Felice Banfield
PFD Report
Historic (No Identified Response)
Ref: 2023-0032Deceased
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Lack of clarity on NIV provision and failure to involve respiratory teams for patients with complex conditions, alongside inadequate monitoring and care continuity, led to missed patient deterioration.
View full coroner's concerns
A lack of clarity about if and when NIV can be offered to admitted patients.
- A patient admitted into RCHT with a respiratory element to her underlying condition was not brought to the attention of the respiratory team. The presenting complaint was not of a respiratory nature and so the challenge appears to be to identify those patients with multiple co-morbidities, one of which has a respiratory component, particularly where the patient is not on a respiratory ward.
- A failure to recognise a deterioration in the presentation of a patient which could have triggered a request for repeat bloods and revealed the worsening acidosis before an AKI developed. There appear at least two elements to this: i) the use of food and fluid charts to make sure a patient is not becoming dehydrated and is having adequate calorific intake; ii) for patients who stay on AMU longer than usual, ensuring there is some continuity in medical or nursing care, so a deterioration in presentation can be recognised promptly. Would there be value, for example, in requiring a patient who is on AMU for longer than say, 48 hours, to become the responsibility of a single, named consultant who will be responsible for regular review starting at the 48 hour mark?
- A patient admitted into RCHT with a respiratory element to her underlying condition was not brought to the attention of the respiratory team. The presenting complaint was not of a respiratory nature and so the challenge appears to be to identify those patients with multiple co-morbidities, one of which has a respiratory component, particularly where the patient is not on a respiratory ward.
- A failure to recognise a deterioration in the presentation of a patient which could have triggered a request for repeat bloods and revealed the worsening acidosis before an AKI developed. There appear at least two elements to this: i) the use of food and fluid charts to make sure a patient is not becoming dehydrated and is having adequate calorific intake; ii) for patients who stay on AMU longer than usual, ensuring there is some continuity in medical or nursing care, so a deterioration in presentation can be recognised promptly. Would there be value, for example, in requiring a patient who is on AMU for longer than say, 48 hours, to become the responsibility of a single, named consultant who will be responsible for regular review starting at the 48 hour mark?
Sent To
- Royal Cornwall Hospital
Response Status
Linked responses
0 of 1
56-Day Deadline
27 Mar 2023
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 25/1/23, I concluded an inquest into the death of Felice Eileen Grace Banfield who died in RCHT on 22/10/21. . The medical cause of death was recorded as: 1a) Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease and Sarcoidosis 1b) 1c) II)
I recorded a Conclusion of Natural Causes. I considered adding a rider of neglect but did not do so on the basis that the shortcomings identified – and accepted – were not gross in the sense they were not total and complete. Nevertheless, I felt the circumstances gave rise to a concern and engaged my statutory duty to make this PFD report.
I recorded a Conclusion of Natural Causes. I considered adding a rider of neglect but did not do so on the basis that the shortcomings identified – and accepted – were not gross in the sense they were not total and complete. Nevertheless, I felt the circumstances gave rise to a concern and engaged my statutory duty to make this PFD report.
Circumstances of the Death
Ms Banfield had a past medical history that included COPD ( felt this was actually Obesity Hypoventilation Syndrome) chronic kidney disease (stage 3) and type 2 diabetes. She used non-invasive ventilation (NIV) at home and brought her machine into RCHT with her when admitted. Her presenting complaint was a painful knee, and the initial differential diagnoses were gout, septic arthritis or a flare of osteo arthritis. Her need for NIV was recognised but following her admission to MAU at 22:20 on 17/10/22, there was a lack of clarity about if and where NIV could be undertaken. As respiratory consultants do not provide an on-call service, it appears to have been decided to leave the issue until the following day when the evidence suggested the matter was simply forgotten. Although presenting with a respiratory element to her condition, her admission was not brought to the attention of respiratory clinicians. On 21/10/21, a respiratory nurse became aware of her presence and took bloods that revealed a mixed respiratory and metabolic acidosis that had caused an AKI. Despite treatment, Ms Banfield deteriorated and died. It was accepted in evidence that this was an avoidable death. The structured judgment review conducted found a poor level of care. There was discussion about the cause for the AKI. While the failure to provide NIV was accepted, it was felt in evidence that the more likely significant driver was a failure to provide adequate fluid and food. Charts to evidence this were not completed.
accepted this had been a problem in MAU for years where there is a rapid turnover of patients and a lack of continuity in medical and nursing care. Information Classification: CONTROLLED
accepted this had been a problem in MAU for years where there is a rapid turnover of patients and a lack of continuity in medical and nursing care. Information Classification: CONTROLLED
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Responsibility for monitoring delivery of standards and quality
Mid Staffs Inquiry
GP oversight of specialist care
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.