Linda Sharp

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2025-0468
Date of Report 15 September 2025
Coroner Paul Marks
Response Deadline ✓ from report 10 November 2025
All 2 responses received · Deadline: 10 Nov 2025
Response Status
Responses 2 of 1
56-Day Deadline 10 Nov 2025
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Coroner’s Concerns
Expert evidence was heard which stated that it is fundamentally flawed to conflate a low Wells score with there being no possibility of a deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and/or a pulmonary embolus (PE). A Wells score on its own does not exclude a a DVT or PE.
Responses
Royal College of General Practitioners
11 Nov 2025
The Royal College of General Practitioners acknowledges the misinterpretation of the Wells score in this case and has commissioned an e-learning module to highlight its correct interpretation. This module is aimed to be published for members in the first quarter of 2026. AI summary
View full response
Dear HM Coroner

Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths - touching on the death of Linda Janet Sharp

Thank you for asking us to comment on the matters of concern following the sad death of Linda Janet Sharp who died on the 21 November 2023. Our sincere condolences go to her family and friends.

‘The matters of concern relate to expert evidence was heard which stated that it is fundamentally flawed to conflate a low Wells score with there being no possibility of a deep vein thrombosis (DVT) and/or a pulmonary embolus (PE). A Wells score on its own does not exclude a DVT or PE’

The Royal College of General Practitioners works to improve patient care by encouraging the highest possible standards in general medical practice by supporting members, setting standards, providing education and training promoting research and advocating and representing the College and its 54,000 members.

General Practitioners have a broad curriculum, and the College is responsible for the definitive educational framework for all doctors undertaking GP speciality training. There are 5 areas of capability aligned to the General Medical Council’s Generic Professional capabilities, and these are supported by Topic guides under which is included six clinical topic guides. The clinical topic guide relating to cardiovascular health includes a specific core area on thromboembolism under circulatory disorders.

Venous thromboembolic diseases: diagnosis, management and thrombophilia testing is covered in NICE guidance NG 158 first published in March 2020 and updated in August
2023. There is a visual representation of the NICE guidance ng158 and this outlines the correct use of the 2 level DVT Wells score outlining the concomitant use of D dimer and

Ultrasound scanning. GPs and Hospital specialists would follow this guidance on managing their patients.

We recognise that in this case the guidelines were not followed and the misinterpretation of the Wells score early in the aetiology of the condition, alongside other missed opportunities could have contributed to the circumstances leading to Linda Janet Sharp’s death.

The College has therefore commissioned some internal work through our elearning team to highlight the specific issue of interpretation of the Wells score. We shall aim to publish this to be available to members in the first quarter of 2026 and the college will be responsible for the production and content of the e learning module. We shall promote this through our members network and our regular Chair’s blog which reaches out to all 54,000 of our members.
Minister of State for Defence
15 Jan 2026
The Ministry of Defence has issued an Electronic Safety Notice to mitigate the risk of steering system misalignment and is updating vehicle maintenance guidance for MOD Land Rovers for comprehensive wheel alignment checks. They also clarified the functionality and audit capabilities of the JAMES platform. AI summary
View full response
Dear Dr Sharpstone,

Thank you for your report of 26 September 2025 to the Ministry of Defence (MOD), following your Inquest into the death of Ms Catherine Moore. First and foremost, I wish to express my sincere condolences to Ms Moore’s family, friends and all those affected by this tragic incident.

The circumstances surrounding Ms Moore’s death are deeply troubling, and I have reflected on the findings of your Inquest with great care. I appreciate your acknowledgment of the improvements the MOD has made to vehicle maintenance processes, particularly in relation to steering components, since this tragic event. I have sought additional assurances to confirm that all reasonably foreseeable risks are being monitored and mitigated.

I am confident that the Electronic Safety Notice issued will address the risk of steering system misalignment being missed again. Furthermore, work to update vehicle maintenance guidance for MOD Land Rovers is progressing, and this will provide a robust, long-term solution to wheel alignment checks. I remain committed to monitoring these efforts closely and will continue to seek assurances regarding the safety and reliability of our vehicles.

Your report raises important concerns regarding the Joint Asset Management Equipment Solutions (JAMES) platform, as well as the repair and maintenance of the MOD Land Rover involved. In considering my response, I have sought advice from Subject Matter Experts in engineering, maintenance, Defence safety and the JAMES platform to ensure we have carefully and thoroughly considered your concerns.

