Angela Turner
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2018-0199
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 21 Aug 2018
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The response to an NHS 111 call was deemed wholly inadequate, raising concerns about emergency access to care.
View full coroner's concerns
1. Wholly inadequate response to the call made to NHS 111 on the afternoon of 30th December 2017.
Responses
Action Planned
The Department of Health and Social Care acknowledges the concerns and states that the North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust (NWAS) is conducting a full investigation into the incident and concerns raised. It also references NHS England's Urgent and Emergency Care review and the introduction of new urgent treatment centres. (AI summary)
The Department of Health and Social Care acknowledges the concerns and states that the North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust (NWAS) is conducting a full investigation into the incident and concerns raised. It also references NHS England's Urgent and Emergency Care review and the introduction of new urgent treatment centres. (AI summary)
View full response
Steve Barclay MP Minister of State for Health Department of Health & 39 Victoria Street London Social Care SW1H OEU Your reference: SNIYD/221-2018 020 7210 4850 Our reference: PFD 1139198 Mr Simon Nelson RECEIVED 9 AUg 2018 HM Assistant Coroner; Manchester West 13 AUg 2018 HM Coroner s Court Paderborn House Howell Croft North Bolton BLI IQY NL Thank you for letter of 26 June to the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care about the death of Ms Angela Marion Tumer: Iam responding as Minister with portfolio responsibility for urgent and emergency care I was extremely saddened to read of the circumstances surrounding Ms Tumer's death: If you have the opportunity, please convey my deepest sympathies to her family. 1 appreciate this must be a very difficult time for them, particularly given the serious concerns about the standard of care Ms Tumer received. Patients have a right to expect the very highest standard of care from the NHS. Iwould like to say how sorry I am that it appears that did not happen in this case Your report raises two areas of concern that I would like to address. The first around the NHS 11 service and the second about the treatment and care Ms Turner received at the Leigh Walk-in Centre. My officials have made enquiries with the North West Ambulance Service NHS Trust (NWAS) which provides the NHS 111 service in the North West area. Iunderstand that NWAS was not represented at the inquest. However; it is now conducting full, comprehensive investigation into the incident and the concerns you have raised. The investigation is currently ongoing and you will appreciate that I am not in a position to comment any further: your
However; Iam aware that NWAS is experiencing challenges in performance and has developed a performance improvement plan that is monitored closely by commissioners and NHS Improvement: Issues around the operation of the NHS 111 service are acknowledged, including the timeliness of response, and the Trust is taking steps to improve quality- NWAS was inspected in June 2018 by the Care Quality Commission and publication of the report is awaited. With regard to the NHS 11l service generally, during last winter the NHS 1ll service dealt with a record 1.5 million calls per month, 150,000 more per month than the winter before; and during 2017-18 as a whole answered over 15 million calls, the majority of which in than a minute. NHS England is looking to develop NHS IIl so that it becomes an integrated urgent care service the "front door" to advice, assessment and treatment; with range of clinical professionals such as paramedics, nurses with specialist experience, mental health professionals, pharmacists, dental professionals and senior doctors available to speak to callers who need it. By increasing clinical input into calls, NHS 111 aims to provide a *consult and complete' model. It will still be appropriate in many cases to refer to other services including primary care, pharmacy and A&E but this will get people the right help need_ NHS England plan that by March 2019 it will be possible to book all patients who call NHS Ill out ofhours directly into further appointments, if required, with 30 per cent of patients able to book appointments in hours It will also be possible for more people to be offered a prescription by the NHS 111 service. Turning to the care and treatment provided to Ms Tumer at the Leigh Walk-in Centre, I am advised that the Bridgewater Community Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust has conducted an investigation into the serious incident; overseen by the Wigan Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) Learning lessons where have gone wrong is essential to ensuring the NHS provides safe, high quality care and I expect the NHS locally to ensure that recommendations are acted upon: Iunderstand there is work locally to review the resilience of the Walk-in Centre service within the urgent care system to ensure that the NHS can provide a high quality, timely service. These are matters for local determination. being less they things
One of the aims of NHS England's Urgent and Emergency Care review' is to make access to urgent and emergency services clearer for patients and to remove the confusing mix of walk-in centres, minor injuries units and urgent care centres, in addition to numerous GP health centres and surgeries offering varied levels of core and extended service. To address this, new urgent treatment centres are being introduced which will standardise this range of options and simplify the system so patients know where to go and have clarity of which services are on offer NHS England has set out a core set of standards for urgent treatment centres to establish aS much commonality as possible: Patients and the public can expect to: be able to access urgent treatment centres that are open at least 12 hours a GP-led, staffed by GPs, nurses and other clinicians, with access to simple diagnostics, e.g. urinalysis, ECG and in some cases have a consistent route to access urgent appointments offered within four hours and booked through NHS 111,ambulance services and general practice. A walk-in access option will also be retained; increasingly be able to access routine and same-day appointments, and out-of-hours general practice, for both urgent and routine appointments, at the same facility, where geographically appropriate; and` know that the urgent treatment centre is part of locally integrated urgent and emergency care services working in conjunction with the ambulance service, NHS 111,local GPs, hospital A&E services and other local providers. [ hope this information is helpful. Thank you for bringing your concerns to our attention: Snar STEVE BARCLAY https: www england nhs uklurgent-emergency-carel day, X-ray; LD
