Alice McMeekin
PFD Report
Historic (No Identified Response)
Ref: 2015-0211
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Police failed to act on reported threats and share critical information with mental health services, leading to a flawed psychiatric assessment and early discharge of a high-risk individual with significant mental health issues.
View full coroner's concerns
In the circumstances it is my statutory duty to report t0 you: 1.The Police The evidence revealed that on the 6lh June 2013 the perpetrator made remarks to a member of the public to the effect that he "would not kill his mother" This information was passed to the Officers who attended the area. Some 2 hours later the same officers attended a call about a man behaving strangely and covered in blood: An ambulance was called The officers had not spoken to the original caller , who subsequently gave evidence that the remarks were that the perpetrator said he "would kill his mother" "Common sense told the officers that the person was one and the same and did welfare check on his mother. day they
At no stage did they question the perpetrator about his originally reported remarks. Also, citing confidentially they did not pass those remarks onto the Ambulance Team. This meant that when later seen by the psychiatric nurse the latter was in ignorance of this significant statement: It is possible that had the nurse been aware this may have altered the outcome of the perpetrator's initial assessment and how he was dealt with
2.The Partnership Trust The Coroner concluded that the evidence at the inquest showed that the perpetrator was suffering from a mental disorder when he tried to kill himself on the 6"h June 2013. Whilst the psychiatric nurse that day did not have all the information which was available at the inquest he had information to show that perpetrator had a history of self-harm, unemployment, family stressors, multiple and complex drug misuse, quasi-incestuous sexual feelings, past sex abuse, hopelessness, low mood and serious suicide attempt that
3.Not withstanding the above the nurse decided that the perpetrator was of zero risk and was not suffering from a mental disorder. He was discharged with the only potential follow up being talking therapy which would not commence, if it ever did, some weeks hence. The evidence at inquest shows that this was a disturbed young man having intended to kill himself 6 hours earlier and who remained a risk to himself. Whilst on the information known to the nurse at the time the tragic outcome could not have been anticipated, there was an opportunity to render care, which could, as a consequence have made a difference It is a concern that the two assessments after the killings also concluded the perpetrator was not suffering from a mental disorder.
At no stage did they question the perpetrator about his originally reported remarks. Also, citing confidentially they did not pass those remarks onto the Ambulance Team. This meant that when later seen by the psychiatric nurse the latter was in ignorance of this significant statement: It is possible that had the nurse been aware this may have altered the outcome of the perpetrator's initial assessment and how he was dealt with
2.The Partnership Trust The Coroner concluded that the evidence at the inquest showed that the perpetrator was suffering from a mental disorder when he tried to kill himself on the 6"h June 2013. Whilst the psychiatric nurse that day did not have all the information which was available at the inquest he had information to show that perpetrator had a history of self-harm, unemployment, family stressors, multiple and complex drug misuse, quasi-incestuous sexual feelings, past sex abuse, hopelessness, low mood and serious suicide attempt that
3.Not withstanding the above the nurse decided that the perpetrator was of zero risk and was not suffering from a mental disorder. He was discharged with the only potential follow up being talking therapy which would not commence, if it ever did, some weeks hence. The evidence at inquest shows that this was a disturbed young man having intended to kill himself 6 hours earlier and who remained a risk to himself. Whilst on the information known to the nurse at the time the tragic outcome could not have been anticipated, there was an opportunity to render care, which could, as a consequence have made a difference It is a concern that the two assessments after the killings also concluded the perpetrator was not suffering from a mental disorder.
Sent To
- Cumbria Constabulary
- Cumbria Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
Response Status
Linked responses
0 of 2
56-Day Deadline
30 Jul 2015
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 19"h of June 2013, commenced an investigation into the death of Alice Anne McMeekin 58 years of age. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 22nd May 2015. The conclusion of the inquest Cause of death: Ia) Head Injuries Conclusion: Unlawfully killed
Circumstances of the Death
At About 8.OOhrs on the 8'h June 2013 at Newton Street, Millom, Cumbria, the deceased was attacked by a male living at that address_ He struck her repeatedly about the head with a hatchet as a result of which she sustained fatal head injuries. Two days prior to this incident the perpetrator had attempted suicide and had been taken to hospital. There he was assessed as at zero risk to himself or others. On the balance of probability the perpetrator was suffered from a recognised mental disorder at the time of the attack
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you and your organisation have the power to take such action Chief Constable (1)To examine the mechanism of passing information to other agencies in particular the ambulance service or mental health service so that issues of confidentiality do not impede the protection of life_ (2)To review the forensic psychiatric services available to the police.
Copies Sent To
very July and
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Recording words and behaviour of high-risk individuals
Southport Inquiry
Police investigation management
Response officer access to case information technology
Southport Inquiry
Police investigation management
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.