Paul Allan
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2018-0251
Hospital Death (Clinical Procedures and medical management) related deaths
Mental Health related deaths
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 19 Nov 2018
Response Status
Responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
19 Nov 2018
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Coroner's Concerns AI summary
The Community Mental Health Team inappropriately discharged a patient instead of transferring care, and failed to consult required alcohol advisory services, leading to a gap in mental health support.
Responses
Response received
View full response
Dear Mr Caller, Re: Regulation 28 Report Paul Robert Allan (Deceased) Thank you for your Regulation 28 report dated the 25th July 2018, and for bringing to my attention the concerns you had after hearing all the evidence. Your concerns relevant to Pennine Care have been reviewed, and the Trust's response is outlined below_ Concern 1: The Rochdale Community Mental Health Team discharged Paul Robert Allan from their care instead of transferring him to the Community Mental Health Team in Stoke where Paul Robert Allen was moving to. Response: The Trust takes seriously its duties around discharging clients from services in line with Trust approved policies and national guidance. Paul Robert Allen was under The Care Programme Approach (CPA) framework at the time of discharge. The CPA framework was introduced in 1990 as the approach for the care of people with mental health needs in England. Under the CPA policy section 7.11.2 states "All health and social care organisations have the duty to collaborate to ensure proper CO-ordinated care is delivered to people with mental health needs; Each district Local Authority Social Services Department and Health Trust will jointly operate a Care Programme Approach (CPA) Policy: Whilst the detail of local CPA policies may differ the core principles will be the same A objective of the CPA is to ensure individuals most in need of care do not slip through the net of service provision.' very key -
As a Trust we will circulate a reminder to all staff regarding the policy to include how to access the policy and its use in practice. It is a duty of all responsible clinicians and registered practitioners to take accountability for clinical decision making adhering to nation and local policy and guidance. The Trust have also ensured that CPA is included on clinical audit programme 2018/19 Concern 2: The Rochdale Community Mental Health Team failed to consult or work with the and Alcohol advisory services in relation to Paul Robert Allen as it is required to do sO. Response: The Trust has recognised the gap in services for dual diagnoses clients and the difficulties experienced in Rochdale as a result of the commissioning arrangements around Drug and Alcohol services being delivered by third sector organisations As such the Trust has recently been successful in their application for Greater Manchester funding from the transformation fund, to develop new posts to bridge this gap. The new posts will develop and establish pathways between Mental Health and Drug and alcohol services and work with the most complex clients and develop effective working practices. Further development meetings with the operational manager of the and alcohol services and Rochdale mental health services are supporting and enhancing this model: Our Rochdale services also form part of the Greater Manchester Strategic Transformation Partnership (groups of NHS and Local Authorities STP) who will be accessing improvement work in relation to suicide prevention across the Greater Manchester area_ Previous National Confidential Inquiry into Suicides and Homicides work has shown that the implementation of their recommendations was associated with reduced suicide rates in mental health trusts_ The NCISH '10 ways to improve safety' (below, and linked) summarises recommendations 20 years of research that could make a difference to suicide rates in our STP. Identifying which of the '10 ways' could be improved in your STP is the first step to an evidence- based quality improvement plan: The NCISH team would expect to see some of these recommendations incorporated into a locally co-produced suicide prevention driver diagram as part of the Ql plan: The Ql plans should focus on the main priority areas of (1) mental health services, (2) self-harm services, (3) suicide prevention in men: Drug drug from
Safci #ards Scrvicesfor Early follow- P dual diagnogis an dliscirge Loi stal? Nc put-ol-3ica (uover arlmissions 10 ways to improve safety 24-holr Qhutreacn) {@DmS Ellsis ieams Perstnalisedris: Fanly wolvrnient Managemeri "earning Iessons Cuidancen depression At a visit to our STP , the project team will provide bespoke data for our STP and Pennine Care NHS trust; benchmarked against national data. The team will discuss any concerns specific to our local area, and help us to incorporate these into our Ql plans: Services for dual diagnosis is an identified area by the NCISH and project" team that can reduce deaths by suicide Pennine Care NHS is a signatory to the Greater Manchester Strategic suicide prevention strategy and wil be working collaboratively and closely with partner agencies to bring the NCISH recommendations to practice Ihope this response assures you that the Trust takes seriously any concerns that you raised:
