Emiliano Sala
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2022-0089
All 22 responses received
· Deadline: 13 May 2022
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The market for illegal commercial flights, especially in sports, operates without required safety standards, risking future deaths. The Civil Aviation Authority has limited powers to investigate and prosecute these breaches.
View full coroner's concerns
1. During the inquest evidence was heard that:
i. Emiliano Sala was an international professional footballer. On the 21st January 2019 Emiliano was a passenger in a single piston engine aircraft flight from Nantes in France to Cardiff in Wales when it crashed into the sea leading to his death.
ii. This flight was an illegal flight due to the fact that it was a commercial flight without the required authorisations, certification or permission.
iii. There is a market in the illegal provision of flights for reward on private aircraft or flown by pilots without an Air Operators Certificate (AOC). Evidence was given that this market particularly exists in the world of sport and music.
iv. These flights do not meet the minimum safety standards for commercial operations and evidence was given this could lead to future aircraft crashes and subsequently, future deaths.
v. In September 2019, following Emiliano's death the Chief Executive of the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) wrote to a number of organisations about the risks associated with these flights and the launch of the safety campaign by the CAA. Evidence has been given that all those listed at the top of this report numbered 3 to 18 were written to and none of the organisations responded. I attach one sample copy of the CAA letter to this report. In order to stop these illegal flights and therefore prevent future deaths, it is important that these organisations make their members aware of the risks associated with these flights.
vi. Whilst the CAA do investigate, and have successfully prosecuted, those involved with these flights, they have limited powers in securing evidence to assist in the investigation of breaches of aviation regulations and such illegal flights.
vii. The CAA successfully prosecuted an individual in respect of the operation of the flight which led to Emiliano's death. One of the offences the individual was convicted of was endangering an aircraft. Clearly this is an offence that can lead to death. This successful prosecution relied heavily on evidence that the CAA were only able to obtain with the help of the Police, using their powers under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984. One example of this was the access to phone records and email correspondence from the devices seized by the Police, another was access to financial records seized by the Police. The CAA do not have powers to seize or inspect such devices or records which therefore restricts them in their investigation of breaches of aviation requlations. In circumstances when the CAA are therefore investigating offences alone, they will not have the support of the Police.
viii. The CM investigator provided evidence at the Inquest that without the support from the Police in their investigation linked to Emiliano's death, it is unlikely the CM would have been able to secure the criminal prosecution.
ix. This lack of powers means that the CM are restricted in their ability to access information which may lead them to identify the illegal flights that are taking place. Having access to such documentation is likely to reduce the illegal flights that take place due to the increase in detection and enforcement. Having these powers, and increasing the number of opportunities to prosecute, would also act as a deterrent to such illegal flights being arranged.
2. I have concerns with regard to the following:
i. There could be future deaths as a result of these illegal flights, and I request that the Secretary of State for Transport conducts a review of the powers available to the CM in investigating breaches of aviation regulations. I request that the Secretary of State for Transport consider meeting with the CM to establish what powers they would find of assistance in their investigative and enforcement role.
ii. I further request that a review is undertaken by the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport of the guidance given to the general public, especially all those involved in the sporting and music worlds, about the illegality of these flights and the risks associated with them. I would again request that consideration be given to meeting with the CM who can properly advise on the risks associated with these flights, especially of future deaths that can occur and what support may assist them in deterring people from using these flights.
iii. I would request that all the organisations identified at numbers 3-20 in the list at the beginning of this report, consider cascading to all their members, and anyone else they consider will benefit from the information, the illegality of these flights and the risks associated with them, especially of a future death, in order to discourage the use of these flights. I would again request that consideration be given to liaising with the CM who can properly advise on the risks and what support would be of benefit to reduce the use of these flights and prevent future deaths. ACTION SHOULD BE TAKEN In my opinion urgent action should be taken to prevent future deaths and I believe vou and/or your organisation have the power to take such action.
i. Emiliano Sala was an international professional footballer. On the 21st January 2019 Emiliano was a passenger in a single piston engine aircraft flight from Nantes in France to Cardiff in Wales when it crashed into the sea leading to his death.
ii. This flight was an illegal flight due to the fact that it was a commercial flight without the required authorisations, certification or permission.
iii. There is a market in the illegal provision of flights for reward on private aircraft or flown by pilots without an Air Operators Certificate (AOC). Evidence was given that this market particularly exists in the world of sport and music.
iv. These flights do not meet the minimum safety standards for commercial operations and evidence was given this could lead to future aircraft crashes and subsequently, future deaths.
v. In September 2019, following Emiliano's death the Chief Executive of the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) wrote to a number of organisations about the risks associated with these flights and the launch of the safety campaign by the CAA. Evidence has been given that all those listed at the top of this report numbered 3 to 18 were written to and none of the organisations responded. I attach one sample copy of the CAA letter to this report. In order to stop these illegal flights and therefore prevent future deaths, it is important that these organisations make their members aware of the risks associated with these flights.
vi. Whilst the CAA do investigate, and have successfully prosecuted, those involved with these flights, they have limited powers in securing evidence to assist in the investigation of breaches of aviation regulations and such illegal flights.
vii. The CAA successfully prosecuted an individual in respect of the operation of the flight which led to Emiliano's death. One of the offences the individual was convicted of was endangering an aircraft. Clearly this is an offence that can lead to death. This successful prosecution relied heavily on evidence that the CAA were only able to obtain with the help of the Police, using their powers under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984. One example of this was the access to phone records and email correspondence from the devices seized by the Police, another was access to financial records seized by the Police. The CAA do not have powers to seize or inspect such devices or records which therefore restricts them in their investigation of breaches of aviation requlations. In circumstances when the CAA are therefore investigating offences alone, they will not have the support of the Police.
viii. The CM investigator provided evidence at the Inquest that without the support from the Police in their investigation linked to Emiliano's death, it is unlikely the CM would have been able to secure the criminal prosecution.
ix. This lack of powers means that the CM are restricted in their ability to access information which may lead them to identify the illegal flights that are taking place. Having access to such documentation is likely to reduce the illegal flights that take place due to the increase in detection and enforcement. Having these powers, and increasing the number of opportunities to prosecute, would also act as a deterrent to such illegal flights being arranged.
2. I have concerns with regard to the following:
i. There could be future deaths as a result of these illegal flights, and I request that the Secretary of State for Transport conducts a review of the powers available to the CM in investigating breaches of aviation regulations. I request that the Secretary of State for Transport consider meeting with the CM to establish what powers they would find of assistance in their investigative and enforcement role.
ii. I further request that a review is undertaken by the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport of the guidance given to the general public, especially all those involved in the sporting and music worlds, about the illegality of these flights and the risks associated with them. I would again request that consideration be given to meeting with the CM who can properly advise on the risks associated with these flights, especially of future deaths that can occur and what support may assist them in deterring people from using these flights.
iii. I would request that all the organisations identified at numbers 3-20 in the list at the beginning of this report, consider cascading to all their members, and anyone else they consider will benefit from the information, the illegality of these flights and the risks associated with them, especially of a future death, in order to discourage the use of these flights. I would again request that consideration be given to liaising with the CM who can properly advise on the risks and what support would be of benefit to reduce the use of these flights and prevent future deaths. ACTION SHOULD BE TAKEN In my opinion urgent action should be taken to prevent future deaths and I believe vou and/or your organisation have the power to take such action.
