Alasdair Penny
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2015-0106
All 2 responses received
· Deadline: 12 May 2015
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Bridge railings are easily mounted, facilitating suicides. Despite existing support notices, physical barriers should be reconsidered to prevent spontaneous jumps from the bridge.
View full coroner's concerns
This Bridge has been the site of 2 suicides in 2011 and 2014; |am unaware if there have been any other successful suicides at this location before then, but if so, not in the very recent past: In each of the 2 cases the deceased jumped from the bridge on to the road below, a distance of 10-11 metres. The 2 footpaths that bound the carriageway each have a metal railing the height of the railing is such that can be quite easily mounted. from May and they
There is a series of discrete notices on the mesh infill to the railings, giving details, understand, of the Samaritans cannot; and do not, offer a solution certainly recognise that merely raining the level of the railing may not prevent the determined person to climb up and jump. But it might well stop the spontaneous jumper. understand that do not know whether it is possible/feasible to provide extra/or some other form of protection in order to make it more difficult for the bridge to be used as a suicide site. However, do believe that the whole situation should be reconsidered in case something can be reasonably implemented to minimise the possibility of a recurrence
There is a series of discrete notices on the mesh infill to the railings, giving details, understand, of the Samaritans cannot; and do not, offer a solution certainly recognise that merely raining the level of the railing may not prevent the determined person to climb up and jump. But it might well stop the spontaneous jumper. understand that do not know whether it is possible/feasible to provide extra/or some other form of protection in order to make it more difficult for the bridge to be used as a suicide site. However, do believe that the whole situation should be reconsidered in case something can be reasonably implemented to minimise the possibility of a recurrence
Responses
Action Taken
Sussex Police highlights that the East Grinstead Neighbourhood Joint Action Group implemented 6 Samaritans signs on the bridge, and the Street Pastors and police continue to patrol the bridge. (AI summary)
Sussex Police highlights that the East Grinstead Neighbourhood Joint Action Group implemented 6 Samaritans signs on the bridge, and the Street Pastors and police continue to patrol the bridge. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Re: Inquest into the death of Alasdair Neal PENNY 16th and 17th March 2015-05-08 write in response to your formal report under Regulation 28: Report to Prevent Future Deaths. The concern around the bridge was raised in 2013 through the East Grinstead Neighbourhood Joint Action Group (NJAG). This was following the suicide of William Rayner in February 2011 and a further incident in which a member of the public was pulled back from the wrong side of the bridge in June 2013. The group consisted of representatives from the local police team; town council and West County Council (WSCC). Over the period between June 2013 and the suicide of Alasdair Penny, numerous recommendations were made by the NJAG which included Raising the parapets of the bridge_ Consideration of a designated zone for memorial flowers_ Cut back the vegetation on the banks to reveal the true nature of the Implementation of signposting for Samaritans etc on the bridge No stopping on Bridge signs_ Patrol activity from the local EG Street Pastors Continued Police patrols of the area contld Police Headquarters Malling House Church Lane Lewes East Sussex BN7 2DZ Telephone 101 Fax (01273) 404263 Website; http / {www sussex police uk e-mail: chief constable@sussex pnn:police.uk Reeests May Sir , Sussex drop.
The NJAG group was able to implement 6 Samaritans signs on the bridge which are still currently in place and the Street Pastors continue to patrol the bridge, as do the local police team: The raising of the parapets_ which was the partners preferred recommendation; was referred to WSCC and was discussed at the County Local Committee meeting in late 2014_ WSCC reported that the vegetation could not be cut back and a report was being prepared as to the reasons why_ The potential alterations to the bridge are being managed by WSCC and an update meeting is planned between Peter Lawrence (WSCC) , Julie Holden (EGTC) and PS Graeme Prentice (Sussex Police) on the 2Oth May 2015
The NJAG group was able to implement 6 Samaritans signs on the bridge which are still currently in place and the Street Pastors continue to patrol the bridge, as do the local police team: The raising of the parapets_ which was the partners preferred recommendation; was referred to WSCC and was discussed at the County Local Committee meeting in late 2014_ WSCC reported that the vegetation could not be cut back and a report was being prepared as to the reasons why_ The potential alterations to the bridge are being managed by WSCC and an update meeting is planned between Peter Lawrence (WSCC) , Julie Holden (EGTC) and PS Graeme Prentice (Sussex Police) on the 2Oth May 2015
Action Planned
West Sussex County Council will investigate the technical feasibility of increasing the height of the parapet on College Lane Bridge and intends to undertake alterations within this financial year if an appropriate solution can be determined. (AI summary)
