Sophia Ayuk

PFD Report Partially Responded Ref: 2023-0022Deceased
Date of Report 20 January 2023
Coroner Graeme Irvine
Coroner Area East London
Response Deadline ✓ from report 17 March 2023
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The patient was not assessed for venous thromboembolism (VTE) risk as per trust policy, and instructions for monitoring food and fluid intake were inadequately followed during her inpatient care.
View full coroner's concerns
1. At no time during the two periods of Ms Ayuk’s inpatient care was she assessed for venous thromboembolism (VTE) risk in contravention of trust policy.
2. Instructions given to monitor and record Ms Ayuk’s food and fluid intake were not adequately followed.
Responses
East London NHS Foundation Trust NHS / Health Body
17 Mar 2023
Action Taken
The Trust has reviewed its VTE policy, disseminated a VTE screening alert, updated new doctors' induction materials, added anti-psychotics to the VTE assessment tool, and included food and fluid chart sessions in physical health training. They have implemented a new nutrition policy, hired specialist dieticians, introduced training on nutrition screening, launched a nutrition and dietetics page, and introduced a dietician referral system. NCfMH has also introduced daily and weekly food/fluid chart checks and a new template for decision making. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Sir,

RE: Regulation 28 Response for Sophia Ayuk

This is a formal response to your Regulation 28 report dated 20 January 2023 where you set out concerns relating to the care of Sophia Ayuk whilst under East London NHS Foundation Trust’s (the Trust’s) care.

I understand that at the inquest into Ms Ayuk’s death you heard evidence from the Trust’s Serious Incident (SI) review author outlining the learning that has taken place as a consequence of her death. However, you remained concerned about the risk of future deaths in relation to the following two areas:

1) At no time during the two periods of Ms Ayuk’s inpatient care was she assessed for venous thromboembolism (VTE) risk in contravention of Trust policy; and

2) Instructions given to monitor and record Ms Ayuk’s fluid and food intake were not adequately followed. I wish to assure you and the family of Ms Ayuk that the Trust has reviewed the issues highlighted by the Regulation 28 report and has planned or undertaken the actions outlined below.

VTE Assessment

I understand that you heard oral evidence at inquest that the Trust proposed the following actions to ensure that VTE risk assessments are undertaken in accordance with the Trust’s policy and best clinical practice:

1) A full review of the Trust’s VTE policy;

2) A VTE Screening and Assessment Clinical Alert was disseminated across the Trust;

3) Changes were made to the new doctors’ induction and junior doctors handbook to include information on VTE assessments;

4) Anti-psychotic medication has been added as a consideration on the Trust’s VTE assessment tool;

5) The Trust’s monthly two day physical health training programme now includes a session on VTE risk; and

6) A yellow card warning was raised with the manufacturers of the anti-psychotic, Zaponex through the Medicines Health Regulations Authority (MHRA) to alert to two patients who have both passed away from pulmonary embolism whilst on Zaponex.

7) The Trust has been trialling Power BI (a data analytics tool) in order to monitor compliance with VTE risk assessments.

Since the inquest took place the following further actions have been undertaken with the expectation that they will improve VTE risk assessment compliance:
1) An Advanced Clinical Practitioner (ACP) has started in the role of Consultant Nurse in Physical Health at NCfMH. She reviews physical health on the in-patient wards. If she has concerns about the physical health of in-patients, including around VTE assessments, she addresses them with staff during daily, morning safety huddles.

2) The Trust’s electronic medical records system (RiO) was updated to include a pop- up reminder to seek a VTE risk assessment if someone’s presentation changes every time nurses update the Observations and Measurements Form.

Since this further work, the Trust’s power BI and doctors task list results have shown that NCfMH’s compliance with VTE assessments has improved significantly.

Food and Fluid Intake Monitoring

I understand that you also heard oral evidence at inquest about the Trust’s plan to improve fluid and food intake monitoring on in-patient wards. The associated actions were as follows:

1) The Trust implemented a new nutrition policy that highlights the importance of food and fluid monitoring for in-patients;

2) The Trust recruited specialist staff to advise on service user nutrition:

a. A Band 7 Specialist Dietician was hired to provide (Trust-wide) nutritional guidance.

b. A Band 5 Dietician post has been approved specifically (Trust-wide) on nutrition. The role is currently being recruited internationally; and

c. The new ACP, Consultant Nurse in Physical Health at NCfMH (as above) will review all aspects of service user physical health including nutrition.