Responses
Action Planned
The ECB intends to circulate communications to appropriate representatives, including a list of steps from the CAA, within one month and emphasize the need to share the information directly with players. All corporate travel for ECB employees and representatives must be booked through the ECB's travel management company Ventur. (AI summary)
The ECB intends to circulate communications to appropriate representatives, including a list of steps from the CAA, within one month and emphasize the need to share the information directly with players. All corporate travel for ECB employees and representatives must be booked through the ECB's travel management company Ventur. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Ms Griffin We refer to the Report to Prevent Future Deaths Issued by Rachael Griffin for the Coroner Area of Dorset (the "Coroner'') on 18 March 2022 under paragraph 7, Schedule 5, of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 and regulations 28 and 29 of the Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013 (the "Report"). In the Report, the Coroner noted her concerns regarding the market in the illegal provision of flights for reward on private aircrafts or flown by pilots without an Air Operators Certificate, which do not meet the minimum safety standards for commercial operations and could lead to future aircraft crashes and deaths, and the particular risks posed in the world of sport. The Coroner invited the England and Wales Cricket Board (the "ECB"), amongst others, to consider cascading to all of its members, and anyone else the ECB considers will benefit from the Information, the illegality of these flights and the risks associated with them (especially of a future death) to discourage the use of these flights. Assessment of risk Since receiving the Report, the ECB has been taking steps to understand the level of risk that currently exists within cricket In order to better understand what communications and information would be of most benefit to stakeholders within the sport. We have summarised below our understanding of the current position. ECB fll1hts All corporate travel for ECB employees and representatives, including England teams, senior management and the Board, must be booked through the ECB's travel management company Ventur. All flights must also be approved by the executive assistant to the ECB CEO to ensure that the appropriate process has been used. The ECB arranges flights on behalf of the vast majority of players or coaches who are playing in The Hundred and the same process applies. If players are already In the Jurisdiction playing In other ECB competitions, flights will not be arranged by the ECB, but the ECB may make a contribution to the flights arranged by the First-Class County or the player. Some players or coaches also choose to arrange their own flights and then claim the money back from the ECB in expenses, particularly If their family are travelling out with them or it is cheaper for them to arrange their own flights (for example using airmlles). Since The Hundred started, this has only applied in a handful of cases and in each case the player or coach was flying with a major commercial provider and not on a charter flight. Before the pandemic, Ventur did not arrange any charter flights for the ECB and since the pandemic only a small number of charter flights have been arranged. Charter flights are only arranged for large groups, of
c.40-50 people. When Ventur arranges commercial flights on behalf of the ECB, It only uses reputable airlines who comply with Civil Aviation Authority ("CAA") regulations and checks are conducted to ensure that Ventur are comfortable with the safety of the airline selected. If charter flights are required, Ventur use ACS (a reputable charter broker) to Identify an appropriate charter. Ventur use ACS as a broker for all of their clients, 19
-= ECB not just the ECB, and have done so for at least ten years. The benefits of using ACS as a broker is that they have an internal compliance team who check the airline's documents and provide insurance coverage In respect of the flights. The airline selected depends on the nature and circumstances of the flight (including availability). ACS usually Identify European airlines to ensure they are compliant with the European safety requirements, or large carriers such as Singapore Airlines or Virgin Atlantic, which further minimises the risks. However, If ACS identify a new airline that Ventur have not used before, Ventur also requests copies of the pilot's licences, aircraft certificates and Insurance policies to get additional comfort about the safety of the flights. Ifa charter flight is organised, ECB legal also review the contract in place with the charter provider. The ECB is therefore very confident that any flights that it arranges for ECB employees and representatives, and In respect of The Hundred, are arranged with legal and reputable providers. One potential risk which has been flagged Is that the ECB arranges for England teams to get to the host nation for any international match or tour but the host nation then arranges any internal flights which are necessary and the ECB has no control over this. The ECB Intends to flag this risk to the members of the ECB executive who are involved with arranging International tours so that they can request details of any internal flights which are being arranged for England teams and appropriate checks can be undertaken. Professlonal teams In the professional game, the ECB raised the issue with the CEOs of the First-Class Counties and they confirmed that there is minimal, if any, use of private charter flights. The only type of journey that may involve a flight would be from one of the furthest away counties to another (e.g. Hampshire to Durham), but that would most likely be ascheduled flight rather than a charter flight. None of the Regional Hosts (the professional teams In the women's game) have flown by charter flight to date. Given the current stage of development and financial resources of the women's same, this is unlikely to change in the near future. Professional players We understand from the Professional Crickets' Association ("PCA") that it Is very rare that individual players arrange their own charter flights, as opposed to scheduled flights. The ECB also does not arrange charter flights for individual players, only commercial flights. As detailed below, after speaking to the CAA, we understand that their main area of concern Is players arranging last minute, ad hoc flights for themselves between small air fields. As far as we are aware, this Is Incredibly rare (or potentially non-existent) amongst cricket players, but we will flag this concern and the points discussed with the CAA when we send out information to the PCA. Recreational teams In light of the position in relation to professional teams and players, we have no reason to believe that any recreational teams would have the resources to charter flights. Communications with the CAA The ECB has also contacted the CAA to discuss Its proposed action further, in particular to understand what support would be of most benefit to reduce the use of Illegal charter flights and prevent future deaths. We spoke to the CAA Assistant Director and Head of Campaigns, , who explained that the key 20
•= ECB risk area, especially In sport, is in people seeking to get last minute, ad hoc, inexpensive transport, often from one local airfield to another local airfield, and that it is therefore important to target individuals to alert them to the inherent risks and ways these risks can be avoided. directed the ECB to the CAA's "Legal to Fly" leaflet on their website, which provides guidance for people looking to hire a flight. The guidance, titled "Everything you need to know about flying safely in light aircraft & business jets" includes asection on how to be sure a flight is legal and safe if it is a flight other than ascheduled airliner. The advice leaflet includes points such as: (i) ensuring the flight ls protected by only using approved operators; (ii) checking the operator is legal by visiting www.caa.eo.uk/aocholders: (iii) contacting the CAA at fod.adinln@caa.co.uk if the company's name cannot be found; (iv) asking to see the Air Operator's Certificate of any company, organisation or individual operating public transport flights as this will prove they meet all relevant insurance and safety requirements; (v) doing your own research if a flight has been arranged on your behalf; and (vi) contacting the CAA at iet@caa.co.uk if there is any suspicion of an illegal flight being offered. The ECB Intends to Incorporate this list and a llnk to the CAA's guidance, into the communications It sends to stakeholders within the game. As emphasised the need to make individuals aware of these steps as well as representatives who arrange flights1 we will make this clear to all stakeholders who receive our communications as below. Next steps We Intend to circulate communications to appropriate representatives of the ECB, First Class Counties, Regional Hosts and the PCA within one month of the date of this response. Further, given the CAA's position that these Issues need to be brought to the attention of individuals, we will emphasise the Importance of ensuring that the information Is shared directly with the players and will ask the PCA to circulate the communications to all of their members and to player agents. As flights for The Hundred are arranged by the ECB, we do not consider it necessary for the communication to be sent to representatives of The Hundred teams but will ensure that the communications are provided to the members of the ECB executive with responsibility for arranging flights for The Hundred. As an aside, we should note that we have not been able to identify any record of the ECB Chair or Chief Executive Officer receiving either the letter from the CAA dated September 2019 or the Report itself.
c.40-50 people. When Ventur arranges commercial flights on behalf of the ECB, It only uses reputable airlines who comply with Civil Aviation Authority ("CAA") regulations and checks are conducted to ensure that Ventur are comfortable with the safety of the airline selected. If charter flights are required, Ventur use ACS (a reputable charter broker) to Identify an appropriate charter. Ventur use ACS as a broker for all of their clients, 19
-= ECB not just the ECB, and have done so for at least ten years. The benefits of using ACS as a broker is that they have an internal compliance team who check the airline's documents and provide insurance coverage In respect of the flights. The airline selected depends on the nature and circumstances of the flight (including availability). ACS usually Identify European airlines to ensure they are compliant with the European safety requirements, or large carriers such as Singapore Airlines or Virgin Atlantic, which further minimises the risks. However, If ACS identify a new airline that Ventur have not used before, Ventur also requests copies of the pilot's licences, aircraft certificates and Insurance policies to get additional comfort about the safety of the flights. Ifa charter flight is organised, ECB legal also review the contract in place with the charter provider. The ECB is therefore very confident that any flights that it arranges for ECB employees and representatives, and In respect of The Hundred, are arranged with legal and reputable providers. One potential risk which has been flagged Is that the ECB arranges for England teams to get to the host nation for any international match or tour but the host nation then arranges any internal flights which are necessary and the ECB has no control over this. The ECB Intends to flag this risk to the members of the ECB executive who are involved with arranging International tours so that they can request details of any internal flights which are being arranged for England teams and appropriate checks can be undertaken. Professlonal teams In the professional game, the ECB raised the issue with the CEOs of the First-Class Counties and they confirmed that there is minimal, if any, use of private charter flights. The only type of journey that may involve a flight would be from one of the furthest away counties to another (e.g. Hampshire to Durham), but that would most likely be ascheduled flight rather than a charter flight. None of the Regional Hosts (the professional teams In the women's game) have flown by charter flight to date. Given the current stage of development and financial resources of the women's same, this is unlikely to change in the near future. Professional players We understand from the Professional Crickets' Association ("PCA") that it Is very rare that individual players arrange their own charter flights, as opposed to scheduled flights. The ECB also does not arrange charter flights for individual players, only commercial flights. As detailed below, after speaking to the CAA, we understand that their main area of concern Is players arranging last minute, ad hoc flights for themselves between small air fields. As far as we are aware, this Is Incredibly rare (or potentially non-existent) amongst cricket players, but we will flag this concern and the points discussed with the CAA when we send out information to the PCA. Recreational teams In light of the position in relation to professional teams and players, we have no reason to believe that any recreational teams would have the resources to charter flights. Communications with the CAA The ECB has also contacted the CAA to discuss Its proposed action further, in particular to understand what support would be of most benefit to reduce the use of Illegal charter flights and prevent future deaths. We spoke to the CAA Assistant Director and Head of Campaigns, , who explained that the key 20
•= ECB risk area, especially In sport, is in people seeking to get last minute, ad hoc, inexpensive transport, often from one local airfield to another local airfield, and that it is therefore important to target individuals to alert them to the inherent risks and ways these risks can be avoided. directed the ECB to the CAA's "Legal to Fly" leaflet on their website, which provides guidance for people looking to hire a flight. The guidance, titled "Everything you need to know about flying safely in light aircraft & business jets" includes asection on how to be sure a flight is legal and safe if it is a flight other than ascheduled airliner. The advice leaflet includes points such as: (i) ensuring the flight ls protected by only using approved operators; (ii) checking the operator is legal by visiting www.caa.eo.uk/aocholders: (iii) contacting the CAA at fod.adinln@caa.co.uk if the company's name cannot be found; (iv) asking to see the Air Operator's Certificate of any company, organisation or individual operating public transport flights as this will prove they meet all relevant insurance and safety requirements; (v) doing your own research if a flight has been arranged on your behalf; and (vi) contacting the CAA at iet@caa.co.uk if there is any suspicion of an illegal flight being offered. The ECB Intends to Incorporate this list and a llnk to the CAA's guidance, into the communications It sends to stakeholders within the game. As emphasised the need to make individuals aware of these steps as well as representatives who arrange flights1 we will make this clear to all stakeholders who receive our communications as below. Next steps We Intend to circulate communications to appropriate representatives of the ECB, First Class Counties, Regional Hosts and the PCA within one month of the date of this response. Further, given the CAA's position that these Issues need to be brought to the attention of individuals, we will emphasise the Importance of ensuring that the information Is shared directly with the players and will ask the PCA to circulate the communications to all of their members and to player agents. As flights for The Hundred are arranged by the ECB, we do not consider it necessary for the communication to be sent to representatives of The Hundred teams but will ensure that the communications are provided to the members of the ECB executive with responsibility for arranging flights for The Hundred. As an aside, we should note that we have not been able to identify any record of the ECB Chair or Chief Executive Officer receiving either the letter from the CAA dated September 2019 or the Report itself.
