Susan Paley

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2024-0647
Date of Report 26 November 2024
Coroner Chris Morris
Coroner Area Manchester South
Response Deadline ✓ from report 21 January 2025
All 1 response received · Deadline: 21 Jan 2025
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
A vulnerable patient was left without an accessible call bell, and care staff lack a checklist to ensure essential safety aids are consistently in place for residents.
View full coroner's concerns
1. Given Ms Paley’s significant health problems and very limited mobility, it is a matter of concern that she had been left in bed without a call bell to hand which she could easily reach should she need to summon assistance; and
2. I am concerned that care staff at Hilltop Court do not currently have a checklist in use to accompany them when checking on residents which would act as an aide-memoire / confirmatory check that residents who require any specific aids (for instance bedrails, call-bell, sensor-mats etc.) have them in place as indicated.
Responses
Harbour Healthcare Other
Action Taken
Harbour Healthcare upgraded the call bell system to enable the use of more advanced, infra-red assistive technology. They also use the digital care planning system PCS and have strengthened it by the addition of a PCS training module completed by all staff using this system. (AI summary)
View full response
RegulaƟon 28 Report To Prevent Future Deaths Response to Coroners Concerns into the death of Ms. Susan Paley who passed away on 11th May 2024 at Hilltop Court Nursing Home, Dodge Hill, Stockport Background Harbour Healthcare is a family run care provider established in 2012. Hilltop Court is owned and operated by Harbour Healthcare, it is a Nursing Home offering nursing care for up to forty-six individuals living with demenƟa. Our philosophy is quite simple, we strive to provide an excellent standard of care to our residents, treaƟng them with complete dignity and respect. We like to call it, simply good care. Circumstances Of The Death Ms Paley was a resident at Hilltop Court Nursing Home and was significantly dependent on the care of others as a consequence of complex neurological problems which leŌ her with tremors, contractures and very limited mobility. Whilst Ms Paley had previously reported swallowing problems, the outcome of her most recent Speech and Language Therapy Assessment was normal meaning no modificaƟon was required to her diet. On 11th May 2024, a Healthcare Assistant had leŌ Ms Paley with a sandwich to eat in bed in her room. When around an hour later the same staff member returned to check on Ms Paley, she found her unresponsive. Whilst staff sought to assist Ms Paley and an ambulance was called, an aƩending paramedic confirmed she had died. A postmortem examinaƟon determined Ms Paley died as a consequence of:
1) a) Asphyxia.
1) b) Food bolus obstrucƟon. Ms Paley died having choked on food whilst eaƟng in her bed, Coroners Conclusion At the conclusion of the inquest, the coroner recorded a conclusion of Accident. Coroner's Concerns
1. Given Ms Paley's significant health problems and very limited mobility, it is a maƩer of concern that she had been leŌ in bed without a call bell to hand which she could easily reach should

she need to summon assistance; and
2. The Coroner is concerned that care staff at Hilltop Court do not currently have a checklist in use to accompany them when checking on residents which would act as an aide-memoire / confirmatory check that residents who require any specific aids (for instance bedrails, call bell, sensor-mats etc.) have them in place as indicated. Response to Concern 1 Given Ms Paley's significant health problems and very limited mobility, it is a maƩer of concern that she had been leŌ in bed without a call bell to hand which she could easily reach should she need to summon assistance; AcƟons Taken Harbour Healthcare uses the electronic care planning system Person Centered SoŌware (PCS) and this has been in use at Hilltop Court since 2022 a All residents have a call bell risk assessment in place. This is completed on admission and reviewed monthly thereaŌer or in response to significant changes in the resident’s condiƟon. This was reviewed and updated in June 2024. b The outcome of the call bell risk assessment is then communicated into a care plan which details specific measures to ensure call bell devices, where in use, are working and within reach. c These specific measures, where appropriate, are then translated into planned care acƟons which are communicated to staff via handheld devices. These act not only to record the care delivered, but also to act as a reminder of care acƟons to be completed. Therefore, ensuring call bells are in reach and funcƟoning appropriately. These measures have been in place since the implementaƟon of PCS but have been revised and made more robust in terms of detailed Ɵme specific acƟons to support resident care. d The use of and response to call bells is already a feature of staff inducƟon and this has been reevaluated to ensure clear and comprehensive understanding amongst the staff team. e The above measures are being regularly reinforced during documented supervisions and staff meeƟngs. f Harbour Healthcare have currently upgraded the exisƟng call bell system to enable the use of more advanced, infra-red assisƟve technology. This work has now been completed. Response to Concern 2 The Coroner is concerned that care staff at Hilltop Court do not currently have a checklist in use to accompany them when checking on residents which would act as an aide-memoire / confirmatory check that residents who require any specific aids (for instance bedrails, call bell, sensor-mats etc.) have them in place as indicated. AcƟons As menƟoned above, Harbour Healthcare uses the digital care planning system PCS, and this has been in use at Hilltop Court since 2022

a The assessment of the requirements for specific aids is completed pre-admission and again on admission, thereaŌer these requirements are reviewed monthly or in response to significant change in the resident’s condiƟon. b Once again, the idenƟfied needs are cascaded into care plans and then translated through to planned care acƟons. This is then communicated to carers via their handheld devices. This acts as an aide-memoire. This system has been in place since the implementaƟon of PCS. c PCS is already part of staff inducƟon, and this has been strengthened by the addiƟon of a PCS training module completed by all staff using this system. d The above measures are being regularly reinforced and documented during supervisions and staff meeƟngs. All of the above measures are underpinned by the following Policies and Procedures. a Room Call Policy b Dementia Policy and Procedure c Use of Bed Rails Policy and Procedure d Pre-Admission and Admission Policy and Procedure e Person-Centred Care and Support Planning Policy and Procedure f CommunicaƟon Policy and Procedure g Training Policy & Procedure Regular oversight by the Regional and Quality Teams ensures that the home is operaƟng within the QCS Policy Framework.
Sent To
  • Harbour Healthcare Ltd
Response Status
Linked responses 1 of 1
56-Day Deadline 21 Jan 2025
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 18th October 2024, I opened an inquest into the death of Susan Paley who died on 11th May 2024 at Hilltop Court Nursing Home, Dodge Hill, Stockport, aged 65 years. The investigation concluded with the inquest which I heard on 22nd November 2024. A post mortem examination determined Ms Paley died as a consequence of:
1) a) Asphyxia;
1) b) Food bolus obstruction. At the end of the inquest, I recorded a conclusion of Accident.
Circumstances of the Death
Ms Paley was a resident at Hilltop Court Nursing Home who was significantly dependent on the care of others as a consequence of complex neurological problems which left her with tremors, contractures and very limited mobility. Whilst Ms Paley had previously reported swallowing problems, the outcome of her most recent Speech and Language Therapy Assessment was normal meaning no modification was required to her diet. On 11th May 2024, a Healthcare Assistant had left Ms Paley with a sandwich to eat in bed in her room. When around an hour later the same staff member returned to check on Ms Paley, she found her unresponsive. Whilst staff sought to assist Ms Paley and an ambulance was called, an attending paramedic confirmed she had died. Ms Paley died having choked on food whilst eating in her bed.
Copies Sent To
Care Quality Commission and Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Quarterly assessment of staffing levels against population needs
Brook House Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
Ensure senior manager presence and accessibility to staff
Brook House Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
Staffing and skills mix review
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
Safe staff numbers and skills
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
Responsibility for regulating and monitoring compliance
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
NHS Litigation Authority Improvement of risk management
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Care home staffing levels

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.