Leslie Pates
PFD Report
Partially Responded
Ref: 2014-0043
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
A complete breakdown in hospital and social services communication with the family occurred. The patient was discharged against family wishes with severe pressure sores and no pressure-relieving mattress.
View full coroner's concerns
During_the course of the inquest the evidence revealed matters giving rise to concern. In 27th_
Responses
Action Taken
Tameside Hospital NHS describes several actions taken to improve communication regarding discharge plans, including developing a checklist, ensuring documented evidence of discussions with patients and carers, raising the profile of the ITT team through public awareness campaigns, ensuring a social worker and Clinical Discharge Facilitator are available, and providing training to staff on discharge planning and nursing documentation. (AI summary)
Tameside Hospital NHS describes several actions taken to improve communication regarding discharge plans, including developing a checklist, ensuring documented evidence of discussions with patients and carers, raising the profile of the ITT team through public awareness campaigns, ensuring a social worker and Clinical Discharge Facilitator are available, and providing training to staff on discharge planning and nursing documentation. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mr Pollard Thank you for your letter of the 30t January 2014 setting out your concerns under Regulations 28 of the Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013. On the 29th January 2014, you held a Inquest into the death of Leslie Alfred Pates who died on the 2nd April 2013. The medical cause of death was recorded as: 1(a) Sepsis 1(b) Pressure sore 1(c) Immobility/stroke II Vascular dementia, Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, Hypertension, Stroke At the conclusion of the Inquest you set out a number of concerns_ These concerns were reported to the Trust and we are now in a position to advise you of what action has been taken to address the issues identified_
1. There has been complete breakdown in effective communication between the hospital and the family of the deceased: To improve effective communication between the Integrated Transfer Team and the patients and their immediate carers/family regarding the discharge plan, the following actions are taken: Develop a checklist to ensure all members of the Multidisciplinary Team (MDT) have engaged with patients and their family prior to discharge. being
The Team leader to ensure through the computer systems between social services and the Trust (IAS/EIS systems) that there is documented evidence that all Integrated Transfer Team (ITT) cases have been discussed with patients and their designated carers.
2. Neither the hospital staff nor the social services staff took any, or any proper, account of the wishes and views of the family prior to the discharge home of the patient: To ensure the patients ad families wishes are fully raised and given full consideration in the discharge process the following actions have been undertaken: To ensure all patients and families have opportunity to discuss plans and have a dedicated name and contact number for the social worker managing their discharge: Leaflet has been produced and is in publication process for patients and carers about "Leaving our Care" To ensure all newly appointed stafflagency workers are adequately orientated to the hospital and all procedures and policies are outlined from both Tameside MBC and Tameside Foundation Trust (TFT) to the expected standards of practice: All temporary workers located within the Transfer Team will have an induction process and complete the induction checklist within one week of commencing role. Each temporary worker will receive an induction and adequate support and documented regular supervision
3. The patient who was aged 80 years was sent home with severe pressure sores and without the facility of a pressure relieving mattress. All patients returning home with care package will have their equipment needs assessed and documented in hospital Social workers to communicate effectively with the Nurse Coordinators so that timely referrals for assessment of equipment needs can be made. The daily length of stay meetings will ensure that the checklist process for discharge is followed. A complex care plan has been formulated for all parties to agree the patient is supported and ready for home Tameside Social Services failed completely or adequately to consider the views of the family of the deceased before determining and bringing into effect a plan for his discharge: All plans of care for patients must be shared with the patient and, with patient's consent; their next of kin and agreed before discharge: Each member of the ITT should ensure all care plans are prepared accurately and presented before being discussed and shared. This will be monitored through regular supervision of Tameside MBC staff and through daily length of stay: The ITT supervisors will monitor documentation via Social worker IAS system: every fully
The Head of Patient Flow and Team Leader for ITT now have transparency ad ability to view and monitor all social worker involvement with cases through Tameside MBC IAS system. This is monitored daily for all cases known to the ITT.