Action Taken
The RFU cascaded the findings in the Regulation 28 Report to all clubs involved in the Premiership. The RFU also raised this subject at the June meeting of the Professional Game Board. (AI summary)
The RFU cascaded the findings in the Regulation 28 Report to all clubs involved in the Premiership. The RFU also raised this subject at the June meeting of the Professional Game Board. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Ms Griffin, CHARTERING COMMERCIAL FLIGHTS REPORT TO PREVENT FUTURE DEATH We write with reference to the Inquest into the death of professional footballer Emiliano Sala on 21 January 2019, and the Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths dated 18 March 2022 and issued to the RFU under paragraph 7, Schedule 5 ofthe Coroners and Justice Act 2009 and regulations 28 and 29 of the Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013 (the Reaulatlon 28 Report). Thank you for your forbearance whilst we have worked to identify, review and action the recommendations in the Regulation 28 Report, and we are pleased to respond as follows. Having considered which of our members are likely to charter aircraft for commercial operations, we can confirm that we have cascaded the findings In the Regulation 28 Report to all clubs Involved in the Premiership, being the top level of the professional game In England. This is the only fully professional league within rugby union In England. Acopy of the letter which has been sent to the Chief Executives of all such Clubs Is enclosed for the Coroner's reference. We also raised this subject at the June meeting of the Professional Game Board, which ls the forum for discussing principal matters relating to the professional game, made up of representatives of the RFU, Premier Rugby, Premiership rugby clubs, Championship rugby clubs and the Rugby Players' Association. We do not consider It likely that other clubs within the membership of the RFU are likely to, or indeed can afford to, charter private aircraft for commercial purposes, neither are we aware ofthls having happened in the past. It is our understanding that to the e)(tent Clubs need to charter flights for either team travel or other purposes, they are llkely to make use of commercial airlines given the costs involved. We would also wish to add that there are Clubs within the membership of the RFU and who participate in the RFU leagues who travel to Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man to play rugby union. As above, these teams make use of commercial airlines for these purposes. The RFU Itself has a commercial arrangement with British Airways, and the majority of flights used for RFU staff and teams are organised through British Airways. T••mwcrk Ro•pat:I E11Joy1110111 Dl1<1111lno Sputl1111ru1.J1lp 36
Aside from those mentioned above, we do not consider that the Regulation 28 Report needs to be shared further with other Clubs within the RFU membership, as it Is highly unlikely that they would be chartering commercial flights for Club or rugby union related purposes. It is Important to note that the financial resources of Clubs within the RFU membership Is significantly lower than those In Football or some other sports, and accordingly the risk of Clubs chartering the type of flights which the Regulation 28 Report seeks to highlight is, in our opinion, minimal. We have nonetheless taken action and communicated the associated risks to those Clubs where we believe the risk is potentially the highest. Should you have any queries, or require any further information, please do not hesitate to contact WIii Leney of these offices via ~ho will be able to assist. With best wishes.
Aside from those mentioned above, we do not consider that the Regulation 28 Report needs to be shared further with other Clubs within the RFU membership, as it Is highly unlikely that they would be chartering commercial flights for Club or rugby union related purposes. It is Important to note that the financial resources of Clubs within the RFU membership Is significantly lower than those In Football or some other sports, and accordingly the risk of Clubs chartering the type of flights which the Regulation 28 Report seeks to highlight is, in our opinion, minimal. We have nonetheless taken action and communicated the associated risks to those Clubs where we believe the risk is potentially the highest. Should you have any queries, or require any further information, please do not hesitate to contact WIii Leney of these offices via ~ho will be able to assist. With best wishes.
Action Taken
The EFL reissued guidance to all Clubs, which was received in March 2021. The EFL will reissue a link to the guidance in advance of each transfer window. (AI summary)
The EFL reissued guidance to all Clubs, which was received in March 2021. The EFL will reissue a link to the guidance in advance of each transfer window. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mrs Griffin, '1 Regulation 28 Report - Emlllano Sala Thank you for supplying a copy of your Regulation 28 Report, and we are pleased to be able to provide a full update on steps taken by the EFL since the tragic death of Mr Sala and the pilot of the light aircraft In which he was travelling. Specifically, we have been asked to 'consider cascading to [our] members, and anyone else [we] consider will benefit from the information, the illegality of these flights and the risks associated with them, especially of a future death, in on:Jer to discourage the use ofthese flights. ' You have also encouraged us to 'llaise with the CAA who can properly advise on the risks and what support would be of benefit to reduce the use of these nights and prevent future deaths'. We have noted that at paragraph 1(v) of the Report it is said that the EFL was contacted by the Civil Aviation Authority in September 2019 with an outline of the risks associated with these flights. Despite an extensive search we can find no trace of having received directly any such correspondence. However, we are aware that the FA did receive contact from the CAA because this was formally reported to the body established by the EFL, Premier League, FA and Professional Footballers' Association to discuss and agree matters relating to employment of players - the Professional Football Negotiating and Consultative Committee (the PFNCC). The PFNCC agreed that any guidance Issued by the CAA should be shared with Clubs. The guidance was received in March 2021 and was promptly Issued to all Clubs. A copy ls attached by way of reference. A copy of the guidance also remains avallable to Clubs via our 'Club portal' system alongside all other key Information documents that relate to Club operational matters. The EFL will reissue a link to the guidance in advance of each transfer window, so that it remains at the forefront of thinking about travel arrangements for players. This will extend to any updated CAA guidance that may be Issued from time to time. Ultimately Clubs have the legal duty to manage the risks associated with travel for employees and other individuals connected to the Clubs, but by ensuring this guidance remains available (with appropriate reminders) we can at least ensure it remains at the forefront of their minds when planning travel arrangements for current or prospective players. We hope this response assists but remain willing to engage In any further discussions should this be necessary.
Action Planned
The British Horseracing Authority briefed its Board and prepared a draft guidance note to send to its member bodies and engaged with the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA). (AI summary)
The British Horseracing Authority briefed its Board and prepared a draft guidance note to send to its member bodies and engaged with the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA). (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mrs Griffin Regulation 28 Notice • Emiliano Raul Sala I write further to the Dorset Coroner's Regulation 28 Notice, dated 21 March 2022, following the Inquest into the death of Emiliano Raul Sala, and in response to the Coroner's request for assistance to raise awareness amongst racing's stakeholders and participants of the risks and potential consequences arising from the use of illegal flights, in order to prevent future deaths. This response is sent on behalf of both the British Horseracing Authority ("BHA"), the governing and regulatory body for horseracing in Great Britain, and The Jockey Club (cc'd), who also received a copy of your report direcUy and were requested to respond substantively by Friday 13 May 2022. The BHA and its member bodies are committed to ensuring the safety of racing's participants and have sought to work with the relevant authorities to raise awareness across the sport of the serious concerns raised by the Coroner. Following receipt of your Regulation 28 Notice, I briefed the BHA Board at our April meeting on the content of the Notice, including the evidence given at the Inquest that there is a market for Illegal flights using private aircraft in exchange for payment/reward, particularly in the music and spo~s industries. The BHA has since engaged with the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) and has prepared a draft guidance note to send to each of our member bodies, namely the Racecourse Association, the Racehorse Owners Association, the Thoroughbred Breeders Association and the National Trainers Federation, together with the Professional Jockeys Association and the National Association of Racing Staff. The note is designed to raise awareness of the risks associated with illegal flights and the responsibility of participants to check appropriate safety licences and certificates when using private aircraft. The guidance incorporates links to the CAA's own information leaflet and webpage provides details for relevant persons at the CAA where further advice can be sought, as required. We have shared the draft note with the CAA to ensure it is correct and that it makes all the points CAA wish to make and will send it as soon as CAA confinn they are happy with it. We will also continue to work with the CAA to ensure that any further guidance on this issue that they feel ls of importance to racing's participants is circulated in an appropriate and timely manner.
