Shaun Hall
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2025-0054
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 27 Mar 2025
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The Urgent Care and Assessment Team declined a referral despite clear suicide risks, with the decision-maker remaining unidentified and no record of the rationale, posing a serious safety failure.
View full coroner's concerns
The assessment from Talking Therapies on 20 November 2023 identified current escalating factors around not being allowed to see his children, and an upcoming court case in relation to this on 14 December 2023. Indeed he stated that if he was not allowed to see his children he would take his own life. Despite all this information being available the Urgent Care and Assessment Team did not accept the referral. Of grave concern is that the identity of the person at the Urgent Care and Assessment Team who declined the referral is not known and no notes were made of the referral.
Responses
Action Taken
Northamptonshire Healthcare Foundation Trust is expanding the use of call handling and recording systems to Crisis Services, implementing a new record keeping audit tool, and enabling full visibility of patient records between UCAT and Talking Therapies staff. They have also emphasised record keeping standards to staff in the UCAT team. (AI summary)
Northamptonshire Healthcare Foundation Trust is expanding the use of call handling and recording systems to Crisis Services, implementing a new record keeping audit tool, and enabling full visibility of patient records between UCAT and Talking Therapies staff. They have also emphasised record keeping standards to staff in the UCAT team. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mrs Pember
RE: Regulation 28: Report to Prevent Future Deaths – Shaun Kenny Hall
Thank you for your Report to Prevent Future Deaths (‘Report’) dated 30 January 2025 concerning the death of Shaun Kenny Hall on 14 December 2023. Before responding to the matters of concern you have included within your Report, I would like to express my condolences to Mr Hall’s family and loved ones. We have carefully reflected on the circumstances surrounding Mr Hall’s death and have identified the specific actions we will take .
Your Report expresses concern about the decision made by the Trust’s Urgent Care and Assessment Team (UCAT) not to accept the referral made by NHS Northamptonshire Talking Therapies considering the information available to UCAT on ‘escalating factors’ and a statement made by Mr Hall that he ‘would take his own life’. Your Report also expresses concern that the identity of the person receiving the referral for UCAT is unknown and that no notes were made of the referral. Responses to each point are taken in turn.
1. UCAT assessments on referral In response to several national drivers and as part of our Trust’s commitment to continuous improvement and learning from incidents, we are developing a range of new risk management processes, including policy updates, changes to risk management documentation and the commissioning of new training modules. Cont’d/… Ref: PFD Shaun Hall (v1) 20250327 Date: 27 March 2025 Email:
Together, these new ways of working will strengthen our approach to the assessment of patients referred to the UCAT and all our crisis and community services. Our new approach will focus on risk formulations that seek to understand the drivers and context behind a service user’s risks, which is a change from our previous risk processes that focused on indicating a level of risk such as ‘low, medium or high’. These changes will provide staff and service users with a better understanding of an individual’s fluctuating risks. As a result, there can be a focus on the development of co-produced safety plans with service users and carers. These safety plans will be owned by the service user and will be responsive to the individual’s own needs and challenges when managing risk.
To support the transition to our new approach to risk formulation, we commissioned a training module from a leading, external provider that brings in national best practice and core skills around formulation and safety planning. To date we have trained more than 140 of our community staff and continue to roll this out across our teams. This represents 80% of the community workforce at this time.
2. The duty of candour of all staff We take our legal duty to be open, honest, and transparent with the people who use our services extremely seriously. We expect all staff to comply with our ‘Being Open / Duty of Candour Policy’ and all clinical staff must complete a Duty of Candour training module. At the time of the incident, we arranged group supervision and spoke with members of the teams involved. We reiterated their responsibilities with regards to the duty of candour. The staff were able to participate in this reflective discussion acknowledging their responsibility and accountability. Additionally, we continue to monitor compliance with Duty of Candour training requirements via our mandatory training programme.
We have heard the concerns you raised and have elected to expand the use of call handling and recording systems within the Trust to our Crisis Services. We currently use a web-based call handling product within our response hub and have begun the process of extending the product into the UCAT services. By the end of July 2025, we anticipate that we will have trained all staff in the use of this product. This product will improve the accuracy of our record keeping and our ability to provide reflective interventions with staff.
3. Record keeping standards within the Trust We expect all clinical staff to adhere to the record keeping standards of their respective professional body and to comply with our ‘Health Records Management and Keeping Standards Policy’. We emphasised the importance of record keeping at the time of the incident to all staff in the UCAT team as a result of our initial learning. We continue to track the team’s compliance with mandatory information governance training and have developed a new record keeping audit tool that ensures governance over the quality and content of records.
Cont’d/…
Having further examined the circumstances surrounding Mr Hall’s death, we have understood the need for a greater level of patient records visibility between UCAT and Talking Therapies staff. We have now enabled both UCAT and Talking Therapies staff to have full visibility of all records relating to the treatment of service users in their care.
