is not clear if a on the risk of overdose was added to Ms Parsons' patient record. However, GP clinical system best practice is that: GP practice staff should ensure all incidences of overdose are added to patient GP clinical system records using the appropriate code; GP practice staff should utilise GP clinical system functionality to create warningslalerts linked to coded entry; Repeat requests for Schedule 2 and 3 controlled drugs; such as morphine, should be subject to a strict Standard Operating Procedure within the GP practice with clear lines of accountability and responsibility for staff; GP practice staff should review all incoming hospital correspondence relating to incidences of overdose against a patients' list of repeat medications and remove the medication(s) to prevent the patient from ordering further repeat prescriptions; GP practice staff should not add controlled drugs to repeat prescribing where clinical risk of an overdose exists; and, https Ilw nice orguklquidancelnge from, flag -
GP practices should carry out an urgent structured medication review of all patients who have taken an overdose_ AII GP practices are expected to have mechanisms in place to review patient safety incidents internally within their practice. In doing so, GP practices should ensure that meet the recommendations set out in NICE guidance as described above. The findings of reviews into patient safety incidents will usually be shared with their local clinical commissioning group (CCG) and reported to NHSEI for the purposes of national learing?. am informed by NHSEI that the GP practice where Ms Parsons was registered has advised that it has reflected carefully on circumstances of Ms Parsons' death and the findings of your investigation. This includes a review of its prescribing processes to confirm comply with NICE guidance, the General Medical Council's Good Practice Guidance on Prescribing and Managing Medicines and Devices', as well as the regional protocol on prescribing Of controlled drugs: In addition to understand that a report on the learning from Ms Parsons' death has been shared with the local clinical commissioning group (CCG) , from which there may be further cascade of learning to the wider GP community. note that you copied your report to the CQC. As you may be aware, CQC is responsible for making sure that health and social care providers, and other regulators, maintain a safe environment for managing controlled drugs in England: part of its responsibilities under the Regulationss, CQC reports annually on its findings through oversight activity and makes recommendations to help ensure the continuing effectiveness of the arrangements for managing controlled drugs in England: am advised by the CQC that it is aware through its analysis of prescribing data, attendance at controlled local intelligence networks (CDLINs) , and its wider inspection and regulatory work; that patients need to be regularly monitored before repeat prescriptions are issued for controlled drugs across all Schedules: In its Controlled Drugs Annual Update for 20196, CQC made the following recommendation to strengthen existing arrangements https:/limprovement nhs uk/resources/reporting patient-safety-incidents general-practice https I gmc-uk orglethical-quidancelethical-quidance-for-doctorslprescribing-and-managing: medicines-and-devices Controlled (Supervision of Management and Use) Regulations 2013, amended on 1 April 2020 to the Controlled (Supervision of Management and Use) (Amendment) Regulations 2020 https Il cgc org uklsitesldefaultiles[The_safer_management_of_controlled_drugs AnquaL_update_ 201 gdf they the they this, As drug Drugs Drugs
The level of controlled drug prescribing continues t0 increase year on year. Unnecessary prescribing for long-term treatment can result in an accumulation of unwanted medicines in patients' homes, which increases waste and the associated risks of misuse. Furthermore, patients commonly do not fully understand the risk of dependence on long-term treatment with many of the scheduled controlled drugs and the importance of returning them to a community pharmacy once they no longer need them: To address this: Prescribers should regularly review patients' clinical needs before prescribing and consider the quantity prescribed, particularly when issuing repeat prescriptions; and, CQC encourage healthcare professionals to fully explain patients' medicines at the point of prescribing and supply: This should include giving guidance and warnings of the potential for dependence and actions to take, appropriate to patient need. CQC will continue to recommend and support measures that strengthen the safe use of controlled drugs in all settings to help improve patient safety: hope this information is helpful: Thank you for bringing these concerns to my attention: With my very best wishes, (5etheM1 LORD BETHELL
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 13th February 2020 I commenced an investigation into the death of Laura Eve PARSONS, 36. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 1st September 2020. The conclusion of the inquest was a narrative which found the deceased Laura Eve Parsons died on 5th November 2019 after consuming an excessive quantity of morphine which was prescribed to her, it's toxicity ultimately causing her death. The medical caused of death was; 1a - Morphine Toxicity,Bronchopneumonia 2 - Metastatic Adenocarcinoma Of Tubo-Ovarian Origin
Circumstances of the Death
On 5th November 2019 police became aware of concerns for the deceased and entry was forced to her home address where she was found dead. An empty 500ml bottle of liquid morphine was recovered from a waste bin inside the address. A subsequent post mortem & toxicological examination revealed fatal levels of morphine in the deceased at the time of her death.
Copies Sent To
NHS North East Commissioning Group
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes with this PFD
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.