Action Planned
The Department for Transport and the CAA are reviewing the powers available to them in investigating breaches of aviation regulations and what powers they would find of assistance in their investigative and enforcement role. (AI summary)
The Department for Transport and the CAA are reviewing the powers available to them in investigating breaches of aviation regulations and what powers they would find of assistance in their investigative and enforcement role. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Ms Griffin. On behalf of the Department for Transport, I acknowledge safe receipt of your Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths arising from the Emiliano Raul Sala inquest and the unfortunate circumstances which led to his death. I write, on behalf of the Secretary of State, to confirm that, together with the CAA, a review is currently being undertaken of the powers available to them in investigating breaches of aviation regulations and also what powers they would find of assistance in their investigative and enforcement role. It is not possible at this time to say what the outcome of this review will be, only that further time is required to enable this review to be completed and to decide whether any further action needs to be taken and, if so, what form such action will take. Accordingly, we respectfully seek an extension of time until Friday 11 November 2022 in order to provide you with a detailed response in line with your request. If a response is able to be provided sooner then of course we will do so. We would wish to take this opportunity to reassure you that the Department remains committed to doing what it can to deter and prevent illegal flight activity.
Noted
The FA states they were not aware of the coroner's report until it was provided by the English Football League. The FA relayed CAA guidance on illegal flights to clubs and Registered Intermediaries in March 2021. (AI summary)
The FA states they were not aware of the coroner's report until it was provided by the English Football League. The FA relayed CAA guidance on illegal flights to clubs and Registered Intermediaries in March 2021. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Coroner, We refer to your report of 18 March 2022. Unfortunately neither your report nor any letter from the CAA of Sept 2019 was received by the FA as far as we are aware. Your report was provided to us by the English Football League on 27 April 2022. As we did not receive the report, we have also had to rely upon the English Football League for the email address to where we should send our response. The FA does not have knowledge of the practice of illegal flights as described In your report and was not an interested party at the inquest. In the absence of being able to review all the evidence presented to the inquest (which would also require expert advice even if we did review the evidence) The FA is not in a position to comment upon the regulatory functions of the CAA or the extent to which any suggested lack of powers inhibits its function of investigating air accidents and prosecuting where the evidence supports a prosecution. We are able to confirm that the CAA did contact our Customer Services team in April 2019. We then agreed a form of words to be sent to clubs regarding the hire of aircraft. The CAA contacted us again in May 2019 asking that we delay issuing any information because the CAA was updating its guidance. The FA did not hear from the CAA again until January 2020 when we were informed that the guidance on "Illegal Public Transport" had been updated and they would like assistance in circulating the new guidance. We agreed to do so and we were informed a document would be sent to us the following week. Nothing was received and so we followed up with the CAA. The CAA apologised having thought the new guidance had been sent to us. It was subsequently sent to us and it was then sent out by the Leagues on behalf of the FA to clubs and by the FA directly to Registered Intermediaries in March 2021. We believe we have done what we can in this matter particularly given the subject matter and obvious jurisdictional matters but are of course willing to assist further if we can.
Noted
The Jockey Club requires aircraft operating at its racecourses to obtain prior permission, demonstrate pilot licensing, provide aircraft registration and insurance, and confirm whether flights are private or commercial. The Jockey Club and Helicopter & Aviation Services Ltd provide records of aircraft activities to authorities when requested. (AI summary)
The Jockey Club requires aircraft operating at its racecourses to obtain prior permission, demonstrate pilot licensing, provide aircraft registration and insurance, and confirm whether flights are private or commercial. The Jockey Club and Helicopter & Aviation Services Ltd provide records of aircraft activities to authorities when requested. (AI summary)
View full response
THE JOCKEY CLUB Dorset Coroners Office Town Hall Bournemouth Dorset BH26DY Date: 23 May 2022 To Whom It May concern, Re: Regulation 28: Report to prevent future deaths (1) ) The Jockey Club does take the safety of our airfields or landing areas and any customers using these airfields very seriously. All aircraft movements should be booked in advance, with the larger and busier airfields (Cheltenham, Epsom and Newmarket) using Helicopter & Aviation Services Ltd to manage all air traffic, on both racedays and non-racedays and provide advice for the smaller racecourses who occasionally allow an aircraft to land on a raceday if requested. None of our airfields or sites are set up to allow aircraft movements at night. All aircraft operating at Jockey Club Racecourse airfields are required to obtain prior permission to land and demonstrate that the pilot is suitably licensed. record the aircraft registration number, prove they have insurance on the aircralt and are fully briefed for use of the field. Helicopter & Aviation Services Ltd would not allow any aircraft to land which were unable to demonstrate this. All aircraft operators are also requested to report whether a flight is private or commercial and if commercial confirm their AOC number. If it is confirmed as a private flight. we are l unable to insist on their providing this information, we appreciate the severity of illegal or J 'grey' charter in the sporting world and its potential dangers, Where requested, Helicopter & Aviation Services Ltd and Jockey Club have and continue to provide records of aircraft activities that may be of interest to the investigations division of the Civil Aviation Authority, Borderforce and any other relevant authority as and when requested. While we cannot take responsibility for the actions of our customers and their choices of flight operator any more than we can police the legality of those driving to and from our racecourses, we do endeavour to keep our customers informed on the risks and ourselves as an airfield operator informed of their operation. The ,JocKey Club, 75 High Holborn, Lontion. WC1V 6LS I r: +44 (0)2/J /WI I 1800 I E:1nfo@t!1e1ockeyclLH.l,CO.l.lk I VV tl1EJU(lf;ycf,i1>.(0, ,~ 34
I .... THE JOCKEY CLUB I hope that this clarifies our intent to support the CAA in its efforts to pursue illegal charter operations within our powers as a private airfield operator.
I .... THE JOCKEY CLUB I hope that this clarifies our intent to support the CAA in its efforts to pursue illegal charter operations within our powers as a private airfield operator.
Action Taken
The organisation circulated a note to its members recommending that they do not pay for or use unlicensed commercial flights, sharing the concerns of the Dorset Coroner. (AI summary)
The organisation circulated a note to its members recommending that they do not pay for or use unlicensed commercial flights, sharing the concerns of the Dorset Coroner. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Madam I confirm we have circulated the note below to our members: )We have been contacted by the Dorset Coroner following the death of Mr Sala whilst on an unlicensed commercial flight. The Coroner is concerned that unlicensed commercial flights can be dangerous, as they are not subject to the safety strictures of licensed commercial flights. We share the concerns of the Dorset Coroner and recommend to our members (and those they can influence) that they do not to pay for, or use, unlicensed commercial flights.' Kind regards
'\ thairman 1 17
'\ thairman 1 17
Action Taken
The Professional Footballers Association has written to its current members and put information on its website to raise awareness on the issue of unlicensed aircraft, and attached the guidance issued by the CAA. (AI summary)
The Professional Footballers Association has written to its current members and put information on its website to raise awareness on the issue of unlicensed aircraft, and attached the guidance issued by the CAA. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear
Thank you for your letter dated 28 June 2022. In order to provide a fuller response for HM Senior Coroner, we have contacted the other football stakeholders in the domestic game to discern what actions have been taken in advance of the PFNCC meeting scheduled for September 2022 at which this matter will be discussed {having been raised as an agenda item by the PFA). For the avoidance of doubt, the PFA has not delayed in placing this item on the agenda - September is the next meeting of this body where all stake~olders are in attendance. Notwithstanding this, from our investigations we have learned that:
• Premier League (PL): The PL discussed this issue most recently at its AGM in June 2022 and sent a communication to all Premier League clubs following this.
• English Football League (EFL): The EFL has sent a communication to all English Football League clubs. A copy of the CAA's guidance also remains avallable to clubs on the EFL's portal. We are advised that the EFL will re-issue a link ta this guidance in advance of each transfer window.
