Darryl Souza
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2018-0098
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 12 Aug 2018
Sent To
Response Status
Responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
12 Aug 2018
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Coroner's Concerns AI summary
Compromised visibility at a crossroads junction, despite existing signage, necessitates urgent improvements like renewed signs, rumble strips, and "Stop" signs, but these lack an implementation timeframe.
Responses
Response received
View full response
Dear Mr Shah Regulation 28 letter to prevent future deaths (Darryl Alfred Wayne Rego SOUZA - deceased) Clipston Crossroads Northamptonshire Thank you for your letter, dated 9th April 2018, regarding road safety concerns at Clipston crossroads and with specific reference to the collision on the 7th October 2018, where a male motorcycle rider, Mr Souza, tragically suffered fatal injuries. The information in your report is most helpful in terms of understanding the events that sadly led to this collision and how we, as a local highway authority, can address any particular safety concerns. In terms of context, the Clipston crossroads arrangement is a typical rural configuration found regularly across the UK road network where bends, undulations and vegetation often limit or vary the degree of visibility on the approaches. Advance warning signs and road markings are the most commonly used measures to alert motorists in all directions of travel. Furthermore, the minor junctions are generally controlled by ‘Give Way’ signs and road markings which place an onus on motorists to approach with caution reinforced by an additional requirement in law that precedence is given to vehicles travelling on the main carriageway. Department for Transport statistics from police collision records have established that the most common causation factors at rural junctions and crossroads involve motorists failing to look or judge the path, or speed, of oncoming vehicles. Coroner for the County of Northampton Constabulary Block Angel Square Angel Street Northampton NN1 1ED For the attention of Mr H Shah Assistant Coroner
Soon after the incident our engineering experts attended this particular location and carried out a study of the minor road approach from Sibbertoft (from where Mr Souza emerged just prior to the collision). The current ‘Give Way’ road markings and signage are of regulatory standard. However, a scheme involving the implementation of ‘yellow backed’ signs and refreshed lines is now planned in order to provide an enhanced reminder for inattentive motorists to emphasise the presence of the crossroads and to approach with caution. In order to supplement the signage we will also be introducing a sequence of ‘rumble strips’ in advance of the junction mouth. Due to the close proximity of a nearby dwelling these will be ‘inaudible’ transverse lines placed across the running lane which create significant optical feedback and prompt greater levels of concentration on the approach to a transition in the road. Taking account of the recommendation in your report for the junction to be regulated by ‘Stop’ signs rather than the current ‘Give Way’ controls, our engineering experts have revisited the location to investigate the feasibility of a re-grade. This type of measure is governed by national guidelines and generally confined to junctions where, in the main, visibility is severely hampered. Our experts measured an available view of 95 metres to the left from the junction mouth. This is on the margins of intervention levels but will consequently provide justification for conversion to a ‘Stop’ requirement. We will therefore include this modification in the scheme. Furthermore, the opposing junction is similar in nature and characteristic in terms of available views and the obvious requirement to exercise care. It therefore makes sense to implement an identical scheme and provide a degree of consistency for motorists approaching the main carriageway in either direction of travel. The safe implementation of the proposed measures will require road closures but we have dispensation to incorporate the scheme into our programme as soon as possible and we are therefore currently looking to complete this work before the end of June 2018. I hope these measures provide reassurance that we do take seriously issues of road safety on the county network and are ever mindful that one death on our roads is one too many. Sadly, we know that behind each statistic is a grieving family or someone coming to terms with a life-changing injury.
