David Hall
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2023-0382
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 25 Dec 2023
Response Status
Responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
25 Dec 2023
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Coroner’s Concerns
The inquest heard evidence that if a suitable emergency social care placement had been available then Mr Hall would not have been admitted to hospital. However, there was no alternative as one could not be found and he was unsafe in the community. His stay in the acute setting led to a rapid deterioration. He had to continue to stay in hospital because a suitable social care placement could not be found for him. The evidence was that had he been in a suitable social care setting his needs would have been met in a more appropriate way. The evidence was that these difficulties in finding a placement were as a result of issues in availability of social care within Stockport.
Responses
Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council acknowledges the challenges in finding suitable emergency social care placements, particularly for short-notice needs. The Council outlines its existing approach to utilise block-booked residential beds and efforts to improve care market capacity, including dedicated step-down capacity and short-term funding for same-day home care support, while noting fluctuations in demand.
AI summary
View full response
Dear Ms Mutch
I refer to the Regulation 28 Report issued following the inquest into the death of Mr David Hall and thank you for contacting Stockport Council.
In your report you highlighted areas of concern regarding Mr Hall’s experiences and care provision by adult social care, prior to his admission into Stepping Hill hospital on 28 January 2023. Noted as; Died from the complications of poor swallow which developed whilst an inpatient where admission had been due to a shortage of a suitable community placement and discharge was delayed due to a shortage of a suitable social care placement.
Below is a summary of events of Adult Social Care involvement prior to Mr Hall’s admission. Details have been obtained from the records adult social care and NHS hold for Mr Hall. Unfortunately, Stockport adult social care was not made aware of the inquest or identified as an interested party to support the inquest. It is our hope that the information provided in this response is sufficient to highlight the steps taken by adult social care and the NHS providers in Mr Hall’s care. Mr Hall was not previously known to adult social care prior to this intervention.
Mr Hall’s daughter, , contacted the Adult Social Care Out of Hours Team on the 26 January 2023, at 19:15pm. She advised that Mr Hall’s wife, had been admitted into hospital the same evening with a suspected fractured Hip and Elbow. was concerned that may be admitted to hospital, and she would be unable to care for her father during this period. confirmed that was Mr Hall’s sole carer and advised that family would be able to support Mr Hall for that evening. At this point a referral was made by the out of hours service to the Heaton Neighbourhood Team to contact Mr Hall, and his family to ensure a short-term plan was in place to support during this difficult time.
The following day a referral and information officer from adult social care, contacted to further discuss the situation at that time. again confirmed her father had stayed with her the previous evening, but also provided further information in respect of the current situation for
and her father. explained her father was experiencing a deterioration in his physical health, which was resulting in an increase in the care and support he required. This was putting a strain on his wife as his main carer. also described concerns in regard to her father’s memory and cognitive functioning describing an incident where he had tried to leave the property several times and attempted to get out of the property through a window.
Chief Executive Town Hall Stockport SK1 3XE
[Type here]
also described her concerns in detail of how and father were managing in their home, in particular concerns around the physical environment. She went on to describe how she felt was not able to continue her caring role, as the physical and emotional needs of her father were increasing. described how her father’s confusion and agitation was increasing in the evenings. She was aware a medication review had been completed by the community mental health team in the past. expressed concerns that adult social care was not involved and advised that they required respite care for this period. confirmed that she felt that her father required support from adult social care. At the time she also described concerns regarding , as a carer.
further advised that she works full time and that her husband had taken the day off work to care for her father. She advised that they would not be able to continue this and required residential respite care. also advised that, she had contacted the crisis response team. We have no record of the outcome of this contact on Mr Hall’s record.
The same day was contacted by the duty social worker, who liaised with the crisis response team, working with individuals through a multi-disciplinary approach to support people in their own home. From discussions with this team, it was felt that they would not be able to support Mr Hall at that time due to his level of need. To ensure all necessary information was considered to inform any interventions discussions were also held with the community mental health team. They advised they had previously supported Mr Hall, but he was not currently receiving support from them.
The duty social worker then confirmed with that respite care would be arranged as soon as a provider that was able to meet Mr Hall’s needs was identified. She was asked to discuss this option with her father to determine how Mr Hall felt about going into respite care. confirmed that Mr Hall was in support of respite care. Thirteen residential homes were contacted, and there was no emergency respite provision available, the same day. One of the providers was able to support from the following Monday. Enquiries were made to secure a night service for Mr Hall from the in-house provider. Following this was contacted with an update, stated that she was unable to provide her father with support over the weekend and she had contacted his GP. Due to this further consideration was given to support that would be immediately available, but no further provision was found on 27th January 2023.
Following the call to the GP Mr Hall was admitted to Stepping Hill hospital, Mr Hall was admitted on 28th January 2023 due to a urine tract infection, acute confusion, agitation, and pseudo gout. The Foundation Trust records show Mr Hall was identified to move to Hilltop Home, a nursing home for people with Dementia.