• Football Association (FA): The FA issued the CAA's guidance to the Premier League and EFL for dissemination to the dubs. The FA has also sent the CAA guidance directly to its Registered Intermediaries. We have written to our current members this week and put on our website, to raise awareness on the issue of unlicensed aircraft, and attached the guidance Issued by the CAA in that messaging (which was provided to us by the EFL). We will ensure that this message Is re-sent In advance of each transfer window, to include any updated CAA guidance that Is issued from time to time. Ta note, we have searched relevant email boxes at the PFA and as far as we are aware, we did not receive anything direct from the CAA in September 2019. We will also add this Issue as an agenda item for the next relevant FIFPRO meeting (FIFPRO is the worldwide representative organisation of professional footballers), so that trade unions from other associations can raise In their respective countries. The PFA was shocked and deeply saddened by the death of Emiliano Sala and would not want to see this ) tragedy repeated. However, as the players' trade union, there is a limit to what we can do as a body to effect change. Ultimately it is very rarely individual players who make the travel arrangements - this is done by the clubs and/or the players' intermediaries. In the case of international transfers, where a player is joining a domestic club from abroad, the player will most likely not yet be a member of the PFA and therefore will be outside of our network until he/she has signed for the club and joined the union (as was the case with Emiliano Sala), To the extent that the football industry introduces any specific rules or regulations on this issue, this will be at the behest of the leagues and/or governing bodies (including FIFA and UEFA, amongst others, due to the international dimension of this particular issue). We hope this information assists and we are happy to clarify any details, should that be necessary. Kind regards
Assistant Chief Executive Professional Footballers' Association 22
Thank you for your letter dated 28 June 2022. In order to provide a fuller response for HM Senior Coroner, we have contacted the other football stakeholders in the domestic game to discern what actions have been taken in advance of the PFNCC meeting scheduled for September 2022 at which this matter will be discussed {having been raised as an agenda item by the PFA). For the avoidance of doubt, the PFA has not delayed in placing this item on the agenda - September is the next meeting of this body where all stake~olders are in attendance. Notwithstanding this, from our investigations we have learned that:
• Premier League (PL): The PL discussed this issue most recently at its AGM in June 2022 and sent a communication to all Premier League clubs following this.
• English Football League (EFL): The EFL has sent a communication to all English Football League clubs. A copy of the CAA's guidance also remains avallable to clubs on the EFL's portal. We are advised that the EFL will re-issue a link ta this guidance in advance of each transfer window.
• Football Association (FA): The FA issued the CAA's guidance to the Premier League and EFL for dissemination to the dubs. The FA has also sent the CAA guidance directly to its Registered Intermediaries. We have written to our current members this week and put on our website, to raise awareness on the issue of unlicensed aircraft, and attached the guidance Issued by the CAA in that messaging (which was provided to us by the EFL). We will ensure that this message Is re-sent In advance of each transfer window, to include any updated CAA guidance that Is issued from time to time. Ta note, we have searched relevant email boxes at the PFA and as far as we are aware, we did not receive anything direct from the CAA in September 2019. We will also add this Issue as an agenda item for the next relevant FIFPRO meeting (FIFPRO is the worldwide representative organisation of professional footballers), so that trade unions from other associations can raise In their respective countries. The PFA was shocked and deeply saddened by the death of Emiliano Sala and would not want to see this ) tragedy repeated. However, as the players' trade union, there is a limit to what we can do as a body to effect change. Ultimately it is very rarely individual players who make the travel arrangements - this is done by the clubs and/or the players' intermediaries. In the case of international transfers, where a player is joining a domestic club from abroad, the player will most likely not yet be a member of the PFA and therefore will be outside of our network until he/she has signed for the club and joined the union (as was the case with Emiliano Sala), To the extent that the football industry introduces any specific rules or regulations on this issue, this will be at the behest of the leagues and/or governing bodies (including FIFA and UEFA, amongst others, due to the international dimension of this particular issue). We hope this information assists and we are happy to clarify any details, should that be necessary. Kind regards
Assistant Chief Executive Professional Footballers' Association 22
Action Taken
UK Athletics has distributed information regarding private flights to World Class Programme athletes, coaches, support staff, and known agents, emphasizing the need to check the legality of flights. (AI summary)
UK Athletics has distributed information regarding private flights to World Class Programme athletes, coaches, support staff, and known agents, emphasizing the need to check the legality of flights. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Madam, Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths issued following the Inquest touching on the death of Emiliano Raul Sala I refer to the letter from of the Coroner's Support Office dated 28 June 2022 enclosing a Report to Prevent Future Deaths dated 18 March 2022. The letter was addressed to
Chair of England Athletics. I apologise that no response has to date been provided to your letter, or to your previous letter to dated 21 March 2022. UK Athletics, the National Governing Body for Athletics in the United Kingdom, is a distinct and separate organisation from England Athletics. UK Athletics was sent the correspondence from the Coroner's Office on 22 July 2022 and has endeavoured to provide this response as soon as possible thereafter. By way of background explanation, UK Athletics is responsible for the operation of the British Athletics World Class Programme, which is funded predominantly by UK Sport. The World Class Programme provides support and facilities for the leading athletes in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. UK Athletics is also responsible for selecting the teams to represent Great Britain and Northern Ireland at International events. Leading athletes also compete at events where their entry is not controlled bv UK Athletics, such as the Diamond League series. UK Athletics also has other regulatory functions, such as the licencing of coaches and Officials and the development of the sport, which we consider less relevant for the purposes of your concerns relating to private flights. I note your concerns. Thank you for bringing them to my attention. UK Athletics will do all it can to prevent future deaths from illegal flights. Having made enquiries, we are not aware of athletes on the World Class Programme taking private flights. While a few leading athletes will earn considerable sums mm
SPORT
from their sporting and linked endeavours In athletics, the sport Is not funded to the same level as professional football, and we are not aware of the use of private flights by athletes. UK Athletics would propose the following action:
1. We will send the enclosed draft letter to:
a. all athletes on the World Class Programme;
b. all athletes outside of the World Class Programme who we are aware will be seeking selection for Great Britain and Northern Ireland Teams;
c. all known agents and coaches of the athletes in a and b above; and )
d. the Home Country Athletic Federations for distribution to any athletes on their programmes where they consider appropriate (although we consider these athletes are even less likely to have the funds to consider a private flight). Many of the World Class Programme Athletes will be taking part In the Commonwealth Games (28 July - 8 August 2022) and then the European Championships (15-21 August 2022). We propose sending the letter (subject to any thoughts you have on the contents) to athletes in mid-September when they are likely to be back in training and not distracted by competition or on holiday. I look forward to your thoughts on the above proposals. Yours faithfully,
Chief Executive Officer mm11 ima SPORT
To: World Class Programme athletes, coaches and support staff Known agents and support staff of athletes on the World Class Programme Home Country Athletic Federations for distribution to athletes on their programmes ( J September 2022 Dear All, Important lhformation regarding private flights I write to you with important information about private flights which you should carefully note. While I understand that it is uncommon for athletes to use private flights and that most of you will not have considered taking a private flight, r would be grateful for your time in reading this important information. UK Athletics has been contacted by Her Majesty's Coroner for the County of Dorset ("Coroner"). The Coroner recently held an Inquest into the death of a professional footballer, Emiliano Raul Sala. Mr Sala sadly died as a consequence of injuries sustained in an aircraft crash. The flight Mr Sala was on was operated as a commercial flight without the required authorisations, certification or permission being in place. The aircraft was chartered from an unlicenced operator. The Coroner has asked UK Athletics to ensure that information is distributed that may prevent future deaths. Two of the specific concerns of the Coroner were:
1. There is a market in the illegal provision of flights for reward on private aircraft or flown by pilots without an Air Operators Certificate. This market exists particularly in the world of sport and music.
2. These flights do not meet the minimum safety standards for commercial operations, which could lead to future aircraft crashes and future deaths. If you are considering taking a private flight, please carry out checks to ensure the flight is legal. If you or any of your team have any questions on the contents of this letter, please contact me directly.