West Sussex County Council will investigate the technical feasibility of increasing the height of the parapet on College Lane Bridge and intends to undertake alterations within this financial year if an appropriate solution can be determined. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Madam Responseof_West Sussex County Council_to_the requlation 28 Report to Prevent Future_Deaths issued by M 1 C Burgess_ Assistant Coroner dated 1Z March 2015_following an inquest_into_ the death of_Alasdair Neal Penny: I am with regard to the actions we propose to take following receipt of your report into the death of Mr Alasdair Neil Penny as a result of a fall from the College Lane Bridge, East Grinstead. was very sorry to read of the events that led to the death of Mr Penny and wish to extend my sympathies to his family. understand Mr Penny was suffering from Paranoid Schizophrenia, but was refusing to take his medication: In the days leading up to his death he had been seen at the bridge on number of occasions, where his odd behaviour led members of the public to report him to the police. On the day before his death he was picked up by the police from the bridge and returned to his parents' home address, though checks made then did not reveal his mental health problems_ You raise the following two matters of concern. The bridge has been the site of a previous suicide in 2011 The height of the railings at the back edge of the footways that bound the bridge is such that can be quite easily mounted and would not deter spontaneous jumper, The bridge was the location of previous suicide in 2011. It is very likely Mr Penny knew Mr Raynor, had both attended the same secondary school, possibly in the same year group. We are not aware of any other similar events prior to Mr Raynor's death in 2011 The College Lane road bridge was constructed to modern design standards, with 1m high parapets conforming to B56779 part Highway Parapets for Bridges and other Structures. This is the national standard and is applied across the whole of West Sussex for road bridges carrying carriageway and adjacent footways. However , we understand your concerns that this standard height is Reewowep writing they They
unlikely to inhibit a deliberate action to climb over the parapet and jump from the bridge: While we would caution that it is unlikely that any engineering solution would be 100% effective we be investigating whether it is technically feasible to increase the height of the current parapet to deter as far as practicable similar events occurring in the future. If an appropriate solution can be determined we intended to undertake the alterations within this financial year, subject to any design and programming constraints If an appropriate technical solution cannot be realised will write to you explaining the reasons why_ We also be raising the issue with other partners through the East Grinstead Neighbourhood Joint Action Group (NJAG) to see if there is any further appropriate preventative work that can be initiated from community perspective including the potential of additional work with vulnerable young people through our Health Services. Previously the East Grinstead NJAG was responsible for arranging the current Samaritans signs and for organising for the local Street Pastors to make the bridge part of their regular patrols.
unlikely to inhibit a deliberate action to climb over the parapet and jump from the bridge: While we would caution that it is unlikely that any engineering solution would be 100% effective we be investigating whether it is technically feasible to increase the height of the current parapet to deter as far as practicable similar events occurring in the future. If an appropriate solution can be determined we intended to undertake the alterations within this financial year, subject to any design and programming constraints If an appropriate technical solution cannot be realised will write to you explaining the reasons why_ We also be raising the issue with other partners through the East Grinstead Neighbourhood Joint Action Group (NJAG) to see if there is any further appropriate preventative work that can be initiated from community perspective including the potential of additional work with vulnerable young people through our Health Services. Previously the East Grinstead NJAG was responsible for arranging the current Samaritans signs and for organising for the local Street Pastors to make the bridge part of their regular patrols.
Sent To
- Sussex Police
- West Sussex County Council
Response Status
Linked responses
2 of 2
56-Day Deadline
12 May 2015
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 7 May 2014 an investigation into the death of Alasdair Neal PENNY aged 23 was commenced. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 17 March 2015_ The conclusion of the inquest (as found by the jury) was Name of Deceased: Alasdair Neal Penny Medical Cause of Death: 1(a) Multiple injuries Circumstances and How, when and where the death came about: Unable to determine his intention 4th May 2014 Underneath Beeching Bridge, A22, East Grinstead, West Sussex Conclusion of the inquest: Alasdair Penny Jumped from the College Lane Bridge, East Grinstead onto the A22 but the evidence does not fully disclose what his intention was.
Circumstances of the Death
This case concerned a 23 year old man who on Sunday 4 May 2014 jumped a road bridge onto the road below: It had been the site of a similar suicide 3 years before (Will RAYNOR in fact the 3rd anniversary was a couple of days before this incident) and there were floral tributes to be found there and friends of the previous case had gone there. The deceased was suffering from Paranoid Schizophrenia and had various difficulties with his family, as well as a pending court case. He was refusing to take medication. In the 2 days before his death he was seen by several people loitering on the bridge. At different times, police units attended and questioned him but none found him in a condition that warranted using their 5.136 Mental Health Act 1983 powers. Eventually on 4 2014 he jumped just as a further police car approached (in a non-threatening way - i.e,, no blue lights or sirens)_ There was evidence from the Healthcare professionals as well as various police officers_
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you ANDIOR your organisations have the power to take such action
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.