Patrick Clifford
PFD Report
Historic (No Identified Response)
Ref: 2017-0291
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Lack of clear patient supervision policy in toilets, difficulties transferring radiology images between hospitals, and refusal to perform requested X-rays caused treatment delays.
View full coroner's concerns
1. The evidence from the nursing staff that a patient would not be supervised within the toilet unless there had been a fall on the ward. It was not clear whether this was a general understanding by nursing staff or a specific policy. I am concerned that future falls (and therefore deaths) will occur unless action is taken to address this policy/understanding.
2. The evidence from the clinicians was that there were sometimes difficulties in transferring images to other hospitals. In this case there appeared to be misunderstandings as to whether or not Wrightington could access radiology images/reports through the Royal Blackburn Hospital PACS system and vice-versa. In the present case this caused delays in the commencement of necessary physiotherapy treatment and I am concerned that future delays could similarly delay treatment and risk future deaths as a result.
3. During the course of evidence it became apparent that the Radiology department at the Royal Blackburn Hospital had refused to carry out Judet X-rays as specifically requested by the orthopaedic specialists at Wrightington. This caused delays in commencing partial weight bearing physiotherapy in Mr Clifford’s case. I am concerned that future delays could similarly delay treatment and risk future deaths as a result.
2. The evidence from the clinicians was that there were sometimes difficulties in transferring images to other hospitals. In this case there appeared to be misunderstandings as to whether or not Wrightington could access radiology images/reports through the Royal Blackburn Hospital PACS system and vice-versa. In the present case this caused delays in the commencement of necessary physiotherapy treatment and I am concerned that future delays could similarly delay treatment and risk future deaths as a result.
3. During the course of evidence it became apparent that the Radiology department at the Royal Blackburn Hospital had refused to carry out Judet X-rays as specifically requested by the orthopaedic specialists at Wrightington. This caused delays in commencing partial weight bearing physiotherapy in Mr Clifford’s case. I am concerned that future delays could similarly delay treatment and risk future deaths as a result.
Sent To
- East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust
Response Status
Linked responses
0 of 1
56-Day Deadline
7 Dec 2017
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 28th September 2016 an inquest was opened into the death of Patrick Clifford. Evidence was heard at inquest on the 22nd March 2017. The inquest was adjourned part heard on the 22nd March 2017 and completed on the 11th October 2017. A narrative conclusion was left:
Mr Clifford fell backwards following a faint in the toilet on Ward B4 at the Royal Blackburn Hospital on the 19th March 2016. He suffered a fractured acetabulum as a result. This was treated conservatively. His condition deteriorated over time. He developed pneumonia due to immobility and heart failure and passed away on the 18th September 2016 at Springhill care home in Accrington.
Mr Clifford fell backwards following a faint in the toilet on Ward B4 at the Royal Blackburn Hospital on the 19th March 2016. He suffered a fractured acetabulum as a result. This was treated conservatively. His condition deteriorated over time. He developed pneumonia due to immobility and heart failure and passed away on the 18th September 2016 at Springhill care home in Accrington.
Circumstances of the Death
Mr Clifford suffered a fall in the toilet at Royal Blackburn Hospital where he was a patient on the 19th March 2016. No risk assessment had been carried out but I found that the fall would not have been prevented had a risk assessment taken place, as there was no requirement for Mr Clifford to be supervised in the toilet due to his level of his mobility. The Trust accepted that a risk assessment should have been carried out and this has now been addressed on Ward B4. During the course of the evidence, it appeared to be suggested that supervision in the toilet would not be required unless there had been a fall on the ward (even if there had been a relevant fall at the patient’s home or other risk factors were present).
Following the fall in March 2016, Mr Clifford sustained a fractured acetabulum. This was treated conservatively, as surgery was not recommended. He was referred to Orthopaedics at Royal Blackburn Hospital and then referred to Wrightington Hospital for advice to be obtained on the fracture. The referral to Wrightington was mainly to obtain advice on the fracture and to obtain their expert opinion on when weight bearing or partial weight bearing could commence. There were delays in obtaining advice from Wrightington, which led to extended bed-rest in Mr Clifford’s case. These delays were due to problems with accessing the images from different PACS systems at the hospitals and misunderstandings as to whether Wrightington could access the images. There were also delays caused by the Radiology department at the Royal Blackburn Hospital refusing to undertake the Judet views that were specifically requested by Wrightington.
Whilst there were delays in commencing partial weight bearing and communications issues later at Burnley General Hospital regarding daily hoisting, I concluded that these matters did not contribute to Mr Clifford’s death in September 2016 on the balance of probabilities. However, these were missed opportunities to improve his condition.
Following the fall in March 2016, Mr Clifford sustained a fractured acetabulum. This was treated conservatively, as surgery was not recommended. He was referred to Orthopaedics at Royal Blackburn Hospital and then referred to Wrightington Hospital for advice to be obtained on the fracture. The referral to Wrightington was mainly to obtain advice on the fracture and to obtain their expert opinion on when weight bearing or partial weight bearing could commence. There were delays in obtaining advice from Wrightington, which led to extended bed-rest in Mr Clifford’s case. These delays were due to problems with accessing the images from different PACS systems at the hospitals and misunderstandings as to whether Wrightington could access the images. There were also delays caused by the Radiology department at the Royal Blackburn Hospital refusing to undertake the Judet views that were specifically requested by Wrightington.
Whilst there were delays in commencing partial weight bearing and communications issues later at Burnley General Hospital regarding daily hoisting, I concluded that these matters did not contribute to Mr Clifford’s death in September 2016 on the balance of probabilities. However, these were missed opportunities to improve his condition.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Close HSS Dispute Resolution Procedure when HSSA opens
Post Office Horizon Inquiry
Inconsistent Healthcare Data Infrastructure
Proportionate Access to Linked Healthcare Records
COVID-19 Inquiry
Inconsistent Healthcare Data Infrastructure
Transfusion Committees and Tranexamic Acid - England
Infected Blood Inquiry
Inadequate Pre-Operative Risk Assessment
Tranexamic Acid - Scotland, Wales and NI
Infected Blood Inquiry
Inadequate Pre-Operative Risk Assessment
Transfusion Performance Benchmarking
Infected Blood Inquiry
Inconsistent Healthcare Data Infrastructure
NHSBT Transfusion Outcome Funding
Infected Blood Inquiry
Inconsistent Healthcare Data Infrastructure
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.