Chair of England Athletics. I apologise that no response has to date been provided to your letter, or to your previous letter to dated 21 March 2022. UK Athletics, the National Governing Body for Athletics in the United Kingdom, is a distinct and separate organisation from England Athletics. UK Athletics was sent the correspondence from the Coroner's Office on 22 July 2022 and has endeavoured to provide this response as soon as possible thereafter. By way of background explanation, UK Athletics is responsible for the operation of the British Athletics World Class Programme, which is funded predominantly by UK Sport. The World Class Programme provides support and facilities for the leading athletes in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. UK Athletics is also responsible for selecting the teams to represent Great Britain and Northern Ireland at International events. Leading athletes also compete at events where their entry is not controlled bv UK Athletics, such as the Diamond League series. UK Athletics also has other regulatory functions, such as the licencing of coaches and Officials and the development of the sport, which we consider less relevant for the purposes of your concerns relating to private flights. I note your concerns. Thank you for bringing them to my attention. UK Athletics will do all it can to prevent future deaths from illegal flights. Having made enquiries, we are not aware of athletes on the World Class Programme taking private flights. While a few leading athletes will earn considerable sums mm
SPORT
from their sporting and linked endeavours In athletics, the sport Is not funded to the same level as professional football, and we are not aware of the use of private flights by athletes. UK Athletics would propose the following action:
1. We will send the enclosed draft letter to:
a. all athletes on the World Class Programme;
b. all athletes outside of the World Class Programme who we are aware will be seeking selection for Great Britain and Northern Ireland Teams;
c. all known agents and coaches of the athletes in a and b above; and )
d. the Home Country Athletic Federations for distribution to any athletes on their programmes where they consider appropriate (although we consider these athletes are even less likely to have the funds to consider a private flight). Many of the World Class Programme Athletes will be taking part In the Commonwealth Games (28 July - 8 August 2022) and then the European Championships (15-21 August 2022). We propose sending the letter (subject to any thoughts you have on the contents) to athletes in mid-September when they are likely to be back in training and not distracted by competition or on holiday. I look forward to your thoughts on the above proposals. Yours faithfully,
Chief Executive Officer mm11 ima SPORT
To: World Class Programme athletes, coaches and support staff Known agents and support staff of athletes on the World Class Programme Home Country Athletic Federations for distribution to athletes on their programmes ( J September 2022 Dear All, Important lhformation regarding private flights I write to you with important information about private flights which you should carefully note. While I understand that it is uncommon for athletes to use private flights and that most of you will not have considered taking a private flight, r would be grateful for your time in reading this important information. UK Athletics has been contacted by Her Majesty's Coroner for the County of Dorset ("Coroner"). The Coroner recently held an Inquest into the death of a professional footballer, Emiliano Raul Sala. Mr Sala sadly died as a consequence of injuries sustained in an aircraft crash. The flight Mr Sala was on was operated as a commercial flight without the required authorisations, certification or permission being in place. The aircraft was chartered from an unlicenced operator. The Coroner has asked UK Athletics to ensure that information is distributed that may prevent future deaths. Two of the specific concerns of the Coroner were:
1. There is a market in the illegal provision of flights for reward on private aircraft or flown by pilots without an Air Operators Certificate. This market exists particularly in the world of sport and music.
2. These flights do not meet the minimum safety standards for commercial operations, which could lead to future aircraft crashes and future deaths. If you are considering taking a private flight, please carry out checks to ensure the flight is legal. If you or any of your team have any questions on the contents of this letter, please contact me directly.
Action Taken
The Institute of Directors included a statement in its 'Influence' email to 20,000 members and posted a notice on its website warning of the dangers of unauthorised flights, following a request from the Civil Aviation Authority. (AI summary)
The Institute of Directors included a statement in its 'Influence' email to 20,000 members and posted a notice on its website warning of the dangers of unauthorised flights, following a request from the Civil Aviation Authority. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mr Parry Thank you for sending me the Regulation 28 Report relating to the death of Emiliano Raul Sala. I JllUSt apologise for the delay in replying to you. Unfortunately, your original email was Incorrectly identified as potential malware and deleted from our systems. I have now received the report and wish to Inform you of the action that the Institute of Directors (loD) is taking to disseminate the findings amongst Its membership. The loD will be Including astatement relating to the report in its 'Influence' email to its 20,000 members 10th on the August 2022. We have already posted a notice on our website as follows: (https;//www. od.corn/news/l11frastruc:1ure/wan,lnn-to-1ocJ-roenibers-concernl11g-lll!!•dangers-of- unauthorised•fllBh ts(). The content of our summary to members Is as follows. Warning to loD members concerning the dangers of unauthorised fllShts Emiliano Sala was an international professional footballer. On the 21st January 2019 Emiliano was a passenger in a single piston engine aircraft flight from Nantes in France to Cardiff in Wales when It crashed into the sea leading to his death. The Coroner's investigation has determined that this flight was an illegal flight due to the fact that it was a commercial flight without the required authorisations, certification or permission. It was also revealed that there is a market in the illegal provision of flights for reward on private aircraft or flown by pilots without an Air Operators Certificate. Evidence was given to the Coroner that this market particularly exists In the world of sport and music. These flights do not meet the minimum safety loD London 116 Pall Mall London SWIY SEO W iod.com/locatlons/london 11
standards for commercial operations and evidence was given this could lead to future aircraft crashes and subsequently, future deaths. The Civil Aviation Authority has asked the loD to publicise the risks associated with unauthorised flights amongst Its membership. It Is essential to raise awareness of this Issue amongst loD members and the general public in order to stop these Illegal flights and therefore prevent future deaths. I hope that this represents a satisfactory response to your request. In the meantime, do not hesitate to contact me if you have further queries.
standards for commercial operations and evidence was given this could lead to future aircraft crashes and subsequently, future deaths. The Civil Aviation Authority has asked the loD to publicise the risks associated with unauthorised flights amongst Its membership. It Is essential to raise awareness of this Issue amongst loD members and the general public in order to stop these Illegal flights and therefore prevent future deaths. I hope that this represents a satisfactory response to your request. In the meantime, do not hesitate to contact me if you have further queries.
Action Taken
The LTA sent a communication to relevant players on 9 August 2022 regarding commercial flights from unlicensed operators, including a link to CAA guidance. (AI summary)
The LTA sent a communication to relevant players on 9 August 2022 regarding commercial flights from unlicensed operators, including a link to CAA guidance. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mrs Griffin Re: Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths We can confirm that, in response to the Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths and in order to comply with paragraph 5.2.iii of such report, a communication was sent out by email on 9 August 2022 to the players that the LTA considers are most relevant in these circumstances. The text of this email Is set out in the annex to this letter.
Action Planned
The Premier League will send correspondence to the Legal, Club Secretarial, and Football departments at each of the Clubs. The Premier League met with Clubs at the Annual General Meeting on 9 June 2022 and raised the issue to the Chairs/Chief Executives/Owners attending. (AI summary)
The Premier League will send correspondence to the Legal, Club Secretarial, and Football departments at each of the Clubs. The Premier League met with Clubs at the Annual General Meeting on 9 June 2022 and raised the issue to the Chairs/Chief Executives/Owners attending. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Sir/Madam, Following my email response of 8 June 2022 to your Regulation 28 Report, detailed below, I would like to reconfirm we are treating this with the utmost seriousness. In orderto most effectively cascade your concerns to our member Clubs, we will send appropriate correspondence to the Legal, Club Secretarial, and Football departments at each of the Clubs. That should ensure that relevant personnel who will be dealing with transfers and travel arrangements are provided with full notice. In that correspondence, we will signpost to the Civil Aviation Authority for further information and guidance. We are meeting with our Clubs at our Annual General Meeting on 9 June 2022. I will personally ensure that this matter Is also raised to the Chairs/Chief Executives/Owners who are attending that meeting. ) If the Premier League can be of any further assistance to the Coroner's Office, please do let me know.