Thank you for bringing these important patient safety issues to my attention and please do not hesitate to contact me should you need any further information.
RE: Regulation 28: Report to Prevent Future Deaths – Shaun Kenny Hall
Thank you for your Report to Prevent Future Deaths (‘Report’) dated 30 January 2025 concerning the death of Shaun Kenny Hall on 14 December 2023. Before responding to the matters of concern you have included within your Report, I would like to express my condolences to Mr Hall’s family and loved ones. We have carefully reflected on the circumstances surrounding Mr Hall’s death and have identified the specific actions we will take .
Your Report expresses concern about the decision made by the Trust’s Urgent Care and Assessment Team (UCAT) not to accept the referral made by NHS Northamptonshire Talking Therapies considering the information available to UCAT on ‘escalating factors’ and a statement made by Mr Hall that he ‘would take his own life’. Your Report also expresses concern that the identity of the person receiving the referral for UCAT is unknown and that no notes were made of the referral. Responses to each point are taken in turn.
1. UCAT assessments on referral In response to several national drivers and as part of our Trust’s commitment to continuous improvement and learning from incidents, we are developing a range of new risk management processes, including policy updates, changes to risk management documentation and the commissioning of new training modules. Cont’d/… Ref: PFD Shaun Hall (v1) 20250327 Date: 27 March 2025 Email:
Together, these new ways of working will strengthen our approach to the assessment of patients referred to the UCAT and all our crisis and community services. Our new approach will focus on risk formulations that seek to understand the drivers and context behind a service user’s risks, which is a change from our previous risk processes that focused on indicating a level of risk such as ‘low, medium or high’. These changes will provide staff and service users with a better understanding of an individual’s fluctuating risks. As a result, there can be a focus on the development of co-produced safety plans with service users and carers. These safety plans will be owned by the service user and will be responsive to the individual’s own needs and challenges when managing risk.
To support the transition to our new approach to risk formulation, we commissioned a training module from a leading, external provider that brings in national best practice and core skills around formulation and safety planning. To date we have trained more than 140 of our community staff and continue to roll this out across our teams. This represents 80% of the community workforce at this time.
2. The duty of candour of all staff We take our legal duty to be open, honest, and transparent with the people who use our services extremely seriously. We expect all staff to comply with our ‘Being Open / Duty of Candour Policy’ and all clinical staff must complete a Duty of Candour training module. At the time of the incident, we arranged group supervision and spoke with members of the teams involved. We reiterated their responsibilities with regards to the duty of candour. The staff were able to participate in this reflective discussion acknowledging their responsibility and accountability. Additionally, we continue to monitor compliance with Duty of Candour training requirements via our mandatory training programme.
We have heard the concerns you raised and have elected to expand the use of call handling and recording systems within the Trust to our Crisis Services. We currently use a web-based call handling product within our response hub and have begun the process of extending the product into the UCAT services. By the end of July 2025, we anticipate that we will have trained all staff in the use of this product. This product will improve the accuracy of our record keeping and our ability to provide reflective interventions with staff.
3. Record keeping standards within the Trust We expect all clinical staff to adhere to the record keeping standards of their respective professional body and to comply with our ‘Health Records Management and Keeping Standards Policy’. We emphasised the importance of record keeping at the time of the incident to all staff in the UCAT team as a result of our initial learning. We continue to track the team’s compliance with mandatory information governance training and have developed a new record keeping audit tool that ensures governance over the quality and content of records.
Cont’d/…
Having further examined the circumstances surrounding Mr Hall’s death, we have understood the need for a greater level of patient records visibility between UCAT and Talking Therapies staff. We have now enabled both UCAT and Talking Therapies staff to have full visibility of all records relating to the treatment of service users in their care.
Thank you for bringing these important patient safety issues to my attention and please do not hesitate to contact me should you need any further information.
Sent To
- Northamptonshire Healthcare Foundation Trust
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
27 Mar 2025
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 03 January 2024 I commenced an investigation into the death of Shaun Kenny HALL aged 36. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 29 January 2025. The conclusion of the inquest was: 1a Suicide
Circumstances of the Death
Shaun Hall suffered with mixed anxiety, depressive disorder and emotionally unstable personality disorder. He regularly consulted his GP for these problems. On 2 November 2023 he attended A&E at Northampton General Hospital having taken an intentional overdose of olanzapine, tramadol and paracetamol. On the advice of his GP he self-referred to NHS Northamptonshire Talking Therapies on 13 November 2023. A telephone assessment took place on 20th November 2023. The Mental Health Support Practitioner was so concerned at Shaun’s presentation that she made a referral to the Urgent Care and Assessment Team the following day. The referral was declined. Mr Hall was subsequently found deceased in the grounds of Whittlebury Hall on 14th December 2023 having hung himself. My conclusion was suicide.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.