James McKeough
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2021-0414
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 2 Mar 2022
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The positioning, brightness, and color of rear flashing LED lights on trailers can mask or be misinterpreted as turn indicators, hindering other drivers' ability to discern turning intentions.
View full coroner's concerns
During the inquest the evidence revealed matters giving rise to concern. In my opinion there is a risk that future deaths will occur unless action is taken. 1. The positioning and size of of the rear mounted flashing LED lights on the Slurrykat and other types of similar trailers.
2. The fact that these lights emitted a brighter light than the right or left turn indicator light therefore masking the indicator lights.
3. These rear flashing lights are the same colour as the indicator lights.
4. The indicator light seems to get lost amongst the other flashing lights or can be misinterpreted as an additional non directional warning lamp.
5. On this particular trailer (SlurryKat) the indicator lights are at the same height as the indicators.
It was found that this issue may have been a contributing factor in Mr McKeough’s death as it appears he did not see the right indicator flashing.
2. The fact that these lights emitted a brighter light than the right or left turn indicator light therefore masking the indicator lights.
3. These rear flashing lights are the same colour as the indicator lights.
4. The indicator light seems to get lost amongst the other flashing lights or can be misinterpreted as an additional non directional warning lamp.
5. On this particular trailer (SlurryKat) the indicator lights are at the same height as the indicators.
It was found that this issue may have been a contributing factor in Mr McKeough’s death as it appears he did not see the right indicator flashing.
Responses
Action Planned
The Department for Transport will write to the National Police Chiefs’ Council, Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency, Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, Agricultural Engineers Association, National Farmers’ Union of England and Wales, and the National Farmers Union of Scotland to provide guidance and raise awareness of requirements for amber warning beacons on agricultural vehicles. (AI summary)
The Department for Transport will write to the National Police Chiefs’ Council, Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency, Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, Agricultural Engineers Association, National Farmers’ Union of England and Wales, and the National Farmers Union of Scotland to provide guidance and raise awareness of requirements for amber warning beacons on agricultural vehicles. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Ms Schofield,
Thank you for your Regulation 28 report dated 9 December, sent to the Secretary of State for Transport following the conclusion of your inquest into the death of James McKeough. I am also grateful for a copy of the full inquest documents provided subsequently. I am replying as Head of Vehicle Engineering in the International Vehicle Standards division of the Department for Transport, which leads on vehicle construction standards.
You found that the evidence considered during the inquest revealed five matters of concern relating to the configuration of the amber flashing lamps mounted to the rear of the impacted trailer. Specifically, you concluded that the position, size, colour, and brightness of the lamps may have concealed or overwhelmed the active direction indicator and been a contributing factor in this collision.
In Great Britain, vehicle lighting is regulated through the Road Vehicles Lighting Regulations 1989 (as amended) (RVLR). In general, the RVLR require that lamps fitted to vehicles show a steady light - exemptions to this requirement exist for direction indicators and warning beacons. The RVLR requires vehicles having a maximum speed not exceeding 25mph or any Penelope Schofield Senior Coroner County Record Office HM Coroners Office Orchard Street Chichester West Sussex PO19 1DD
HEAD OF VEHICLE ENGINEERING INTERNATIONAL VEHICLE STANDARDS DEPARTMENT FOR TRANSPORT 3RD FLOOR – GREAT MINSTER HOUSE 33 HORSEFERRY ROAD
Web Site: www.dft.gov.uk
2 March 2022
trailer drawn by it to be fitted with an amber warning beacon if it is to be driven on an unrestricted dual-carriageway. A warning beacon is defined in regulations as a lamp that is capable of emitting a flashing or rotating beam of light throughout 360° in the horizontal plane.
Having considered the inquest documents provided, it appears that the two rear flashing amber lamps fitted to the trailer and implicated by the police in the outcome of this collision do not comply with the definition of a warning beacon as they are unidirectional and not capable of emitting a beam of light throughout 360° in the horizontal plane.
Based on the evidence supplied, we consider that had a compliant warning beacon been fitted appropriately to the trailer in compliance with RVLR it may have enabled Mr McKeough to differentiate the warning signal from an active direction indicator.
However, the evidence does suggest a lack of understanding of the requirements of the RVLR and I will be writing to the National Police Chiefs’ Council, Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency, Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, Agricultural Engineers Association and National Farmers’ Union of England and Wales and the National Farmers Union of Scotland to provide guidance and raise awareness of the specific requirements for amber warning beacons fitted to agricultural vehicles used on the road.