5. The required 'meeting" between Social Services and the family prior to discharge hospital, simply never took place: To improve communication from the ward staff to the ITT through the induction of robust SHOP board round. A Pilot of "Sick Patients Home Other Plar" (SHOP) is in progress on two medical wards, This is to be escalated across the trust over the next 3 months and become embedded practice: This will improve ward based communication to the discharge team ad is documented. The SHOP process is a full MDT process daily where all patients are discussed and discharge plans agreed daily. This is documented and evidenced by the ITT team: In addition, the profile of the ITT team is being raised through public awareness and increased visibility and open access Creating information boards and posters to display across the wards ad departments to raise awareness of the team to allow patients, families ad carers to have easy access to the team for support and guidance in the discharge process. The team has a social worker available 6 a week to patients and relatives and a Clinical Discharge Facilitator (CDF) available seven days a week, from 0800-2000hrs to speak with patients, staff and relatives for advice CDF team are providing training to new staff on their Corporate Induction about planning discharges. ITT team are training all staff on the Nursing documentation relating to discharge and compiling a data base of all staff trained. hope that these reassurances address the issues that have been raised.
1. There has been complete breakdown in effective communication between the hospital and the family of the deceased: To improve effective communication between the Integrated Transfer Team and the patients and their immediate carers/family regarding the discharge plan, the following actions are taken: Develop a checklist to ensure all members of the Multidisciplinary Team (MDT) have engaged with patients and their family prior to discharge. being
The Team leader to ensure through the computer systems between social services and the Trust (IAS/EIS systems) that there is documented evidence that all Integrated Transfer Team (ITT) cases have been discussed with patients and their designated carers.
2. Neither the hospital staff nor the social services staff took any, or any proper, account of the wishes and views of the family prior to the discharge home of the patient: To ensure the patients ad families wishes are fully raised and given full consideration in the discharge process the following actions have been undertaken: To ensure all patients and families have opportunity to discuss plans and have a dedicated name and contact number for the social worker managing their discharge: Leaflet has been produced and is in publication process for patients and carers about "Leaving our Care" To ensure all newly appointed stafflagency workers are adequately orientated to the hospital and all procedures and policies are outlined from both Tameside MBC and Tameside Foundation Trust (TFT) to the expected standards of practice: All temporary workers located within the Transfer Team will have an induction process and complete the induction checklist within one week of commencing role. Each temporary worker will receive an induction and adequate support and documented regular supervision
3. The patient who was aged 80 years was sent home with severe pressure sores and without the facility of a pressure relieving mattress. All patients returning home with care package will have their equipment needs assessed and documented in hospital Social workers to communicate effectively with the Nurse Coordinators so that timely referrals for assessment of equipment needs can be made. The daily length of stay meetings will ensure that the checklist process for discharge is followed. A complex care plan has been formulated for all parties to agree the patient is supported and ready for home Tameside Social Services failed completely or adequately to consider the views of the family of the deceased before determining and bringing into effect a plan for his discharge: All plans of care for patients must be shared with the patient and, with patient's consent; their next of kin and agreed before discharge: Each member of the ITT should ensure all care plans are prepared accurately and presented before being discussed and shared. This will be monitored through regular supervision of Tameside MBC staff and through daily length of stay: The ITT supervisors will monitor documentation via Social worker IAS system: every fully
The Head of Patient Flow and Team Leader for ITT now have transparency ad ability to view and monitor all social worker involvement with cases through Tameside MBC IAS system. This is monitored daily for all cases known to the ITT.