Action Planned
The Confederation of British Industry plans to publish an article on employee wellbeing and safety linking to the Sala case, use social media to amplify the importance of employee well-being and safety, and flag the case to its account managers who manage the CBI's aerospace members. (AI summary)
The Confederation of British Industry plans to publish an article on employee wellbeing and safety linking to the Sala case, use social media to amplify the importance of employee well-being and safety, and flag the case to its account managers who manage the CBI's aerospace members. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear
Reply from the Confederation of British Industry to Coroner's report Ref: 171881 Thank you for your letter to the CB l's Director General dated 21 March 2022 and for the accompanying Coroner's Regulation 28 report into the untimely and tragic death of Emiliano Raul Sala. Section 2 (Iii) of the Matters of Concern section of the report requests that we, the CBI, as a member organisation representing UK business, consider cascading to our members and anyone else who we consider will benefit from the Information the illegality and danger of unlicensed and unregulated flights (as detailed in the findings) in a bid to discourage their use amongst the business community. The CBI will of course work to prevent Incidents of this type from happening in the future. The below outlines three areas where the CBI believes It will be able help in these efforts and commits to take the following action: I. By the end of August 2022 publish an article around the Importance of employee wellbeing and safety on the CBI member facing website linking to the Sala case and the Coroner's findings where public. We wlll llaise with the CAA in the preparation of the article. We wf/1 pass the text on to your office for information once issued. I/. Use the CBI social media account to retweet and amplify to our members and followers the importance of employee well-being and safety, This would be when the article referred to above is published and also should a campaign emerge to raise awareness of the risks highlighted In your report. Ill. Flag this case to Its account managers who manage the CBl's aerospace members in a bid to raise the awareness and prominence of the issue of unregulated flights In the sector. Thank you for reaching out to the CBI and we hope this response plays some part In tackling the Issue of unregulated flights in the UK. If you have any questions on this response, please do not hesitate to contact me. Regards
Head of Governance, CBI CBI, Cannon Place, 78 Cannon Street, London, EC4N 6HN 16
Reply from the Confederation of British Industry to Coroner's report Ref: 171881 Thank you for your letter to the CB l's Director General dated 21 March 2022 and for the accompanying Coroner's Regulation 28 report into the untimely and tragic death of Emiliano Raul Sala. Section 2 (Iii) of the Matters of Concern section of the report requests that we, the CBI, as a member organisation representing UK business, consider cascading to our members and anyone else who we consider will benefit from the Information the illegality and danger of unlicensed and unregulated flights (as detailed in the findings) in a bid to discourage their use amongst the business community. The CBI will of course work to prevent Incidents of this type from happening in the future. The below outlines three areas where the CBI believes It will be able help in these efforts and commits to take the following action: I. By the end of August 2022 publish an article around the Importance of employee wellbeing and safety on the CBI member facing website linking to the Sala case and the Coroner's findings where public. We wlll llaise with the CAA in the preparation of the article. We wf/1 pass the text on to your office for information once issued. I/. Use the CBI social media account to retweet and amplify to our members and followers the importance of employee well-being and safety, This would be when the article referred to above is published and also should a campaign emerge to raise awareness of the risks highlighted In your report. Ill. Flag this case to Its account managers who manage the CBl's aerospace members in a bid to raise the awareness and prominence of the issue of unregulated flights In the sector. Thank you for reaching out to the CBI and we hope this response plays some part In tackling the Issue of unregulated flights in the UK. If you have any questions on this response, please do not hesitate to contact me. Regards
Head of Governance, CBI CBI, Cannon Place, 78 Cannon Street, London, EC4N 6HN 16
Action Taken
The Rugby Football League wrote to all member clubs advising them of the situation regarding private flights and asking them to ensure they do not use such flights. (AI summary)
The Rugby Football League wrote to all member clubs advising them of the situation regarding private flights and asking them to ensure they do not use such flights. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Sirs Resulatlon 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths Inquest touchlns the death of Emiliano Raul Sala I have been passed your correspondence relating to this matter and apologise for the delay in writing to you. I know that you have contacted my colleague and left a volcemall. I returned that call at 3.25 today and have left a message. I am more than happy to talk with you If necessary. I think there has been some issue with the Report to Prevent Future Deaths being served upon us. However, I can confirm that we have considered the RPFD and actioned the requests of HM Coroner. Rugby League is a sport that does not use such flights as mentioned in this case but we have still written to all our member Clubs advising them of the situation and asking that they ensure that wherever they do not sue such flights., We would also be happy to meet with the relevant authorities. We informed all our Clubs of this within 7 days of receiving the RPFD and ensured It was circulated to the relevant decision maker at the Club and to the CEO. I trust this information is sufficient but would be happy to discuss with you on a call. Again we apologise for the delay In formally responding •
Action Taken
The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport shared CAA guidance with sports organisations, Live music Industry Venues & Entertainment (LIVE), the Music Venues Trust (MVT), and the Musicians' Union. (AI summary)
The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport shared CAA guidance with sports organisations, Live music Industry Venues & Entertainment (LIVE), the Music Venues Trust (MVT), and the Musicians' Union. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Ms Griffin, Thank you for your email sending the Regulation 28 Notice for the Prevention of Future Deaths in relation to Emiliano Sala. This was initially sent to Rt Hon Nadine Dorries MP's Parliamentary Mailbox. As this is separate to the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS), we were only made aware of the recommendation for the Department at the beginning of last month, hence the gap between the publication of the report and this response. With regard to your recommendation, the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) is responsible for the regulation of aviation safety in the United Kingdom, and Ministerial responsibility lies with the Department for Transport (Off). Therefore, it would not be appropriate for DCMS to conduct a review of aviation guidance. You will be aware that the DIT are currently reviewing the powers available to the CAA in investigating breaches of aviation regulations. However, in light of your recommendation, we have discussed this case with the DIT and CAA to assess the most relevant guidance for those involved in sport and music. The CAA recommended their latest guidance alongside a leaflet with further information. We have shared these with the sports organisations your Regulation 28 report was sent to for dissemination to anyone who may be chartering a private flight, as well as Live music Industry Venues & Entertainment (LIVE), the Music Venues Trust (MVT), and the Musicians' Union. In our view, this fulfils your recommendation to DCMS by ensuring the sport and music industries are fully aware of the measures they should be taking to ensure all flights are safe and legal,
Action Taken
The RFU requested Premiership clubs review the PFD report on commercial flight chartering and ensure flights are legal and have required authorisations, certifications and permissions, and pass the information to relevant employees. (AI summary)
The RFU requested Premiership clubs review the PFD report on commercial flight chartering and ensure flights are legal and have required authorisations, certifications and permissions, and pass the information to relevant employees. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Chief Executive, CORONER REPORT TO PREVENT FUTURE DEATH-CHARTERING COMMERCIAL FLIGHTS I am writing following the Inquest into the death of professional footballer Emiliano Sala on 21 January 2019, which has been undertaken by Rachael Griffin, Senior Coroner for the Coroner Area of Dorset (the Inquest). Mr Sala was found to have died as a result of injuries caused by a high energy aircraft crash whilst flying between Nantes to Cardiff, As a result of the Inquest, the RFU, together with other sporting bodies, has been served with a report by the Coroner known as a Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths (the PFD Report), a copy of which is enclosed. The Coroner concluded that the illegal provision of flights for reward on private aircraft, or flown by pilots without an air operators' certificate was particularly prevalent in the sport and music industries and therefore requires those to whom she sent the PFD Report to pass this to relevant stakeholders. This was discussed at the Professional Game Board, and although clearly flights such as these are likely to be far more prevalent in other sports such as football, there may be some relevance to professional rugby clubs In England. The purpose of this letter is therefore to request that you review the PFD report so that you are aware of the risks associated with flights such as these and to ensure, In the event commercial flights are chartered by Clubs (for away games or otherwise), that due consideration is given to ensuring that such flights are legal and have ) in place all required authorisations, certifications and permissions. We would be grateful If you would pass this letter and its enclosure to the attention of all employees within your Club who may be Involved in procuring or organising commercial flights for Club operations. If you had any queries or concerns in relation to the PFD Report, or regarding using commercial charter flights generally, we would suggest that a first port of call is the Clvil Aviation Authority.
Action Taken
The British Chambers of Commerce circulated briefing materials to its Chamber of Commerce members, raised the issue in a call with Chamber of Commerce CEOs, and highlighted the importance of taking action at the BCC Board. (AI summary)
The British Chambers of Commerce circulated briefing materials to its Chamber of Commerce members, raised the issue in a call with Chamber of Commerce CEOs, and highlighted the importance of taking action at the BCC Board. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mrs. Griffin I am writing to you in my capacity as President, British Chamber of Commerce, in response to your report into the tragic death of the footballer Emiliano Raul Sala. Our organisation represents the 53 Accredited Chambers which make up our UK network. Together, we represent tens ofthousands of businesses ofall shapes and sizes, which employ almost six million people across the UK. We also have a international Network with 77 British Chambers of Commerce and business groups located in every continent of the world and directly linked to UK-based Chambers of Commerce. Your report called upon our organisation to make members aware of the risks associated with taking flights which are not operated by an individual holding an Air Operators Certificate. Following receipt of your letter we have carried out the following actions:
• Our staff have circulated briefing materials to our Chamber of Commerce members so that they can make their members aware of the issues (please see Appendix). This text was taken directly from the Civil Aviation Authority's campaign materials on this issue and was issued following consultation with the Airport Operators' Association.
• Our Executive Director has raised this issue in a call with our network ofChamber of Commerce CEOs and asked them to disseminate the information below through their Chamber membership networks.
• I personally raised this point at the the BCC Board in March to stress the importance of taking action on this matter. I trust that this meets our obligation to make members aware of these risks, and I thank you for bringing this matter to our attention.
• Our staff have circulated briefing materials to our Chamber of Commerce members so that they can make their members aware of the issues (please see Appendix). This text was taken directly from the Civil Aviation Authority's campaign materials on this issue and was issued following consultation with the Airport Operators' Association.
• Our Executive Director has raised this issue in a call with our network ofChamber of Commerce CEOs and asked them to disseminate the information below through their Chamber membership networks.
• I personally raised this point at the the BCC Board in March to stress the importance of taking action on this matter. I trust that this meets our obligation to make members aware of these risks, and I thank you for bringing this matter to our attention.
