Stephen Tilbury
PFD Report
Historic (No Identified Response)
Ref: 2014-0109
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Excessive vehicle speed in a residential area, despite an existing trief curb, poses a significant risk as the curb can deflect speeding vehicles onto the pavement. Physical speed reduction measures are needed.
View full coroner's concerns
Evidence was heard from eye witnesses to the collision; One witness who knows the area very well stated, am well used to tyres screeching in Crow Lane , people are always driving too quickly in Crow Lane. The Senior Investigating Officer also gave evidence to confirm that local residents are concerned about speeding in that area The Collision Investigator gave evidence to confirm that in order to reduce the risk of death in the future, steps should be taken to put something physical in place, on the road, to help ensure that vehicles are travelling at the speed limit on approach to the bend, Such physical measures might be speed bumps Another possibility that he considered was for another trief curb to be put on the south footway (mirroring the opposite curb), to deflect vehicles away from the pavement and back into the road; The Senior Investigating Officer also confirmed that measures should be taken to slow vehicles down; She confirmed that physical measures, such as speed bumps, would be Of greater value than illuminated or other signs. The presence of the trief curb had a causative impact upon the death of Lauren Brown. It was the presence of the trief curb which deflected the Ford Transit Van onto the south footway where the collision with Miss Brown occurred. Evidence was heard that the presence of the trief curb is necessary to prevent vehicles that are travelling at speed from ending Up on the railway line This was the reason why the trief curb was put in place. Again, an eyewitness commented that "on the right hand side of the road is a raised concrete kerb. This is there to stop people from crashing through the fence and onto the railway line remember the road before this kerb was here and people would come round the bend too quickly and end up on the rails_ The Collision Investigator also confirmed that one of his colleagues had dealt with a fatal case where a driver had crashed onto the railway lines_ The trief curb therefore appears to be appropriately located. Had Mr Tilbury been travelling at the required speed of 3Omph, the trief curb would not have posed a risk to him or Miss Brown;
Sent To
- London Borough of Havering
Response Status
Linked responses
0 of 1
56-Day Deadline
7 May 2014
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 1st July 2013 an investigation was commenced into the death of Stephen Michael Tilbury: On the 5th 2013 an investigation was commenced into the death of Lauren Marie Brown These deaths arose from the same facts. The investigations concluded at the end of the inquests which took place on the 7th March 2014, Conclusion of the inquests was as follows: Narrative conclusion relating to Lauren Marie Brown. Miss Lauren Marie Brown was walking along the pavement on the south footway of Crow Lane at approximately 21.50 on 28"h June 2013 The driver of a Ford Transit Van failed to negotiate a bend in the road, mounted the pavement and collided with Miss Brown, causing her fatal injuries . The driver had a blood alcohol level well in excess of the legal limit and he approached the bed at excessive speed Narrative conclusion relating to Stephen Michael On 28"h June 2013 at approximately 21.50, Mr Tilbury was driving his Ford Transit Van along Crow Lane, near the junction with Whalebone Lane, South; He failed to successfully negotiate a bend in the road_ The van mounted the pavement, collided with pedestrian, continued through a chain link fence, collided with a tree and then slid down an embankment: Mr Tilbury was not wearing a seatbelt, His blood alcohol levels were well in excess of the legal limit: He approached the bend at excessive speed. He died at the scene from his injuries.
Circumstances of the Death
Mr Tilbury was driving his Ford Transit Van at approximately 21.50 on 28"h June 2013. As he approached a bend in the road at Crow Lane (approximately 80 metres from where Crow Lane meets Whalebone Lane, South) he lost control of his vehicle and hit the trief curb on the offside of the road, (This section of Crow Lane is single carriageway): The trief curb deflected the vehicle across the road to the south footway where he mounted the pavement and collided with Miss Brown, causing her fatal injuriesHis van then continued through the chain link fence, collided with tree and slid July Tilbury: down an embankment Mr Tilbury was not wearing a seatbelt and he died at the scene Miss Brown suffered a fatal injury to her head. She was taken to the Royal London Hospital but died in the early hours of the 29" June 2013. Mr Tilbury was found to have levels of alcohol of 225mgl100mls (the legal limit for driving is 8Omgl1OOmls) He was also found by the Collision Investigator to have been travelling at a speed in excess of 4Omph: The speed limit on that section of the road is 3Omph.
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe your organisation has the power t0 take such action.
Copies Sent To
/4 [SIGNED BY CORONER] may
Inquest Conclusion
Narrative conclusion relating to Lauren Marie Brown. Miss Lauren Marie Brown was walking along the pavement on the south footway of Crow Lane at approximately 21.50 on 28"h June 2013 The driver of a Ford Transit Van failed to negotiate a bend in the road, mounted the pavement and collided with Miss Brown, causing her fatal injuries . The driver had a blood alcohol level well in excess of the legal limit and he approached the bed at excessive speed Narrative conclusion relating to Stephen Michael On 28"h June 2013 at approximately 21.50, Mr Tilbury was driving his Ford Transit Van along Crow Lane, near the junction with Whalebone Lane, South; He failed to successfully negotiate a bend in the road_ The van mounted the pavement, collided with pedestrian, continued through a chain link fence, collided with a tree and then slid down an embankment: Mr Tilbury was not wearing a seatbelt, His blood alcohol levels were well in excess of the legal limit: He approached the bend at excessive speed. He died at the scene from his injuries.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Arrange emergency temporary accommodation provision
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Domestic abuse accommodation support
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.