Ernest Harper

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2014-0223
Date of Report 9 May 2014
Coroner Ian Pears
Response Deadline est. 4 July 2014
All 1 response received · Deadline: 4 Jul 2014
Response Status
Responses 1 of 1
56-Day Deadline 4 Jul 2014
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Coroner’s Concerns
(1) That it was possible to fall between the safety barrier and the back of the vehicle (2) That details of a passenger’s health and/or mobility (for the purpose of risk assessing the passenger’s safety when accessing and egressing the vehicle) is dependant upon information supplied voluntarily by the passenger and/or his family rather than by a formal assessment
Responses
Bedford Borough Council
23 Jun 2014
Response received
View full response
Dear Mr Pears Re:_Inquest touching the death of Mr Ernest Charles HAPRER Inquest heldon the May 2014at Coroners Court_Ampthill In response to the matters of concern raised in the Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths dated 12 May 2014, write to confirm actions taken by Bedford Borough Council. The matters of concern were described as follows That it was possible to fall between the safety barrier and the back of the vehicle_ 2 That the detail of a passenger's health andlor mobility (for the purpose of risk assessing the passenger's safety when accessing and egressing the vehicle) is dependent upon information supplied voluntarily by the passenger andlor his family rather than by a formal assessment Bedford Borough Council has taken the matters of concern very seriously and am abie to respond to each point io describe the actions aiready taken and those in the process of being undertaken. Concern raised: That it was possible to fall between the safety barrier and the back of the vehicle. Action_TakenIProposed: Devices have been retro- fitted to the doors on all Ford Transit vehicles, the type of vehicle the accident occurred on. This blocks the gaps between the back of the vehicle and the handrail. Dosat

We are now talking to manufacturers and the Driver and Vehicle Standard Agency to see if there are any additional measures that can be introduced to further improve safety. In addition to through the Association of Transport Co-ordinating Officers, we are making other Local Authorities aware of our experiences. Concern raised: 1 That details of passengers health andlor mobility (for the purpose of risk assessing and egressing the vehicle) is dependent upon information supplied voluntarily by the passenger andlor his family rather than by former assessment: Action Taken/ Proposed: redesign of risk assessments is currently being carried out by the Transport Operations Group regarding getting onioff vehicles; these revised risk assessments will be cross referenced to safe systems of work. Generic risk assessments eg transport of elderly passengers, are produced on the Council's health and safety web based software system, AssessNET, with a plan in place to introduce client specific risk assessments. These new controls will be implemented by 14
2014. In the future as any new vehicles are introduced, risk assessments and safe systems of work will also be reviewed to take into account any differences in vehicle design and specification_ A newly redesigned Client Transport Referral has also been devised by the Transport Operations Group, in conjunction with Adult Services_ The form which has been re-designed through consultation with our Occupational Therapists will focus on the person's functional ability and will be used for initial transport requests, as well as requests for reinstatement of the transport service when there has been a break in service due to medical reasons_ This new form will capture information taken from the person/family member and will help to determine whether the reinstatement of the previous transport arrangements are appropriate. The new proposed process also includes a requirement for a client specific risk assessment to be conducted by the Social Care Transport Team for every client who is not ambulant The redesigned referral will be introduced by 14 July 2014. A system has been produced and this will be implemented by 14 2014,to ensure that any information provided verbally by Centre staff to vehicle staff on arrival regarding the client is also provided in a written format The written form includes guidance notes for staff with regard to what type of information must be relayed_ If any concerns are noted during the at a Centre, the centre staff will verbally this information to the transport staff on arrival, backed up with the written form; copies of which will also be provided to the Social Workers and Social Transport Bedford Borough Council has deleted historical information its Routewise forms provided to staff working on the vehicle to make current information regarding passengers clearer to staff. This ensures that the driver and passenger assistant have the most current information on passengers_ this, being July Form form July Day day Day day relay Care Team: from

Bedford Borough Council have taken the actions outlined in this response and have also identified a range of proposed actions to prevent any further deaths through injury from falling from a vehicle. In conclusion, would like to place on record the Councils sincere apologies for this unfortunate incident.
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 11th March 2014 the Senior Coroner commenced an Investigation into the death of Ernest Charles Harper, aged 91. The Investigation concluded at the end of the Inquest on 7th May 2014. The Conclusion of the Inquest was that Mr Harper died as a result of [medical cause of death]:

Ia Acute Pulmonary Oedema b Lower Respiratory Tract Infection c Right Subdural and Subarachnoid Haemorrhage following a Fall which injuries were caused as a result of him falling from a tailgate lift of a small minibus, operated and forming part of Bedford Borough Council’s Accessible Transport Fleet.
Circumstances of the Death
On the 20th February 2014 Mr Harper had been collected from his home address via the Council’s accessible transport - a minibus – to visit the Goldington Day Care Centre. His mobility was such that he used a zimmer frame and/or a trike. Mr Harper was aged 91 at the time. On his return, with the aid of a Passenger Transport Assistant, he manoeuvred onto the tailgate lift using his trike, but fell to his side and off the tailgate, between a safety support and the back of the vehicle.
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Amend GLOS to allow claimants oral submissions at panel hearings
Post Office Horizon Inquiry
Care risk assessment failures
Post Office to engage in negotiations during HSSA appeal period
Post Office Horizon Inquiry
Care risk assessment failures
Require multidimensional risk assessments throughout operations
Jermaine Baker Inquiry
Care risk assessment failures
Amend firearms authorisation forms for risk assessment and tipping points
Jermaine Baker Inquiry
Care risk assessment failures
Draw up maternity risk assessment protocol
Morecambe Bay Investigation
Care risk assessment failures
Audit maternity and paediatric services
Morecambe Bay Investigation
Care risk assessment failures
Pressure damage risk assessment
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Care risk assessment failures
Nutritional screening
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Care risk assessment failures
Reorganisation due diligence
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Care risk assessment failures
Replace Buried Metallic LPG Pipes
ICL Inquiry
Public Infrastructure Physical Hazards

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.