This was his discharge pathway from hospital. Unfortunately, Mr Hall was confirmed as Covid positive, on 28th February 2024 which delayed his discharge. Further arrangements were then made to support Mr Hall on 13th March 2023, but unfortunately, he was too poorly to leave hospital as he was receiving treatment.
It is important to note, the UTI diagnosed by Mr Halls’ GP on 28 January was one of the reasons he was admitted into hospital. The impact of this was such that the GP supported a hospital admission.
[Type here] [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [ yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp ype he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he here] Commissioning concerns relating to the Regulation 28 Report In relation to the regulation 28, I have noted below some of the work currently ongoing within adult social care to ensure that we have a safe, efficient, and effective provision of care for our residents. Adult social care discharges its duty under the Care Act with the availability of care and support services, for delivering care and support and avoiding admissions into hospital. This also includes an emergency response when carers are unable to continue in there caring role(s).
We will utilise residential and nursing beds within the community, some of whom adult social care block book for availability.
We acknowledge the challenges in the social care market and are continually working to address these through more flexible, sustainable and outcome focussed services. It is particularly challenging working within the independent sector and the Council acknowledge the services they provide on our behalf and work in partnership to address any gaps in our market. This is a particular issue where emergency step up support is concerned where there is a need to respond at short notice to avoid an individual being admitted into hospital.
We know capacity in the market fluctuates and seasonal pressures can exacerbate the ability to place individuals at short notice. However, we have and are continuing to take steps to improve the capacity in the care market and to ensure providers can support individuals at short notice. For instance, we have dedicated step down capacity that could be flexed to accommodate individuals and have recently utilised short-term funding to provide same day pick up of home care support. The relatively high levels of occupancy in the nursing care market in Stockport provide some sufficiency challenges where there are higher levels of demand for this type of placement. The number of vacancies in care homes in Stockport is currently steady with the longer-term trend being an increase in occupancy. The assessment is that the numbers of beds available in Stockport are generally sufficient to meet the demands placed on the sector by the Council and health partners although this is subject to fluctuations in demand.
I refer to the Regulation 28 Report issued following the inquest into the death of Mr David Hall and thank you for contacting Stockport Council.
In your report you highlighted areas of concern regarding Mr Hall’s experiences and care provision by adult social care, prior to his admission into Stepping Hill hospital on 28 January 2023. Noted as; Died from the complications of poor swallow which developed whilst an inpatient where admission had been due to a shortage of a suitable community placement and discharge was delayed due to a shortage of a suitable social care placement.
Below is a summary of events of Adult Social Care involvement prior to Mr Hall’s admission. Details have been obtained from the records adult social care and NHS hold for Mr Hall. Unfortunately, Stockport adult social care was not made aware of the inquest or identified as an interested party to support the inquest. It is our hope that the information provided in this response is sufficient to highlight the steps taken by adult social care and the NHS providers in Mr Hall’s care. Mr Hall was not previously known to adult social care prior to this intervention.
Mr Hall’s daughter, , contacted the Adult Social Care Out of Hours Team on the 26 January 2023, at 19:15pm. She advised that Mr Hall’s wife, had been admitted into hospital the same evening with a suspected fractured Hip and Elbow. was concerned that may be admitted to hospital, and she would be unable to care for her father during this period. confirmed that was Mr Hall’s sole carer and advised that family would be able to support Mr Hall for that evening. At this point a referral was made by the out of hours service to the Heaton Neighbourhood Team to contact Mr Hall, and his family to ensure a short-term plan was in place to support during this difficult time.
The following day a referral and information officer from adult social care, contacted to further discuss the situation at that time. again confirmed her father had stayed with her the previous evening, but also provided further information in respect of the current situation for
and her father. explained her father was experiencing a deterioration in his physical health, which was resulting in an increase in the care and support he required. This was putting a strain on his wife as his main carer. also described concerns in regard to her father’s memory and cognitive functioning describing an incident where he had tried to leave the property several times and attempted to get out of the property through a window.
Chief Executive Town Hall Stockport SK1 3XE
[Type here]
also described her concerns in detail of how and father were managing in their home, in particular concerns around the physical environment. She went on to describe how she felt was not able to continue her caring role, as the physical and emotional needs of her father were increasing. described how her father’s confusion and agitation was increasing in the evenings. She was aware a medication review had been completed by the community mental health team in the past. expressed concerns that adult social care was not involved and advised that they required respite care for this period. confirmed that she felt that her father required support from adult social care. At the time she also described concerns regarding , as a carer.
further advised that she works full time and that her husband had taken the day off work to care for her father. She advised that they would not be able to continue this and required residential respite care. also advised that, she had contacted the crisis response team. We have no record of the outcome of this contact on Mr Hall’s record.