As a Trust we will circulate a reminder to all staff regarding the policy to include how to access the policy and its use in practice. It is a duty of all responsible clinicians and registered practitioners to take accountability for clinical decision making adhering to nation and local policy and guidance. The Trust have also ensured that CPA is included on clinical audit programme 2018/19 Concern 2: The Rochdale Community Mental Health Team failed to consult or work with the and Alcohol advisory services in relation to Paul Robert Allen as it is required to do sO. Response: The Trust has recognised the gap in services for dual diagnoses clients and the difficulties experienced in Rochdale as a result of the commissioning arrangements around Drug and Alcohol services being delivered by third sector organisations As such the Trust has recently been successful in their application for Greater Manchester funding from the transformation fund, to develop new posts to bridge this gap. The new posts will develop and establish pathways between Mental Health and Drug and alcohol services and work with the most complex clients and develop effective working practices. Further development meetings with the operational manager of the and alcohol services and Rochdale mental health services are supporting and enhancing this model: Our Rochdale services also form part of the Greater Manchester Strategic Transformation Partnership (groups of NHS and Local Authorities STP) who will be accessing improvement work in relation to suicide prevention across the Greater Manchester area_ Previous National Confidential Inquiry into Suicides and Homicides work has shown that the implementation of their recommendations was associated with reduced suicide rates in mental health trusts_ The NCISH '10 ways to improve safety' (below, and linked) summarises recommendations 20 years of research that could make a difference to suicide rates in our STP. Identifying which of the '10 ways' could be improved in your STP is the first step to an evidence- based quality improvement plan: The NCISH team would expect to see some of these recommendations incorporated into a locally co-produced suicide prevention driver diagram as part of the Ql plan: The Ql plans should focus on the main priority areas of (1) mental health services, (2) self-harm services, (3) suicide prevention in men: Drug drug from
Safci #ards Scrvicesfor Early follow- P dual diagnogis an dliscirge Loi stal? Nc put-ol-3ica (uover arlmissions 10 ways to improve safety 24-holr Qhutreacn) {@DmS Ellsis ieams Perstnalisedris: Fanly wolvrnient Managemeri "earning Iessons Cuidancen depression At a visit to our STP , the project team will provide bespoke data for our STP and Pennine Care NHS trust; benchmarked against national data. The team will discuss any concerns specific to our local area, and help us to incorporate these into our Ql plans: Services for dual diagnosis is an identified area by the NCISH and project" team that can reduce deaths by suicide Pennine Care NHS is a signatory to the Greater Manchester Strategic suicide prevention strategy and wil be working collaboratively and closely with partner agencies to bring the NCISH recommendations to practice Ihope this response assures you that the Trust takes seriously any concerns that you raised:
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you andlor your organisation have the power to take such action.
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
In July 2017 | opened an investigation into the death of Paul Robert Allan. The investigation concluded at the end of the Inquest on Tuesday 19th June 2018. The medical cause of death was 1a. Multiple Injuries and the short-form conclusion was suicide.
Circumstances of the Death
On the evening of 16th July 2017 Paul Robert Allan walked into the tunnel and on to the track at platform West Central Line at Oxford Circus tube station and Paul Robert Allan was struck by a train that was travelling from Tottenham Court Road to Oxford Circus Westbound. Coroners Concerns: The MATTERS OF CONCERN are as follows:
1) The Rochdale Community Mental Health Team discharged Paul Robert Allan from their care instead of transferring him to the Community Mental Health Team in Stoke where Paul Robert Allen was moving to
2) The Rochdale community Mental Health Team failed to consult or work with the and Alcohol advisory services in relation to Paul Robert Allan as it is required to do.
1) The Rochdale Community Mental Health Team discharged Paul Robert Allan from their care instead of transferring him to the Community Mental Health Team in Stoke where Paul Robert Allen was moving to
2) The Rochdale community Mental Health Team failed to consult or work with the and Alcohol advisory services in relation to Paul Robert Allan as it is required to do.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes with this PFD
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Cross-Administration Patient Safety Coordination
Infected Blood Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Central Delivery with Devolved Support
Infected Blood Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Independent review of use of force on mentally ill detainees
Brook House Inquiry
Mental health access for alcohol addiction
Multi-Trust Mortality Meeting Engagement
Hyponatraemia Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Commissioner for Survivors of Institutional Childhood Abuse (COSICA)
HIA Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Establish partner Trust buddying arrangement
Morecambe Bay Investigation
Poor health and social care integration
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.