JAMES is a complex system, and this complexity stems from the sheer volume and variety of equipment it is designed to manage. It is unfortunate that the platform was not presented or explained sufficiently at the inquest, but I am reassured that the system is fit for purpose for the current, trained user community. That said, I take the concerns you have raised very seriously, and I have addressed each in the addendum overleaf.

I hope this response provides reassurance of my commitment to ensuring the highest standards of safety across Defence. Thank you for bringing these important matters to my attention.
Action Should Be Taken
possibly by making your membership and other clinicians aware of this.
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 17th January 2025, I commenced an investigation into the death of Linda Janet Sharp, aged 70 years. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 18th August 2025. The narrative conclusion of the inquest was:- Linda Janet Sharp first had symptoms of thromboembolic disease at the time of consultation on the 17th October 2023. She had further presentations to healthcare professionals from that date until the 20th November 2023, all which would have been consistent with thromboembolic disease. Had she been referred to hospital after any of these consultations, a diagnosis of pulmonary embolism would have been considered and she would have received empirical therapeutic anticoagulation therapy with a low molecular-weight-heparin preparation pending definitive tests to confirm or refute the diagnosis. Had such a management plan been instituted, she would not have died on the 21st November 2023
Circumstances of the Death
Linda Janet Sharp had significant comorbidities in the form of hypertension, type 2 diabetes mellitus, hypothyroidism, stable angina, left bundle branch block, anaphylactic reaction secondary to penicillin, osteoporosis, gastritis and duodenitis. She also had generalised anxiety and was an ex-cigarette smoker. She attended her General Practitioner on the 17th October 2023 complaining of swelling in her right leg. The WELL's score, which is a risk stratification tool for thromboembolic disease was applied without further testing, that might have included a D Dimer test or Doppler ultrasound study of the calf vessels, and she was reassured and given safety netting advice. On the 2nd November 2023, she was attended by paramedics because of shortness of breath and taken to Scarborough General Hospital for further assessment. Tests for thromboembolic disease were not performed and empirical anticoagulation was not prescribed. She was discharged later that day. On the 6th November 2023, she attended the Emergency Department at Leicester Royal Infirmary due to an allergic reaction, possibly arising from amlodipine therapy. On the 15th November 2023, she was seen by an advanced nurse practitioner at her GP surgery where it was assumed her moderately low oxygen saturation was due to chronic pulmonary obstructive disease, but no confirmatory tests were carried out. On the 16th November 2023, she was attended by the ambulance service and was noted to have initial low oxygen saturation levels which rose to normal limits after a second set of observations had been carried out. She was not conveyed to hospital on that occasion. A further attendance by paramedics occurred on the 19th November 2023. I had accepted evidence from the attending paramedic that if he had known about the previous attendance on the 16th November 2023, he would have conveyed Linda to hospital. Mrs Sharp was seen again in her GP surgery on the 20th November 2023 complaining of breathlessness and haemoptysis. Various investigations were commissioned, but pulmonary embolism which can be associated with haemoptysis was not considered in any differential diagnoses that was formulated. Linda Sharp had a cardiac arrest at her home address around 23:30 hours on the 20th November 2023, but despite the provision of advanced life support by paramedics, who attended, she could not be resuscitated and died at 00:31 hours on the 21st November 2023. I have accepted expert evidence that a deep vein thrombosis could have been diagnosed from the 17th October 2023 onwards and that her various presentations in general practice and to the ambulance service were likely to have been underpinned by episodes of thromboembolism. I have also accepted the WELL's score algorithm employed alone, does not exclude a thromboembolism and needs to be supplemented by other tests. If at any point between the 17th October 2023 and the 20th November 2023, when Linda Sharp was associated with healthcare professionals, she had been taken to hospital, on balance, thromboembolic disease would have been considered and steps taken to confirm or refute such a diagnosis. The suspicion of the diagnosis would have resulted in the administration of a therapeutic dose of a low molecular-weight-heparin preparation, which on balance, would have prevented further thrombus formation within six hours of administration, and with this, on the balance of probabilities, the massive pulmonary embolism that occurred before midnight on the 20th November 2023 and her subsequent death on the 21st November 2023 would have been avoided. Treatment would have proceeded before confirmatory tests been performed according to standard protocol.
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Transfusion Committees and Tranexamic Acid - England
Infected Blood Inquiry
Inadequate Pre-Operative Risk Assessment
Tranexamic Acid - Scotland, Wales and NI
Infected Blood Inquiry
Inadequate Pre-Operative Risk Assessment
Reflection period for consent
Paterson Inquiry
Inadequate Pre-Operative Risk Assessment

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.