However; Iam aware that NWAS is experiencing challenges in performance and has developed a performance improvement plan that is monitored closely by commissioners and NHS Improvement: Issues around the operation of the NHS 111 service are acknowledged, including the timeliness of response, and the Trust is taking steps to improve quality- NWAS was inspected in June 2018 by the Care Quality Commission and publication of the report is awaited. With regard to the NHS 11l service generally, during last winter the NHS 1ll service dealt with a record 1.5 million calls per month, 150,000 more per month than the winter before; and during 2017-18 as a whole answered over 15 million calls, the majority of which in than a minute. NHS England is looking to develop NHS IIl so that it becomes an integrated urgent care service the "front door" to advice, assessment and treatment; with range of clinical professionals such as paramedics, nurses with specialist experience, mental health professionals, pharmacists, dental professionals and senior doctors available to speak to callers who need it. By increasing clinical input into calls, NHS 111 aims to provide a *consult and complete' model. It will still be appropriate in many cases to refer to other services including primary care, pharmacy and A&E but this will get people the right help need_ NHS England plan that by March 2019 it will be possible to book all patients who call NHS Ill out ofhours directly into further appointments, if required, with 30 per cent of patients able to book appointments in hours It will also be possible for more people to be offered a prescription by the NHS 111 service. Turning to the care and treatment provided to Ms Tumer at the Leigh Walk-in Centre, I am advised that the Bridgewater Community Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust has conducted an investigation into the serious incident; overseen by the Wigan Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) Learning lessons where have gone wrong is essential to ensuring the NHS provides safe, high quality care and I expect the NHS locally to ensure that recommendations are acted upon: Iunderstand there is work locally to review the resilience of the Walk-in Centre service within the urgent care system to ensure that the NHS can provide a high quality, timely service. These are matters for local determination. being less they things
One of the aims of NHS England's Urgent and Emergency Care review' is to make access to urgent and emergency services clearer for patients and to remove the confusing mix of walk-in centres, minor injuries units and urgent care centres, in addition to numerous GP health centres and surgeries offering varied levels of core and extended service. To address this, new urgent treatment centres are being introduced which will standardise this range of options and simplify the system so patients know where to go and have clarity of which services are on offer NHS England has set out a core set of standards for urgent treatment centres to establish aS much commonality as possible: Patients and the public can expect to: be able to access urgent treatment centres that are open at least 12 hours a GP-led, staffed by GPs, nurses and other clinicians, with access to simple diagnostics, e.g. urinalysis, ECG and in some cases have a consistent route to access urgent appointments offered within four hours and booked through NHS 111,ambulance services and general practice. A walk-in access option will also be retained; increasingly be able to access routine and same-day appointments, and out-of-hours general practice, for both urgent and routine appointments, at the same facility, where geographically appropriate; and` know that the urgent treatment centre is part of locally integrated urgent and emergency care services working in conjunction with the ambulance service, NHS 111,local GPs, hospital A&E services and other local providers. [ hope this information is helpful. Thank you for bringing your concerns to our attention: Snar STEVE BARCLAY https: www england nhs uklurgent-emergency-carel day, X-ray; LD
Sent To
- Department of Health and Social Care
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
21 Aug 2018
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 18th January 2018 I commenced an Investigation into the death of Angela Marion Turner, 57 years, born on the 30th June 1960. The Investigation concluded at the end of the Inquest on the 6th June 2018.
The medical cause of death was:-
Ia Spontaneous subarachnoid haemorrhage Ib Ruptured intracranial aneurysm
The conclusion of the Inquest was Anglea Marion Turner died of natural causes.
The medical cause of death was:-
Ia Spontaneous subarachnoid haemorrhage Ib Ruptured intracranial aneurysm
The conclusion of the Inquest was Anglea Marion Turner died of natural causes.
Circumstances of the Death
On the afternoon of Saturday 30th December 2017 having complained of intense pain following a sudden onset headache the son of the deceased telephoned 111. His called remained unanswered for approximately 45 minutes. He was subsequently advised by his mother’s GP Practice to attend the local Walk In Centre where, although appropriately triaged, her subsequent assessment proved suboptimal and she was inappropriately discharged home. On the 31st December 2017 at approximately 15:30 hours she was discovered collapsed at home. A subsequent CT scan confirmed a subarachnoid haemorrhage from which she died on 10.01.2018.
Copies Sent To
3. The Chief Executive, Wrightington, Wigan and Leigh NHS FT, Suite 2, Buckingham Row, Brick Kiln Lane, Wigan
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.