LGO Individual Decisions

33,513 published decisions from the Local Government & Social Care Ombudsman (Jan 2022–Feb 2026). The Local Government & Social Care Ombudsman investigates complaints about councils and registered social care providers in England. Source: lgo.org.uk.

33,513
Total Decisions
11,687
Investigated
9,465
Upheld
81%
Upheld (of investigated)
Clear

Showing 14 results matching "South Derbyshire District Council"

South Derbyshire District Council (25-010-801)
Housing Other
Decision date: 12 Jan 2026 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Allocations
Summary: We will not investigate this complaint about the Council’s decision that Miss X does not qualify for the housing register. There is insufficient evidence of fault in how the Council made its decision to justify an investigation. We will not investigate Miss X’s complaint about the Council not properly considering her first review request as the Council offered a proportionate remedy.
South Derbyshire District Council (25-017-813)
Benefits And Tax Other
Decision date: 5 Jan 2026 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Council Tax
Summary: We will not investigate this complaint about a late Council tax bill because there is a right of appeal to Valuation Tribunal.
South Derbyshire District Council (25-010-359)
Other Categories Other
Decision date: 8 Dec 2025 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Other
Summary: We will not investigate Mr X’s complaint that the Council refused to communicate with him by phone. There is insufficient evidence of fault.
South Derbyshire District Council (25-003-796)
Planning Other
Decision date: 7 Nov 2025 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Planning Applications
Summary: We will not investigate Dr Y’s complaint about the Council’s decision to approve planning permission for her neighbour’s extension. There is not enough evidence of fault in the Council’s decision making to justify our involvement.
South Derbyshire District Council (23-019-648)
Adult Care Services Upheld
Decision date: 30 Sep 2024 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Disabled Facilities Grants
Summary: Ms X complained about delays and poor-quality workmanship of a wet room she had installed under a Disabled Facilities Grant. The Council was at fault. Its contractor took too long installing the wet room and poor quality of works has led to ongoing problems and snags. The Council agreed to make a payment to Ms X to acknowledge the distress and inconvenience caused. It has also agreed to commission an independent survey of the wet room to identify and resolve any ongoing issues caused by the initial contractor’s works.
South Derbyshire District Council (23-015-574)
Planning Other
Decision date: 23 May 2024 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Enforcement
Summary: We will not investigate this complaint about changes to a planning permission. This part of the complaint is late and we have seen no reason why Mr X could not have complained to us much sooner. Also, we will not investigate his concerns about freedom of information as he has already raised this matter with the Information Commissioner’s Officer. We consider this is the appropriate body to consider this part of the complaint.
South Derbyshire District Council (22-007-183)
Environment And Regulation Upheld
Decision date: 14 Dec 2022 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Refuse And Recycling
Summary: There was fault by the Council as it missed about 15 assisted bin collections and/or returns in six months. An apology, payment and agreement to monitor collections for the next month remedies the injustice caused to Mr X.
South Derbyshire District Council (22-009-441)
Other Categories Other
Decision date: 27 Oct 2022 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Elections And Electoral Register
Summary: We will not investigate this complaint about the conduct of a local election. The actions of the Returning Officer are outside our jurisdiction.
South Derbyshire District Council (22-001-714)
Planning Other
Decision date: 26 Jun 2022 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Planning Applications
Summary: We will not investigate Mr X’s complaint about the Council’s delay in determining his planning application. This is because it would have been reasonable for Mr X to appeal to the Planning Inspectorate.
South Derbyshire District Council (21-017-128)
Planning Not Upheld
Decision date: 15 Jun 2022 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Planning Applications
Summary: Mr X complained about the Council’s decision to grant planning permission without conditions on highways and drainage, causing access issues and increasing flood risk. We find no fault in the Council’s decision making process.
South Derbyshire District Council (21-010-440)
Planning Other
Decision date: 23 Mar 2022 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Planning Applications
Summary: We will not investigate this complaint about the Council’s handling of a planning application and associated enforcement matters relating to a site next to the complainant’s home. This is because the complaint does not meet the tests in our Assessment Code on how we decide which complaints to investigate. There is not enough evidence of fault by the Council directly causing the complainant a significant injustice.
South Derbyshire District Council (21-017-644)
Environment And Regulation Other
Decision date: 18 Mar 2022 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Refuse And Recycling
Summary: We will not investigate Mr X’s complaint that the Council’s household waste bin size allocation policy penalises his family by giving them less bin space than other families. There is not enough evidence of Council fault, nor of a significant injustice caused to Mr X’s family, to warrant us investigating.
South Derbyshire District Council (21-013-471)
Environment And Regulation Other
Decision date: 25 Jan 2022 · South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Noise
Summary: Ms X complains about the Council’s response to her complaints of noise nuisance from a games area near her home. We will not investigate the complaint because we are unlikely to find evidence of fault by the Council sufficient to warrant an investigation.
South Derbyshire District Council (25-012-798)
Planning Other
· South Derbyshire Council
Subject: Enforcement
Upheld
9,465
LGO found fault with the organisation complained about.
Not Upheld
2,222
Complaint investigated but no fault found.
Closed / Other
21,826
Closed after initial enquiries, resolved early, or withdrawn.

Investigated Decisions Over Time

Excludes 21,826 closed after initial enquiries. Quarterly, by outcome.

Annual Complaints (LGO-wide)

Official annual statistics across all organisations

Year Received Investigated Upheld Upheld %
2024-25 39,320 8,596 7,104 82.6%

Decisions by Sector

Sectors by Upheld Rate

Which sectors have the highest upheld rate?

Sector Decisions Upheld Rate
Education 5,609 3,193 57%
Adult Care Services 5,168 2,094 41%
Transport And Highways 4,050 306 8%
Housing 4,021 1,407 35%
Planning 3,380 395 12%
Children S Care Services 3,280 792 24%
Environment And Regulation 3,201 592 18%
Benefits And Tax 2,378 405 17%
Other Categories 1,968 118 6%
Health 458 163 36%

Organisation Accountability

Top 20 organisations by upheld rate (minimum 5 investigated decisions). Based on 11,687 investigated decisions (excludes 21,826 closed after initial enquiries). Benchmark: 81% average across all investigated decisions. Sparklines show annual decision volumes 2022–2026.

# Organisation Trend Investigated Upheld Not Upheld Upheld Rate vs avg
1 Care UK Community Partnerships Limited 10 10 0 100% +19pp
2 Three Rivers District Council 9 9 0 100% +19pp
3 Broxbourne Borough Council 7 7 0 100% +19pp
4 St Albans City Council 7 7 0 100% +19pp
5 Burnley Borough Council 6 6 0 100% +19pp
6 Runnymede Borough Council 6 6 0 100% +19pp
7 Adur District Council 5 5 0 100% +19pp
8 Rutland County Council 5 5 0 100% +19pp
9 Vale Of White Horse District Council 5 5 0 100% +19pp
10 Swindon Borough Council 23 22 1 96% +15pp
11 Somerset Council 129 122 7 95% +14pp
12 North East Lincolnshire Council 21 20 1 95% +14pp
13 Essex County Council 421 392 29 93% +12pp
14 Derbyshire County Council 136 126 10 93% +12pp
15 Blackpool Borough Council 14 13 1 93% +12pp
16 London Borough of Lambeth 153 140 13 92% +11pp
17 London Borough of Barking & Dagenham 59 54 5 92% +11pp
18 Warrington Council 13 12 1 92% +11pp
19 Eastbourne Borough Council 12 11 1 92% +11pp
20 London Borough of Southwark 139 126 13 91% +10pp
All-organisation benchmark 81%