Dorothy McDermott
PFD Report
Historic (No Identified Response)
Ref: 2015-0266
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
A vulnerable patient was inappropriately placed in a residential care home without nursing care or staff trained for her needs. A lack of formal guidance for agencies led to unsuitable placements for vulnerable individuals.
View full coroner's concerns
Dorothy McDermott was 80 years old. She had been housebound for 234 years. She had been diagnosed with a urinary tract infection and was confused. On the 17 th January 2015, she had fallen three times whilst at home. Paramedics advised a rapid response but they finished at 5.3Opm. Mrs McDermott required a place of safety. Following discussions between the Local Authority’s emergency duty team and the out of hours service for the district nursing team, emergency respite care was arranged at the Littleborough Care Home to which Mrs McDermott was conveyed during the early hours of the 18 th January. It was envisaged that Mrs McDermott would be reassessed on the 19 th January. The Littleborough Care Home offered residential but not nursing care. Care staff at the home were not trained in either the examination for or care of pressure sores. That placement was inappropriate. The rationale for that decision was one of availability with the facility of a ground floor bedroom which had been newly decorated. Whilst appreciating that the decision to procure respite care was made ‘out of hours’ the overriding concern given the extent of Mrs McDermott’s vulnerability should have been to obtain a suitable placement which guaranteed a place of safety. Whilst not wishing to be prescriptive, formal Guidance is required to as to ensure that vulnerable individuals are appropriately placed by the Agencies involved.
Sent To
- Department of Health and Social Care
- Pennine Care Trust
- Rochdale Metropolitan Borough Council
Response Status
Linked responses
0 of 4
56-Day Deadline
4 Sep 2015
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 10 th February 2015 I commenced an investigation into the death of Dorothy McDermott for whom the cause of death was confirmed at Inquest as being that of la) Septicaemia, lb)Decubitus Ulcer / Bed Sore with Hypertension and Urinary Tract Infection, whilst not causative of death, being contributory factors under 2. At an Inquest convened on the 2 nd July 2015 the following conclusion was made
— ‘Against a background of increasing immobility and susceptibility to urinary tract infections, Dorothy McDermott was at high risk of developing pressure sores. On the 17 th January 2015, having fallen three times that day, she was admitted from home to emergency respite care where she remained until the 26 th January. She was not examined when attended upon by a GP on the January and subsequently opportunities to examine her sacrum were missed by reason of inadequate training of care staff. The evidence does not show when the Grade 4 pressure sore developed but more likely than not, it would be over a number of days prior to the 26 th January on which date a visiting District Nurse was alerted to concerns raised by care staff by which time Mrs McDermott was already in extremis. She was admitted to Fairfield General Hospital where she died during the early hours of the 27 th January 2015’.
— ‘Against a background of increasing immobility and susceptibility to urinary tract infections, Dorothy McDermott was at high risk of developing pressure sores. On the 17 th January 2015, having fallen three times that day, she was admitted from home to emergency respite care where she remained until the 26 th January. She was not examined when attended upon by a GP on the January and subsequently opportunities to examine her sacrum were missed by reason of inadequate training of care staff. The evidence does not show when the Grade 4 pressure sore developed but more likely than not, it would be over a number of days prior to the 26 th January on which date a visiting District Nurse was alerted to concerns raised by care staff by which time Mrs McDermott was already in extremis. She was admitted to Fairfield General Hospital where she died during the early hours of the 27 th January 2015’.
Circumstances of the Death
As above
Copies Sent To
1. The Department of Health
2. Rochdale MBC
3. Pennine Care Trust
4. Littleborough Care Home
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Strengthening identification of healthcare support workers and nurses
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Unqualified Staff Deployment
Strengthening identification of healthcare support workers and nurses
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Unqualified Staff Deployment
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.