Clare Dupree
PFD Report
No Identified Response
Ref: 2026-0181
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
In-cell automatic fire detection is still to be fully implemented at Eastwood Park prison and across a number of prisons in the wider prison estate; the current use of domestic smoke detectors only mitigates the risks from an in-cell fire.
View full coroner's concerns
At the start of the inquest the MOJ made an admission it said …
1. “The Ministry of Justice has determined that in-cell automatic fire detection (AFD) is necessary to minimise the risk of harm from fires.
2. As at 26th December 2022, cell 59 on Residential 6 was not and is not currently equipped with in-cell AFD
3. For those cells which do not have in -cell AFD, battery powered standalone domestic smoke detectors (DSD’s) are in place outside cell doors, including cell 59 on Residential 6. This was the position as at 26th December 2022. The use of DSD’s as a mitigatory measure was agreed in 2015, in consultation with the Crown Premises Fire Safety Inspectorate. The Ministry of Justice acknowledges that the use of DSD’s in this way is a less effective way of minimising fire risks than in-cell AFD but has adopted them after thorough consideration as being the most effective available means of reducing risk as far as practicable until the installation of in-cell AFD can be completed “ During the inquest evidence was heard from from HMPPPS - that in cell AFD’s are now planned for Eastwood Park with a start date of June 2026. I also heard about the position in relation to the prioritisation list for others in the prison estate. That said I also heard the frustration of from the CPFSI about the time this is taking to implement. The matter of concern is therefore … that in cell AFD is still to be implemented/completed at EWP prison and in addition a number of prisons across the prison estate. That the current use of DSD’s only seek to mitigate the risks from an in-cell fire.
Telephone 01275 461920 Email AvonCoronersTeam@bristol.gov.uk Website www.avon-coroner.com
1. “The Ministry of Justice has determined that in-cell automatic fire detection (AFD) is necessary to minimise the risk of harm from fires.
2. As at 26th December 2022, cell 59 on Residential 6 was not and is not currently equipped with in-cell AFD
3. For those cells which do not have in -cell AFD, battery powered standalone domestic smoke detectors (DSD’s) are in place outside cell doors, including cell 59 on Residential 6. This was the position as at 26th December 2022. The use of DSD’s as a mitigatory measure was agreed in 2015, in consultation with the Crown Premises Fire Safety Inspectorate. The Ministry of Justice acknowledges that the use of DSD’s in this way is a less effective way of minimising fire risks than in-cell AFD but has adopted them after thorough consideration as being the most effective available means of reducing risk as far as practicable until the installation of in-cell AFD can be completed “ During the inquest evidence was heard from from HMPPPS - that in cell AFD’s are now planned for Eastwood Park with a start date of June 2026. I also heard about the position in relation to the prioritisation list for others in the prison estate. That said I also heard the frustration of from the CPFSI about the time this is taking to implement. The matter of concern is therefore … that in cell AFD is still to be implemented/completed at EWP prison and in addition a number of prisons across the prison estate. That the current use of DSD’s only seek to mitigate the risks from an in-cell fire.
Telephone 01275 461920 Email AvonCoronersTeam@bristol.gov.uk Website www.avon-coroner.com
Sent To
- Ministry of Justice
Response Status
Linked responses
0 of 2
56-Day Deadline
19 May 2026
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 17th January 2023 I commenced an investigation into the death of Clare Louise Dupree. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest 17th March 2026. The conclusion of the inquest, held before a jury, was a narrative. Box 3 on the jury Record of Inquest stated… “On the 26th December 2022 Clare Louise Dupree suffered sustained inhalation of smoke in Cell 59, Residential Unit 6, at HMP Eastwood Park. The lack of Automatic in-cell Fire Detection (AFD) caused a delay in detecting the fire, which resulted in her death on 28th December 2022.” Of relevance to this report Box 4 on the jury Record of inquest stated … “...The use of DSDs (domestic smoke detectors) instead of AFDs (automatic fire detection) possibly contributed to Clare's death. The lack of AFD's caused a delay in alerting staff to the fire in Clare's cell … Clare died from sustained inhalation of smoke due to a delay in detection of fire as a result of arson.”
Circumstances of the Death
Clare was a 48 yrs old female and was taken into custody at Eastwood Park Prison on 19th November 2022, she had a history of poor mental health.
Telephone 01275 461920 Email AvonCoronersTeam@bristol.gov.uk Website www.avon-coroner.com On 26th November 2022 there was a fire in her cell, caused by a vape, staff were alerted by the DSD outside of her cell. She was removed from the cell after the fire service arrived, was taken to Southmead Hospital where she died from: 1a) Hypoxic-ischaemic brain injury, lower respiratory tract infection and multi-organ failure 1b) Inhalation of products of combustion
Telephone 01275 461920 Email AvonCoronersTeam@bristol.gov.uk Website www.avon-coroner.com On 26th November 2022 there was a fire in her cell, caused by a vape, staff were alerted by the DSD outside of her cell. She was removed from the cell after the fire service arrived, was taken to Southmead Hospital where she died from: 1a) Hypoxic-ischaemic brain injury, lower respiratory tract infection and multi-organ failure 1b) Inhalation of products of combustion
Copies Sent To
Ministry of Justice
Healthcare
Practice Plus Group
Mental healthcare
Crown Premises Fire Safety Inspectorate
Cardiff & Vale Health Board and to the following
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Communication strategy for patients and families
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
Coroner family information gaps
Clinician Attendance at Post-Mortem Discussions
Hyponatraemia Inquiry
Coroner family information gaps
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.