I hope you find this information helpful and are assured that the Department is taking appropriate action to respond to your concerns.
Thank you for your Regulation 28 report dated 9 December, sent to the Secretary of State for Transport following the conclusion of your inquest into the death of James McKeough. I am also grateful for a copy of the full inquest documents provided subsequently. I am replying as Head of Vehicle Engineering in the International Vehicle Standards division of the Department for Transport, which leads on vehicle construction standards.
You found that the evidence considered during the inquest revealed five matters of concern relating to the configuration of the amber flashing lamps mounted to the rear of the impacted trailer. Specifically, you concluded that the position, size, colour, and brightness of the lamps may have concealed or overwhelmed the active direction indicator and been a contributing factor in this collision.
In Great Britain, vehicle lighting is regulated through the Road Vehicles Lighting Regulations 1989 (as amended) (RVLR). In general, the RVLR require that lamps fitted to vehicles show a steady light - exemptions to this requirement exist for direction indicators and warning beacons. The RVLR requires vehicles having a maximum speed not exceeding 25mph or any Penelope Schofield Senior Coroner County Record Office HM Coroners Office Orchard Street Chichester West Sussex PO19 1DD
HEAD OF VEHICLE ENGINEERING INTERNATIONAL VEHICLE STANDARDS DEPARTMENT FOR TRANSPORT 3RD FLOOR – GREAT MINSTER HOUSE 33 HORSEFERRY ROAD
Web Site: www.dft.gov.uk
2 March 2022
trailer drawn by it to be fitted with an amber warning beacon if it is to be driven on an unrestricted dual-carriageway. A warning beacon is defined in regulations as a lamp that is capable of emitting a flashing or rotating beam of light throughout 360° in the horizontal plane.
Having considered the inquest documents provided, it appears that the two rear flashing amber lamps fitted to the trailer and implicated by the police in the outcome of this collision do not comply with the definition of a warning beacon as they are unidirectional and not capable of emitting a beam of light throughout 360° in the horizontal plane.
Based on the evidence supplied, we consider that had a compliant warning beacon been fitted appropriately to the trailer in compliance with RVLR it may have enabled Mr McKeough to differentiate the warning signal from an active direction indicator.
However, the evidence does suggest a lack of understanding of the requirements of the RVLR and I will be writing to the National Police Chiefs’ Council, Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency, Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, Agricultural Engineers Association and National Farmers’ Union of England and Wales and the National Farmers Union of Scotland to provide guidance and raise awareness of the specific requirements for amber warning beacons fitted to agricultural vehicles used on the road.
I hope you find this information helpful and are assured that the Department is taking appropriate action to respond to your concerns.
Sent To
- Department for Transport
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
2 Mar 2022
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 11th February 2020 I commenced an investigation into the death of James McKeough. His death occurred following a road traffic collision on 3rd February 2020. . The investigation was concluded with the Inquest being held on 6th December 2021. At the end of the Inquest, I concluded that James McKeough died following a Road Traffic collision. At the conclusion of the Inquest, I indicated that I would be making a Regulation 28 report addressing concerns that were raised at the Inquest regarding the current standard of lighting and position of this lighting on Slurrykat and similar tankers.
Circumstances of the Death
On Monday 3rd February 2020, James McKeough was riding his motorcycle south on the A29 at Bury Hill, near Arundel. He came up behind a tractor towing a Slurry tanker at the top of the hill, travelling in the same direction. The tractor was indicating to turn right. It appears that Mr McKeough was hidden from the tractor driver's view and it seems that Mr McKeough did not see the tractor lights indicating. As the tractor turned right Mr McKeough collided with the offside of the tractor sustaining fatal injuries.
Copies Sent To
Forensic Crash Investigators
Sussex Police
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Revise signal sighting standard to explicitly consider signal readability
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Define additional time required for reading gantry-mounted and complex signals
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Clarify "very short duration" definition within the signal sighting standard
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Identify and retrospectively review locations affected by "very short duration" ambiguity
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Clarify "overhead line equipment" in signal sighting standard to mean wires and droppers
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Define acceptable limits for temporary signal obscuration in sighting standards
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Explicitly define cab sight lines for signal positioning based on driver's eye
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Railtrack to conduct safety examination of Paddington station layout and operations.
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Hazardous road design
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.