Value for Money
Government cyber resilience
Published 29 January 2025
7 recommendations
Cabinet Office
Cyber securityDefence and national securityDigital, data and technology
nao.org.uk
The cyber threat to UK government is severe; government must act now to protect its own operations and key public services.
Recommendations (7)
Source: NAO Recommendations Tracker · PAC follow-up below
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 1
Accepted
Work in Progress
Within six months, GSG should develop, share and start using a cross?government implementation plan for the Government Cyber Security Strategy: 2022?2030 (?the Strategy?). GSG should refresh it regularly, include how the government is responding to new and severe cyber threats not covered by the Strategy and:
? bring together a comprehensive monitoring and evaluation framework that allows GSG to measure departments? performance, track and show progress towards the Strategy?s outcomes, and evaluate what is working well or not, including an assessment of lessons learned from previous efforts to attract, upskill and retain cyber skills in government; and
? identify the priority actions the government needs to take to be cyber resilient by 2030, the government organisations that are accountable for those actions, the timescales within which those actions need to be taken,
and the extent to which those organisations have the resource and levers needed to complete their actions.
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 2
Accepted
Implemented
Within six months, GSG should set out how the whole of government needs to operate differently, and what is needed for this transformation to be effective, so that the government can achieve its goals for cyber security and resilience. GSG should work with the relevant bodies at the centre of government to develop and agree what governance, type and amount of funding, people and skills, and organisational structure and mandate will best enable government to achieve its objectives. This should include setting out how the centre of government will:
? provide different types of support, capability and guidance to departments;
? build cyber security into its digital and technology strategies, plans and activity from the outset; and
? clarify which aspects of cyber risk and resilience departments, GSG and other organisations are responsible for and when that responsibility moves from one organisation to another.
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 3
Accepted
Work in Progress
GSG should strengthen GovAssure?s focus on improving cyber resilience outcomes. GSG should:
? continue building the capacity to support departments in developing and implementing targeted improvement plans, and monitoring and evaluating progress against them;
? continue developing how GovAssure data can be used to measure departments? performance as part of its comprehensive monitoring and evaluation framework; and
? baseline government organisations? cyber resilience against organisations that are responsible for UK critical national infrastructure.
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 4
Accepted
Work in Progress
GSG should work with CDDO to take a more rigorous approach to understanding and mitigating the risk to government organisations? cyber resilience caused by legacy IT systems. Learning from GovAssure and the legacy IT risk assessment framework, this approach should:
? identify the legacy systems in use across government;
? understand the risk these legacy IT systems pose to cyber resilience, the extent of departments? remediation plans, and be risk-based when prioritising security enhancements;
? assess and strengthen the security enhancements that are in place; and
? be considered alongside GovAssure when measuring government organisations? cyber resilience and performance.
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 5
Accepted
Work in Progress
GSG should design regular communications to ensure that senior leaders and other decision-makers across government understand the cyber threat, how it is relevant to their business outcomes and what they can do about it. GSG should embed this into departments? board and programme governance.
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 6
Accepted
Work in Progress
Government departments should urgently strengthen their own governance, accountability and reporting arrangements around cyber risk. In their annual security appraisal, accounting officers should assess their progress and performance in meeting the cyber security standards set out in Functional Standard GovS 007: Security (the Security Standard), which HM Treasury mandated in 2021. To show the importance of building a cyber security culture, accounting officers should:
? ensure that membership of their most senior decision-making board includes at least one digital leader with cyber expertise and one non-executive director with cyber expertise;
? engage with GSG to agree how the department will contribute to GSG?s cross-government implementation plan;
? understand the cyber risk posed by their most critical IT systems and create and test appropriate incident response plans; and
? commission reporting that shows progress made in implementing the Strategy.
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 7
Accepted
Work in Progress
Working in alignment with GSG?s government skills strategy, departments should make and enact plans to fill the cyber skills gaps in their workforces. Within the next year, they should:
? undertake a gap analysis of their current cyber workforce to identify what skills are needed to enable effective implementation of the Strategy; and
? present clear and detailed improvement plans to GSG.
Parliamentary Committee Follow-Up
The Public Accounts Committee examined this NAO report and published its own recommendations. The government responds to PAC recommendations via Treasury Minutes.
24th Report - Government cyber resilience
Public Accounts Committee
· 9 May 2025
· 12 recommendations