The same day was contacted by the duty social worker, who liaised with the crisis response team, working with individuals through a multi-disciplinary approach to support people in their own home. From discussions with this team, it was felt that they would not be able to support Mr Hall at that time due to his level of need. To ensure all necessary information was considered to inform any interventions discussions were also held with the community mental health team. They advised they had previously supported Mr Hall, but he was not currently receiving support from them.
The duty social worker then confirmed with that respite care would be arranged as soon as a provider that was able to meet Mr Hall’s needs was identified. She was asked to discuss this option with her father to determine how Mr Hall felt about going into respite care. confirmed that Mr Hall was in support of respite care. Thirteen residential homes were contacted, and there was no emergency respite provision available, the same day. One of the providers was able to support from the following Monday. Enquiries were made to secure a night service for Mr Hall from the in-house provider. Following this was contacted with an update, stated that she was unable to provide her father with support over the weekend and she had contacted his GP. Due to this further consideration was given to support that would be immediately available, but no further provision was found on 27th January 2023.
Following the call to the GP Mr Hall was admitted to Stepping Hill hospital, Mr Hall was admitted on 28th January 2023 due to a urine tract infection, acute confusion, agitation, and pseudo gout. The Foundation Trust records show Mr Hall was identified to move to Hilltop Home, a nursing home for people with Dementia.
This was his discharge pathway from hospital. Unfortunately, Mr Hall was confirmed as Covid positive, on 28th February 2024 which delayed his discharge. Further arrangements were then made to support Mr Hall on 13th March 2023, but unfortunately, he was too poorly to leave hospital as he was receiving treatment.
It is important to note, the UTI diagnosed by Mr Halls’ GP on 28 January was one of the reasons he was admitted into hospital. The impact of this was such that the GP supported a hospital admission.
[Type here] [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [T [ yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp yp ype he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he he here] Commissioning concerns relating to the Regulation 28 Report In relation to the regulation 28, I have noted below some of the work currently ongoing within adult social care to ensure that we have a safe, efficient, and effective provision of care for our residents. Adult social care discharges its duty under the Care Act with the availability of care and support services, for delivering care and support and avoiding admissions into hospital. This also includes an emergency response when carers are unable to continue in there caring role(s).
We will utilise residential and nursing beds within the community, some of whom adult social care block book for availability.
We acknowledge the challenges in the social care market and are continually working to address these through more flexible, sustainable and outcome focussed services. It is particularly challenging working within the independent sector and the Council acknowledge the services they provide on our behalf and work in partnership to address any gaps in our market. This is a particular issue where emergency step up support is concerned where there is a need to respond at short notice to avoid an individual being admitted into hospital.
We know capacity in the market fluctuates and seasonal pressures can exacerbate the ability to place individuals at short notice. However, we have and are continuing to take steps to improve the capacity in the care market and to ensure providers can support individuals at short notice. For instance, we have dedicated step down capacity that could be flexed to accommodate individuals and have recently utilised short-term funding to provide same day pick up of home care support. The relatively high levels of occupancy in the nursing care market in Stockport provide some sufficiency challenges where there are higher levels of demand for this type of placement. The number of vacancies in care homes in Stockport is currently steady with the longer-term trend being an increase in occupancy. The assessment is that the numbers of beds available in Stockport are generally sufficient to meet the demands placed on the sector by the Council and health partners although this is subject to fluctuations in demand.
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 16th March 2023 I commenced an investigation into the death of David Hall. The investigation concluded on the 2nd August 2023 and the conclusion was one of Narrative: Died from the complications of poor swallow which developed whilst an inpatient where admission had been due to a shortage of a suitable community placement and discharge was delayed due to a shortage of a suitable social care placement. The medical cause of death was 1a) Aspiration Pneumonia and COVID-19; II) Dementia
Circumstances of the Death
David Hall had dementia and was admitted to Stepping Hill Hospital as a consequence of there being no safe and suitable place for him to reside when his usual care arrangement could not continue. He was fit and ready for discharge and was awaiting a placement in a suitable care facility. Whilst in the acute hospital setting, he deteriorated rapidly. His nutritional requirements were not fully met and his swallow deteriorated, which led to further weight loss and ultimately to him developing aspiration pneumonia. Whilst an in-patient he contracted covid 19 which impacted his overall health further. He continued to deteriorate and died at Stepping Hill Hospital on 14th March 2023.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes with this PFD
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Arrange emergency temporary accommodation provision
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Domestic abuse accommodation support
Deputy CMO for Children's Healthcare
Hyponatraemia Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
Establish a ministerial Children and Families Board within government
Laming Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
Government inspectorates to assess quality and inter-agency effectiveness for child services
Laming Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
Train child protection officers to confidently challenge other professionals' views
Laming Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
Home Office to actively maintain child protection investigation standards through inspections
Laming Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
Home Office to implement national child protection officer training curriculum
Laming Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
Chief constables to ensure trained detective officers in child protection teams
Laming Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
PITO to evaluate child protection IT systems for police forces
Laming Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
Chief constables to integrate and adequately resource child protection teams
Laming Inquiry
Underinvestment in Children's Social Care
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.