3) The Trust introduced a series of training measures in relation to nutrition on in- patient wards:

a. The Trust’s monthly two day physical health training programme now includes a session on food and fluid charts;

b. A new learning module on nutrition screening is now live on the Learning Academy; and

c. A newly launched nutrition and dietetics page can be found on the Trust intranet with advice and resources for in-patient ward teams.

4) A dietician referral system has been introduced to provide advice and guidance on complex cases.

5) There are on-going plans to add the St Andrews Nutrition Screening Instrument (SANSI) nutrition and malnutrition screening form to RIO.

Since you expressed your concerns in the Regulation 28 report. NCfMH has undertaken the following additional steps to address the issue of staff compliance with food and fluid chart completion:

1) Daily food/fluid chart checks are done by senior nurses to ensure completion.

2) Matrons now do weekly night checks that include review of food/fluid charts.

3) A new template for decision making for commencing/terminating food and fluid chart monitoring has been developed and is in use. I hope I have provided reassurance to you and the family of Ms Ayuk about the learning that has taken place as a consequence of her sad death.
Sent To
  • Department of Health and Social Care
  • East London Foundation Trust
Response Status
Linked responses 1 of 2
56-Day Deadline 17 Mar 2023
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 19th March 2022 I commenced an investigation into the death of Sophia Ayuk age 34 years. The investigation concluded at the end of an Article Two compliant inquest held on 18th and 19th January 2023. I arrived at a narrative conclusion.

“Sophia Abunaw Ayuk died in hospital on 18th March 2023 as the result of a pulmonary embolism. A deep vein thrombosis had developed in her left calf due to Sophia sitting motionless in her room on the day of her death. Sophia's behaviour on 18th March 2022 was due to her mental illness. Ms Ayuk had not taken any food or drink for at least two days prior to her death. Dehydration may have contributed to the development of Ms Ayuk's thrombosis.”

The medical cause of death was determined following a post-mortem examination;

1a Pulmonary embolus 1b Deep vein thrombosis

II Schizophrenia (treated)
Circumstances of the Death
Ms Ayuk had been diagnosed with Hebephrenic Schizophrenia since 2013, her illness was treatment resistant and consequently, was treated with Clozapine. Ms Ayuk had been treated in the community and in hospital to manage her symptoms.

In October 2021 Ms Ayuk suffered a relapse of psychosis and was admitted under S.2 of the Mental Health Act to a mental health ward for treatment. After a period of stabilisation Mrs Ayuk was discharged home but returned shortly thereafter when symptoms returned in January 2022. At the time of her death Ms Ayuk had yet to be successfully titrated back on to Clozapine and consequently, was experiencing symptoms of her illness

On 18th March 2022 Ms Ayuk was observed by staff to remain in her bedroom all day. Sophia sat, fully clothed and motionless on a chair for most of the day. Sophia would not respond to verbal prompts and declined food and drink.

At 20.45.49 Ms Ayuk was seen to emerge from her bedroom and walk down a corridor to the main area of the ward. Moments later Sophia fell to the floor and a patient alerted staff.

Staff made an emergency call for the rapid response team and went to Sophia’ assistance. Ms Ayuk was breathing and conscious at that time. Sophia began to deteriorate and 999 was called at 21.04.

Paramedics responded promptly and on arrival found Sophia unresponsive but breathing. No pulse could be found and CPR was commenced. Resuscitation continued for 90 minutes until Sophia was declared deceased.
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Care planning system
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records Care plan failures
Relative discussions recorded
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records Care plan failures
TVN instructions recorded
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records Care plan failures
Wound documentation
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records Care plan failures
Positional change records
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records Care plan failures
Fluid balance monitoring
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records Care plan failures
DNAR decision awareness
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records Care plan failures
Healthcare trust risk information visibility
Southport Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records
Data Systems for High-Risk Individuals
COVID-19 Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records
Standardised Advance Care Planning
COVID-19 Inquiry
Care plan failures

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.