Soon after the incident our engineering experts attended this particular location and carried out a study of the minor road approach from Sibbertoft (from where Mr Souza emerged just prior to the collision). The current ‘Give Way’ road markings and signage are of regulatory standard. However, a scheme involving the implementation of ‘yellow backed’ signs and refreshed lines is now planned in order to provide an enhanced reminder for inattentive motorists to emphasise the presence of the crossroads and to approach with caution. In order to supplement the signage we will also be introducing a sequence of ‘rumble strips’ in advance of the junction mouth. Due to the close proximity of a nearby dwelling these will be ‘inaudible’ transverse lines placed across the running lane which create significant optical feedback and prompt greater levels of concentration on the approach to a transition in the road. Taking account of the recommendation in your report for the junction to be regulated by ‘Stop’ signs rather than the current ‘Give Way’ controls, our engineering experts have revisited the location to investigate the feasibility of a re-grade. This type of measure is governed by national guidelines and generally confined to junctions where, in the main, visibility is severely hampered. Our experts measured an available view of 95 metres to the left from the junction mouth. This is on the margins of intervention levels but will consequently provide justification for conversion to a ‘Stop’ requirement. We will therefore include this modification in the scheme. Furthermore, the opposing junction is similar in nature and characteristic in terms of available views and the obvious requirement to exercise care. It therefore makes sense to implement an identical scheme and provide a degree of consistency for motorists approaching the main carriageway in either direction of travel. The safe implementation of the proposed measures will require road closures but we have dispensation to incorporate the scheme into our programme as soon as possible and we are therefore currently looking to complete this work before the end of June 2018. I hope these measures provide reassurance that we do take seriously issues of road safety on the county network and are ever mindful that one death on our roads is one too many. Sadly, we know that behind each statistic is a grieving family or someone coming to terms with a life-changing injury.
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you ANDIOR your organisation, have the power t0 take such action_
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 25/10/2017 commenced an inquest into the death of Darryl Alfred Wayne Rego SOUZA aged 26. The investigation concluded at end of the inquest on 23/03/2018. The conclusion was that Mr Souza died as a result of a road traffic collision.
Circumstances of the Death
Mr Souza died on Saturday 7th October 2017 at the crossroad junction of Naseby Road and Longhold Road, Clipston, Northamptonshire as a result of fatal chest injuries sustained when the motorcycle he was riding was involved in a collision with a Mini motor vehicle. Mr Souza had approached the scene on Longhold Road travelling from Sibbertoft. On Mr Souza's approach, at a point 1OOm from the crossroads, the road negotiates a slight left hand curve and at the same location 2 warning signs are located at the near and the off side of the road with attached boards underneath that state "Give 100 Yards" The road then straightens and it is possible to see straight over the crossroads through to the Kelmarsh road. Just prior to the junction, a "Give Way" sign is sited on the nearside grass verge. Faded, but visible give way lines then control the junction The Mini motor vehicle had been travelling on Naseby Road heading from Clipston towards Naseby. Approaching the scene from Clipston, the main Naseby Road leaves the village exiting the 30 mph zone and entering the 60 mph zone that is applicable up to and including (he site of the accident which is 60Om away: The road travels straight for a short distance before it then curves to the left round a slight bend. Once round the bend the road is straight and descends a slight decline towards the scene of the incident: As the scene is approached, the Naseby Road can be seen turning to the left up ahead and prior to this left hand bend, a crossroads warning sign mounted on a high visibility yellow board is situated to the near side of road with a plate mounted underneath it stating "110 yards". "Slow" is painted on the road surface adjacent to the road and although faded is visible. A further conventional cross road sign is situated towards the later end of the curve on the grass verge the near side footpath and again, "Slow" , is painted on the road surface adjacent t0 this sign Mr Souza was sports motor cycle which meant he had a low position in the road_ There were hedges on his approach which obscured his view of Naseby Road ahead. There were windows of increased visibility but these closed down the closer that he to the_junction Mr Souza had slowed to 10-15 mph then almost came to a stop at the the Way the riding got crossroads_ At the junction, the maximum unhindered view of Naseby Road to his left was 79m. A vehicle travelling at the applicable speed limit (60 mph) would cover 79m in 2.9 seconds_ The Forensic Collision Investigator concluded it was_ "possible that when Darryl emerged from Longhold Road, the driver of the Mini would not have time to take any avoiding action Mr Souza sustained serious chest injuries having collided with the A-pillar of the Mini and sadly succumbed to injuries at the scene. There was no evidence of dangerous or excess speed from either driver or rider_ There were no defects in either vehicle that could have contributed to the accident. The weather and road conditions were favourable
Copies Sent To
had his days
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes with this PFD
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Revise signal sighting standard to explicitly consider signal readability
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Define additional time required for reading gantry-mounted and complex signals
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Clarify "very short duration" definition within the signal sighting standard
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Identify and retrospectively review locations affected by "very short duration" ambiguity
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Clarify "overhead line equipment" in signal sighting standard to mean wires and droppers
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Define acceptable limits for temporary signal obscuration in sighting standards
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Explicitly define cab sight lines for signal positioning based on driver's eye
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Railtrack to conduct safety examination of Paddington station layout and operations.
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.