Isaac Bahar
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2015-0229
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 10 Aug 2015
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
A patient with advanced kidney disease was fatally prescribed Codeine, directly breaching hospital policy and national guidance on medication for vulnerable patients.
View full coroner's concerns
_ Mr; Bahar was admitted to the Royal Sussex County Hospital on 10th November 2014 with pneumothorax due to fractured ribs. He was treated urgently and appropriately until his analgesia. He was a man with known Stage 4 Chronic Disease, in breach of the hospital's own policy and in breach of national guidance he was prescribed and given four doses of Codeine over 18 hours. Although this was stopped by the ward Pharmacist as soon as she was able to review his chart; Mr: Bahar collapsed with severe opiatelopioid toxicity 30 hours later and died just under three hours after the collapse. The at his Inquest found this error to be one of the causes of his death day Kidney yet drug Jury
VERONICA HAMILTON-DEELEY, LL.B.
VERONICA HAMILTON-DEELEY, LL.B.
Responses
Action Taken
Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals Trust has discussed the incident with general surgeons and the nursing and pharmacy teams, leading the general surgeons to decide that codeine should no longer be routinely available for them to prescribe. (AI summary)
Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals Trust has discussed the incident with general surgeons and the nursing and pharmacy teams, leading the general surgeons to decide that codeine should no longer be routinely available for them to prescribe. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Miss Hamilton-Deeley TheLate Isaac Baharzdate of birthi 18.10.1941 NHS_Noi 623 012 4009 Thank you for your letter of 1Sth June 2015 and its enclosures, received on 19th June, and for drawing your concerns to our attention Wehave not been able to identify any Trust member of staff called but we have ensured that the matron with responsibility for all the Level 9a wards has had sight of your report and an opportunity to reflect on the matters you have raised_ We too have given careful consideration to your letter. As you know, we are always willing to review our practices in this Trust; in order to identify improvements which can be made in the light of experience: Mr Bahar was very unwell when he was admitted to the Royal Sussex County Hospital, and his prognosis was poor. However, we agree that it is wrong and unacceptable for any patient with chronic kidney disease, as suffered by Mr Bahar, to have codeine prescribed and administered to him. This was followed up with both the medical staff concerned even though both happened to be locums, had both worked continuously in the Trust for a considerable period; our investigations have not found any reason to believe that this acknowledged error arose from their locum status. were both aware that codeine should not be prescribed in such circumstances. While the consultant was not able to recall the particular circumstances of the ward round in which his plan included prescribing codeine for Mr Bahar_ the more junior doctor who actually wrote the prescription is clear that it was and remains her routine practice to check renal function by looking at the relevant test results before writing any such prescription. She was mortified to discover that on this occasion she must have failed to do so. She could only hypothesise, and apologise profoundly, that on this occasion there must have been some interruption or other distraction which made her overlook what she is well aware is a vital step before any such prescription is written. A ward pharmacist routinely reviews prescription charts, and when she found this inappropriate prescription she immediately discussed it at the time with the team and crossed off the prescription less than 24 hours after it had been written. With our partner brighton and sussex medical school Gur City they They
The Trust's lead pharmacist in patient safety carried out a detailed investigation of this matter. She found no evidence that there was a failure in knowledge or education, or any failure in selection or induction of locum staff_ which caused or contributed to the medication being prescribed outside the Trust's recommended analgesia guidance. The British National Formulary (BNF) makes it clear that codeine and other opioid analgesics should be avoided or used with caution at reduced doses in patients with renal impairment_ Codeine was also used on the gastroenterology ward where Mr Bahar was a patient to help reduce diarrhea, a common symptom for gastroenterology patients. The lead pharmacist has confirmed that she would not expect nurses to be aware of the nuances of codeine metabolism in patients with renal impairment, and there was therefore no reason for the nurses administering the prescription to query this prescription before administering it. This incident, and the sad death of Mr Bahar, has been discussed in detail with both the general surgeons and the nursing team on Level 9a, as well as with the pharmacy team. As a direct result, the general surgeons decided that codeine should no longer be routinely available for them to prescribe_ Discussions are continuing to seek a consensus as to whether the benefits of withdrawing codeine altogether from use within the Trust by other specialists would outweigh the associated disadvantages of such a step. Thank you once for raising this concern with us_ Please pass on our sincere condolences to Mr Bahar's daughter and the family on their sad loss.
The Trust's lead pharmacist in patient safety carried out a detailed investigation of this matter. She found no evidence that there was a failure in knowledge or education, or any failure in selection or induction of locum staff_ which caused or contributed to the medication being prescribed outside the Trust's recommended analgesia guidance. The British National Formulary (BNF) makes it clear that codeine and other opioid analgesics should be avoided or used with caution at reduced doses in patients with renal impairment_ Codeine was also used on the gastroenterology ward where Mr Bahar was a patient to help reduce diarrhea, a common symptom for gastroenterology patients. The lead pharmacist has confirmed that she would not expect nurses to be aware of the nuances of codeine metabolism in patients with renal impairment, and there was therefore no reason for the nurses administering the prescription to query this prescription before administering it. This incident, and the sad death of Mr Bahar, has been discussed in detail with both the general surgeons and the nursing team on Level 9a, as well as with the pharmacy team. As a direct result, the general surgeons decided that codeine should no longer be routinely available for them to prescribe_ Discussions are continuing to seek a consensus as to whether the benefits of withdrawing codeine altogether from use within the Trust by other specialists would outweigh the associated disadvantages of such a step. Thank you once for raising this concern with us_ Please pass on our sincere condolences to Mr Bahar's daughter and the family on their sad loss.
Sent To
- Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
10 Aug 2015
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 11th 2015 commenced an investigation into the death of Isaac Silas
Circumstances of the Death
See Record of Inquest
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you AND your organisation have the power to take such action
Copies Sent To
Legal Services Manager; Brighton & Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust, Chair, Brighton & Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust 3_ Secretary of State for Health, Department of Health Simon Stevens, Chief Executive NHS England 5_ National Patient Safety Agency 6_ Director of Public Health, Brighton & Hove Clinical Commissioning Group Director for Clinical Quality & Primary Care, Brighton & Hove Clinical Commissioning_Group_ they days
VERONICA HAMILTON
DEELEY, LLB
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.