Recommendation IBI-11: Responding to Calls for a Public Inquiry
From Infected Blood Inquiry Final Report, published 20 May 2024.
Recommendation
(a) that a minister should retain the power to call an inquiry as the minister sees fit, in accordance with the Inquiries Act 2005 – but where a minister does not choose to do so, then:
(b) if there is sufficient support from within Parliament for there to be an inquiry, the question whether there should be one should be referred to PACAC for it to consider the question.
(c) If it appears to PACAC that there is sufficient concern to justify a public inquiry, either because what happened and why has caused concern (as the committee sees it) or there are likely to be lessons learned which may prevent similar concerns arising in future, the committee may recommend to an appropriate minister that there be an inquiry.
(d) If the minister disagrees with the recommendation, they must set out in detail and publish reasons for this disagreement which are sufficient to satisfy PACAC that the matter has been carefully and properly considered.
In brief (written by this site)
The Inquiry recommended establishing a formal parliamentary process to consider calls for public inquiries. In October 2026, the Ministry of Justice stated that work was under way to inform how the duty is used in relation to reviews going forward (Ministry of Justice, Oct 2026). In March 2026, Sir Brian Langstaff welcomed ministers' acceptance in principle of the recommendation and their commitment to update Parliament (Sir Brian Langstaff, Mar 2026). In May 2025, the UK Government stated that deciding on the referral mechanism was for Parliament, while accepting an obligation to publish reasons if ministers disagree with an inquiry recommendation (Cabinet Office response, May 2025).
AI-generated summary of the record on this page, checked by a second model and automatic checks, 14 Nov 2026. The record below is the sources' own words.
Government response
UK Government
It is clear that blood products and blood were contaminated, and despite a wealth of evidence, no action was taken to spell out the risks, and insufficient precautions were taken. It is also evident that despite these failings, no proper action was taken to investigate and understand what had happened. Understandably, a number of participants to the Inquiry have called for a recognised process in deciding whether or not there should be a public inquiry into a matter which is potentially of public concern, or from which lessons might be learned.
The Inquiry recommends that the UK Parliament should have a role in recommending the establishment of a public inquiry, and that Ministers should set out the reasons behind a decision not to hold an Inquiry. The Government welcomes these recommendations, recognising that Parliamentary Select Committees already have the power to scrutinise departments and make recommendations, and it is for Parliament to consider these recommendations.
The Government also notes that the recent report by the House of Lords Committee on Inquiries recommends that "formal implementation monitoring should be undertaken by a new, joint, select committee of Parliament: the Public Inquiries Committee". Therefore while we note the recommendations made by the Inquiry, it is for Parliament to decide whether to accept these recommendations, and decide how to fulfil recommendation 11 alongside its existing scrutiny mechanisms.
Should Parliament decide to adopt recommendation 11, the Government accepts its obligation under 11d), to set out in detail and publish reasons when it disagrees with a recommendation to establish an inquiry.
Next Steps
The Government’s response to the recommendations of the House of Lords Statutory Inquiries Committee was published on 10 February. In its response, the Government committed to providing a further update to Parliament on its intentions for wider reforms of the frameworks around inquiries.
Delivery
Ministry of Justice says in progress (12 October 2026)
But I can reassure the noble Baroness that this work is under way, and it will inform how the duty is used in relation to those reviews going forward.
From: House of Lords, Public Office (Accountability) Bill, Committee (1st day), 12 October 2026
Site note: The passage is copied unchanged from the source it cites (House of Lords, Public Office (Accountability) Bill, Committee (1st day), 12 October 2026) and was checked word for word against that document. The status is the position the speaker's own words state; where the speaker is neither a UK government department nor the body the recommendation is addressed to, the site records no status of its own.
Earlier statements on delivery (2)
Cabinet Office (28 January 2026)
I do not have a precise date for you, but that is certainly in train
Site note: The passage is copied unchanged from the source it cites (Nick Thomas-Symonds MP (Labour), then Paymaster General and Minister for the Cabinet Office, oral evidence to the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee on the work of the Cabinet Office, 28 January 2026) and was checked word for word against that document. The status is the position the speaker's own words state; where the speaker is neither a UK government department nor the body the recommendation is addressed to, the site records no status of its own.
Cabinet Office (10 February 2025)
The Government will give a further update to Parliament on this work in due course
The Government will publish guidance on inquiries for Ministers, chairs and secretaries,
including the appropriate considerations around their establishment, drawing on the helpful
work of this Committee.
Site note: The passage is copied unchanged from the source it cites (Government Response to the House of Lords Statutory Inquiries Committee report, Cabinet Office, 10 February 2025) and was checked word for word against that document. The status is the position the speaker's own words state; where the speaker is neither a UK government department nor the body the recommendation is addressed to, the site records no status of its own.
What other bodies have found
In their own words. These do not change the delivery statement above.
Infected Blood Inquiry (31 March 2026)
I welcome the Government’s acceptance in principle of Inquiry Recommendation 11 about responding to calls for a public inquiry and the commitment to provide a further update to Parliament.
From: Letter from Sir Brian Langstaff to the Minister for the Cabinet Office
Responsible bodies
Themes and tags
Who has spoken
- UK Government
Response - Ministry of Justice
Delivery statement - Infected Blood Inquiry
Finding