Helen England
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2016-0141
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 11 May 2016
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
No protocol or guidance exists for Mental Health Nurses regarding doctor referral decisions when discharging self-harm patients, particularly those on a Community Treatment Order, creating a significant risk.
View full coroner's concerns
(1) There was no protocol nor any guidance in place for Mental Health Nurses at the 5 Boroughs NHS Partnership Foundation Trust to follow when considering whether or not to refer to a Doctor a decision to discharge a patient, following an attendance at, or admission to, an acute Hospital consequent upon an episode of self-harm, particularly when the patient is subject to a Community Treatment Order imposed under the terms of the Mental Health Act.
Responses
Action Taken
The Trust has amended its Community Treatment Order Procedure in light of the coroner's concerns and is communicating this to staff. (AI summary)
The Trust has amended its Community Treatment Order Procedure in light of the coroner's concerns and is communicating this to staff. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Ms Leeming Re: Helen England (Deceased) D.O.B: 28 May 1975 D.OD: 26 December 2016 Thank you for your letter of 11 April 2016, received in this office on 12 April 2016, regarding Helen England and the outcome of the inquest into Helen's death, which concluded on 4 March 2016. note your concerns, raised at a national level with the Secretary of State for Health; the RT Hon Jeremy Hunt; regarding the absence of any protocol or guidance for clinical staff to follow when considering whether or not to refer to a doctor in decision to discharge patient following their attendance at an acute hospital, particularly in relation to those patients who are subject to Community Treatment Order. Better of mind body Chief Executive: Wr. Simon J. Barber Chairman: Mr: Bernard Pilkington Trust Headquarters , Hollins Park House, Hollins Lane, Winwick, Warrington, WAZ 8WA Mini Com Number 01925 664094 0154848 Your View . 1
am writing to inform you that although the Regulation 28 was not aimed specifically at the Trust would like to confirm that our Community Treatment Order Procedure has been amended in light of your concerns and process for communicating this to our staff is underway. If can be of any further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me.
am writing to inform you that although the Regulation 28 was not aimed specifically at the Trust would like to confirm that our Community Treatment Order Procedure has been amended in light of your concerns and process for communicating this to our staff is underway. If can be of any further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Sent To
- Department of Health and Social Care
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
11 May 2016
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 3rd of January 2014 I commenced an investigation into the death of Helen England, aged 38. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on the 7th March 2016. The conclusion of the inquest was Suicide.
Circumstances of the Death
Helen England has suffered from Bipolar Affective Disorder since 1999 and between that time and her death she had been detained as an in-patient under the terms of the Mental Health Act on eleven occasions. On the 15th October 2013 Helen England was discharged from an in-patient compulsory admission to Leigh Infimary that had been imposed under the terms of the Mental Health Act. On the same date she was made subject to a Mental Health Act Community Treatment Order containing certain conditions. Whilst living in the community subject to the order Helen was subject to social stresses and her mental health deteriorated. Her behaviour also gave rise to a concern that she was a risk to others. On the 18th November 2013 she was re-admitted to Leigh Infirmary and was subsequently again detained as an in-patient under the terms of the Mental Health Act. On the 13th December 2013 Helen was again discharged from hospital and a second Community Treatment Order was imposed. Whilst in the community Helen again became subject to social and relationship stresses as had previously happened. On the 22nd December 2013 Helen was admitted to The Royal Albert Edward Infirmary in Wigan, having self-inflicted a superficial cut to her left wrist and a deep lacertion to her right arm. This was the first occasion in Helen's history upon which she had demonstrably self-harmed. During the evening of 22nd December Helen was seen by a Registered Mental Health Nurse who decided that Helen was not fit for a mental health assessment at that time. There was a plan for Helen to be seen by her Community Support Worker the following day, the 23rd December 2013, but this visit was cancelled by the Community Team due to Helen's hospital admission. On the 24th December 2013, Helen underwent surgery for the injury to her right arm at The Royal Albert Edward Infirmary in Wigan, following which she was assessed as being medically fit for discharge at about 19.30 hours. At approximately 20.30 hours Helen was seen on the ward by the same Registered Mental Health Nurse who had previously seen her on the 22nd December. The nurse conducted an assessment of Helen's mental health in the course of which Helen denied that she had intended suicide when she had injured herself, nor did she admit to having any suicidal ideas at the time of the examination. The nurse decided that Helen did not meet the criteria for detention under the terms of the Mental Health Act and it was planned that Helen should be discharged to reside with her family for the next few days. The nurse was not required to, and did not, seek advice from a doctor when making this decision, despite Helen being subject to a Community Treatment Order. The nurse was aware that Helen was subject to the Order, but was not aware of its terms since they were not included in the records available to the nurse. There was no protocol or guidance in place for the nurse to follow when considering whether or not to refer a decision to discharge a patient to a doctor, either when a patient was subject to a Community Treatment Order or at all. Following Helen's discharge on the 24th December 2013, she did stay with her family until the morning of the 26th December 2013 when she insisted upon returning to her own home at 5 Sandy Lane Lowton. At or about 10.42 on the 26th December 2013 Helen's mother telephoned Mental Health Services to advise that Helen had returned home and to express concerns about her safety. In a second telephone call she was advised to contact the Police, but she did not feel able to do this. That call ended at about 11.12 hours. The Mental Health Nurse tried to contact Helen at about 11.36 hours and when she could not do so she first telephoned Helen's mother and then the Police at about 11.44 hours. The delay of twenty four minutes between the Nurse speaking to Helen's mother and the Nurse ringing the Police has not been fully explained. The Police call taker received the call at 11.51 hours and graded it as requiring an attendance at Helen's address within one hour, and a Police Officer arrived at Helen's home at 12.11 hours. The Officer then waited for the attendance of a second Officer before entering the property, because there was intelligence that one of the occupants of the property, who was not Helen, had previously injured a Police Officer attending at the address. A second Police Officer arrived at 12.30 hours and both Officers entered Helen's home at 12.31, where they found Helen hanging from the staircase having left notes indicating an intention to end her own life.
Copies Sent To
1. , Helen’s Mum
2. Slater and Gordon Solicitors
3. DAC Beachcroft
4. Andrew Foster CBE, CE , The Royal Albert and Edward Infimary
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Prevent discharge of hospitalised children with concerns until home is safe
Laming Inquiry
Care and discharge planning
Require consultant or paediatrician permission for discharging children with protection concerns.
Laming Inquiry
Care and discharge planning
Require documented future care plan for discharging children with protection concerns.
Laming Inquiry
Care and discharge planning
Ensure identified GP for children with deliberate harm concerns discharged from hospital.
Laming Inquiry
Care and discharge planning
Establish comprehensive counselling and support services as integral to patient care
Bristol Heart Inquiry
Care and discharge planning
Require every trust to provide a professional bereavement service and online information
Bristol Heart Inquiry
Care and discharge planning
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.