Action Planned
Motorsport UK will publish advice to its license holders on its website and in its monthly ezine regarding air-worthiness of chartered aircraft and pilot qualifications. (AI summary)
Motorsport UK will publish advice to its license holders on its website and in its monthly ezine regarding air-worthiness of chartered aircraft and pilot qualifications. (AI summary)
View full response
From: Sent: Tue Jun 14 15:50:28 BST 2022
Subject: Re: Emiliano Raul Sala (ref: 171881) FORMAL RESPONSE OF MOTORSPORT UK ASSOCIATION LIMITED ('MOTORSPORT UK') TO REGULATION 28 REPORT ('the Report') IN THE ABOVE MATTER Motorsport UK is the UK national sporting authority of 4+wheeled motorsport, recognised by FIA (World Governing Body) and recognised by UK Statute for the purposes of the Road Traffic Acts and related Regulations ('ASN'). Motorsport UK as ASN acknowledges the factual premise of the Report in the above matter and the seriousness of the issues raised, notwithstanding that independently arranged travel of Competitors (Entrants and Drivers) and Officials is outside the direct remit of the ASN and that ASN does not make such arrangements. In light of the Report, the ASN will so soon as practicable publish advice to its License holders by means of clear notice on its website and in its monthly ezlne 1Revolution' relating to and drawing attention to the concerns raised by the Report regarding air- worthiness of privately chartered aircraft and the qualifications verification of pilots contracted to provide the services together with recommendation to refer to the CAA in the event of any doubt or concerns. I trust this is sufficient for your purposes and thank you for bringing the matter to our attention. Regards
Regulatory Counsel & Disciplinary Officer O motorsport UK
Subject: Re: Emiliano Raul Sala (ref: 171881) FORMAL RESPONSE OF MOTORSPORT UK ASSOCIATION LIMITED ('MOTORSPORT UK') TO REGULATION 28 REPORT ('the Report') IN THE ABOVE MATTER Motorsport UK is the UK national sporting authority of 4+wheeled motorsport, recognised by FIA (World Governing Body) and recognised by UK Statute for the purposes of the Road Traffic Acts and related Regulations ('ASN'). Motorsport UK as ASN acknowledges the factual premise of the Report in the above matter and the seriousness of the issues raised, notwithstanding that independently arranged travel of Competitors (Entrants and Drivers) and Officials is outside the direct remit of the ASN and that ASN does not make such arrangements. In light of the Report, the ASN will so soon as practicable publish advice to its License holders by means of clear notice on its website and in its monthly ezlne 1Revolution' relating to and drawing attention to the concerns raised by the Report regarding air- worthiness of privately chartered aircraft and the qualifications verification of pilots contracted to provide the services together with recommendation to refer to the CAA in the event of any doubt or concerns. I trust this is sufficient for your purposes and thank you for bringing the matter to our attention. Regards
Regulatory Counsel & Disciplinary Officer O motorsport UK
Noted
The Executive Association of Great Britain stated that the report and concerns are not applicable to their particular circumstances as they do not arrange travel for members, and members do not travel by air to attend meetings. (AI summary)
The Executive Association of Great Britain stated that the report and concerns are not applicable to their particular circumstances as they do not arrange travel for members, and members do not travel by air to attend meetings. (AI summary)
View full response
Coroner's Support Team Coroner's Office
11 th August 2022 Subject: Emlllano Raul Sala - Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths (ref: 171881) ) Ms
Thank you for your email and the earlier copy of the Regulation 28 Report to prevent Future Deaths. I am the Chairman of the Executive Association of Great Britain which is networking group in London that meets once a month. We do not arrange the travel for any of the members or the guests to our meetings. In addition none of our members travel by air to attend the monthly meetings. I believe that the report and concerns about the air travel provided by an unlicensed operator are not applicable to our particular circumstances.
11 th August 2022 Subject: Emlllano Raul Sala - Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths (ref: 171881) ) Ms
Thank you for your email and the earlier copy of the Regulation 28 Report to prevent Future Deaths. I am the Chairman of the Executive Association of Great Britain which is networking group in London that meets once a month. We do not arrange the travel for any of the members or the guests to our meetings. In addition none of our members travel by air to attend the monthly meetings. I believe that the report and concerns about the air travel provided by an unlicensed operator are not applicable to our particular circumstances.
Noted
UK Sport asserts that the use of illegal private plane journeys is not permitted with their funding and that the risk of government funded sports using them is minimal. (AI summary)
UK Sport asserts that the use of illegal private plane journeys is not permitted with their funding and that the risk of government funded sports using them is minimal. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Ms Griffin, Thank you for providing us with a copy of the Coroner's Report which we have duly reviewed. Firstly, we would like to apologise for not responding within deadline and thank you for agreeing to extend the deadline for response to Thursday. We appreciate the importance of this work and fully understand the seriousness of the points raised, and may we therefore take this opportunity to extend our thanks for the work being done In respect of this very important issue. UK Sport can confirm that use of illegal private plane journeys are not permitted with funding provided by us to any of the sports or athletes that we invest in, and therefore no action will be taken by UK Sport at this stage. Unlike with professional sports, it is extremely unlikely that our government funded sports are able to afford such journeys and so in reality the risk of illegal private plane hire is minimal. This conclusion has been drawn after discussion with the Department for Digital, Culture Media and Sport, our governmental body, who have in turn liaised with the Department of Transport on this matter. I trust the above is helpful but please do not hesitate to contact me with any queries or for more information.
Noted
The EFL circulated a CAA notice to club secretaries raising awareness of the risks of illegal public transport using unlicensed aircraft. (AI summary)
The EFL circulated a CAA notice to club secretaries raising awareness of the risks of illegal public transport using unlicensed aircraft. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Secretary The Civil Aviation Authority ('CAA') wishes to raise awareness around the risks of illegal public transport using unlicensed aircraft for commercial purposes. The use of such aircraft is a risk to the safety of passengers carried. The CAA has updated it guidance material and reminds the users of aircraft being charted commercially that the operator Is required to hold an Air Operators Certificate, this means that they are properly regulated and operate to Internationally recognised safety standards. If an aircraft Is operated on a commercial basis outside of these regulations then It Is likely that the fllght will be illegal and that any Insurance could be invalidated. If anybody has any specific questions on this matter, then they are Invited to make contact with the CAA who can give further advice If needed, either through the e-mail addresses in the attached or through the CAA's website which can be found at:
Best wishes
Head of Player Admlnstration EFL Please note our offices are now closed and all staff are working from home - please contact us via telephone and emall only, documents should not be posted. 25
Best wishes
Head of Player Admlnstration EFL Please note our offices are now closed and all staff are working from home - please contact us via telephone and emall only, documents should not be posted. 25
Sent To
- Department for Culture, Media and Sport
- Department for Transport
- Football Association
- Rugby Football League
- Rugby Football Union
- UK Sport
Response Status
Linked responses
22 of 20
56-Day Deadline
13 May 2022
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 8th February 2019 an investigation was commenced into the death of Emiliano Raul Sala, born on the 3pt October 1990. The investigation concluded at the end of the Inquest on the 17th March 2022. The Medical Cause of Death was: la Head and trunk iniuries The narrative conclusion of the Inquest recorded by the jury was "Emiliano Raul Sala died as a consequence of injuries sustained in an aircraft crash, where the flight was operated as a commercial flight without the required authorisations, certification or permission being in place."
Circumstances of the Death
On the 21st January 2019 Emiliano Raul Sala was a passenger in a Piper PA-46-31OP Malibu aircraft, registration , flying from Nantes, France to Cardiff, UK. At approximately 20: 16 hours the aircraft disappeared from radar. Emiliano was recovered from the wreckage on the sea bed on the 6th February 2019. Emiliano died instantly from fatal head and trunk injuries due to a high energy aircraft crash. It is likely that Emiliano was deeply unconscious due to carbon monoxide poisoning at the time of the accident. The organiser, of this flight, charted the aircraft from an unlicensed operator. This flight was a commercial flight operating without the correct certification and relevant permissions. The owner of the aircraft did not have any written contract wither the operator and minimal oversight of the day to day operations. The operator hired the pilot who did not have a commercial pilots license, no night rating and his rating to fly single engine piston aircraft had expired. He had limited experience in flying in instrument meteorological conditions. The aircraft maintenance was up to date in line with part 91 and part 43 however, was not consistent with a part 135 maintenance schedule for a commercial aircraft. These circumstances culminated in an unlicensed night flight, undertaken in poor weather conditions with the pilot under visual meteorological conditions. The pilot likely felt under pressure to complete the flight for a highly valued customer. The pilot lost control of the aircraft during a manually flown turn which was probably initiated the remain in, or regain visual meteorological conditions. The aircraft then suffered an inflight breakup whilst manoeuvring at an airspeed significantly outside its design parameters. The aircraft struck the sea, nose high and in an inverted attitude. The pilot was likely to have been affected by carbon monoxide poisoning. This was caused by a failure in aircraft exhaust system. In-service inspections of the exhaust system do not eliminate the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning.
Copies Sent To
Government Legal Department (GLD) on behalf of the Air Accidents Investigation Branch (MIB)
Civil Aviation Authority (CM)
on behalf of Aerotech Aircraft Maintenance Ltd
Capital Law on behalf of Cardiff City Football Club
on behalf of Cool Flourish Ltd
Kennedy's Law on behalf of Eastern Air Executive
Squire Patton Boggs on behalf of FC Nantes
Clyde & Co on behalf of Piper Aircraft Inc
Gunnercooke on behalf of Southern Aircraft Consultancy Ltd
Air Law Firm on behalf of Starr Europe
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Review CCTV monitoring SIA licence requirements
Manchester Arena Inquiry
Unregulated recreation safety
Establish standard for event healthcare services
Manchester Arena Inquiry
Unregulated recreation safety
Mandatory Ambulance Liaison Officer at events
Manchester Arena Inquiry
Unregulated recreation safety
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.