5. The required 'meeting" between Social Services and the family prior to discharge hospital, simply never took place: To improve communication from the ward staff to the ITT through the induction of robust SHOP board round. A Pilot of "Sick Patients Home Other Plar" (SHOP) is in progress on two medical wards, This is to be escalated across the trust over the next 3 months and become embedded practice: This will improve ward based communication to the discharge team ad is documented. The SHOP process is a full MDT process daily where all patients are discussed and discharge plans agreed daily. This is documented and evidenced by the ITT team: In addition, the profile of the ITT team is being raised through public awareness and increased visibility and open access Creating information boards and posters to display across the wards ad departments to raise awareness of the team to allow patients, families ad carers to have easy access to the team for support and guidance in the discharge process. The team has a social worker available 6 a week to patients and relatives and a Clinical Discharge Facilitator (CDF) available seven days a week, from 0800-2000hrs to speak with patients, staff and relatives for advice CDF team are providing training to new staff on their Corporate Induction about planning discharges. ITT team are training all staff on the Nursing documentation relating to discharge and compiling a data base of all staff trained. hope that these reassurances address the issues that have been raised.
Sent To
- Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council
- Tameside NHS Foundation Trust
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 2
56-Day Deadline
30 Mar 2014
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 5th April 2013 commenced an investigation into the death of Leslie Alfred Pates dob 21st February 1932. The investigation concluded on the 29"h January 2014 and the conclusion was that he died from Natural Causes. The medical cause of death was Ia Sepsis 1b Pressure sore Ic Immobilitylstroke 2 Vascular dementia; Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, Hypertension, Stroke_
Circumstances of the Death
On the 11' December 2012 he was admitted to Tameside General Hospital Medical Assessment Unit; later being placed on wards 42 and 43. He was eventually discharged home on the 22 January 2013 against the wishes of his family. The Consultant heading up his care accepted that he did not see the patient prior to his discharge, that he had no grounds for saying that "the family were happy for him to go home and that there was no reasonable analysis made by the hospital and others as to his fitness to return home_ The social worker conceded that there had been no meeting with the family to discuss discharge (as should be the case), that matters "were not in place from a Social Services position" and that there had been no Iiaison between social services and the District Nurse teams. On the January 2013 he had to be transferred from his home to a Nursing Home and by the 17th February 2013 his condition was so bad that he was re-admitted to Tameside General Hospital by 999 ambulance_ A doctor at the hospital supplied an MCCD to the coroner which gave the cause of death on the 2nd April 2013 as sepsis when heard evidence from the consultant chest physician that he found patient on the morning of the 2nd April 2013 to be apyrexial with clean pressure sore CoRONER'S CONCERNS During_the course of the inquest the evidence revealed matters giving rise to concern. In 27th_ the my opinion there is a risk that future deaths will occur unless action is taken. In the circumstances it is my statutory duty to report to you: The MATTERS OF CONCERN are as follows.
1.There has been a complete breakdown in effective communication between the hospital and the family of the deceased_ Neither the hospital staff nor the social services staff took or any proper; account of the wishes and views of the family prior to the discharge home of the patient:
3. The patient who was aged 80 years was sent home with severe pressure sores and without the facility of a pressure relieving mattress.
4. Tameside Social Services failed completely or adequately to consider the views of the family of the deceased before determining and bringing into effect a plan for his discharge. required "meeting" between Social Services and the family prior to discharge from hospital, simply never took place:
1.There has been a complete breakdown in effective communication between the hospital and the family of the deceased_ Neither the hospital staff nor the social services staff took or any proper; account of the wishes and views of the family prior to the discharge home of the patient:
3. The patient who was aged 80 years was sent home with severe pressure sores and without the facility of a pressure relieving mattress.
4. Tameside Social Services failed completely or adequately to consider the views of the family of the deceased before determining and bringing into effect a plan for his discharge. required "meeting" between Social Services and the family prior to discharge from hospital, simply never took place:
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and | believe you have the power to take such action. It is essential that full information is passed promptly to the GP practice of a patient discharged.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Thalassaemia Society Support
Infected Blood Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Care plan failures
Haemophilia Centre Resources
Infected Blood Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Care plan failures
GMMH local structured risk assessment responsibility
Southport Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Cross-Administration Patient Safety Coordination
Infected Blood Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Central Delivery with Devolved Support
Infected Blood Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Multi-Trust Mortality Meeting Engagement
Hyponatraemia Inquiry
Poor health and social care integration
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.