Value for Money

Improving Broadband

Published 16 October 2020 12 recommendations Department for Culture, Media & Sport Digital infrastructureDigital, data and technology nao.org.uk
This report considers what the Superfast Broadband Programme has delivered and the lessons for government’s roll-out of nationwide gigabit broadband.

Recommendations (12)

Source: NAO Recommendations Tracker · PAC follow-up below
11
Accepted
1
Partially Accepted
12
Implemented
12
NAO Confirmed
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 1 Accepted Implemented
The Department should, in respect of both the Superfast and Future Programmes: a) work with suppliers and Ofcom to address customer issues with broadband and encourage take-up, to help realise the benefits from widespread broadband envisaged in its Superfast Programme’s business case and to ensure the Future Programme also achieves the benefits of gigabit-capable technology;
Page 13, paragraph 24, point a 12/2022
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 10 Accepted Implemented
• the extent to which it intends to follow an “outside-in” approach;
Page 14, paragraph 24, point f, third bullet point 12/2021
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 11 Accepted Implemented
• those local areas which will still not be covered by the final 20% of the Future Programme and any mitigations to ensure that these areas are not left behind; and
Page 14, paragraph 24, point f, fourth bullet point Q1 2023-24
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 12 Accepted Implemented
• how and when it intends to review and update these plans to ensure transparency about what it considers to be deliverable and by when.
Page 14, paragraph 24, point f, fifth bullet point 03/2021
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 2 Accepted Implemented
b) set out how it will ensure better outcomes for consumers, including any relevant learning from similar programmes, so that they have both choice and the ability to switch providers; and
Page 13, paragraph 24, point b 06/2021
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 3 Accepted Implemented
c) set out how it intends to measure the benefits of its investment, including setting programme-specific objectives as clear measures of success for its Future Programme.
Page 13, paragraph 24, point c 05/2022
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 4 Accepted Implemented
In respect of the Future Programme, it should: d) set out how it intends to improve its data, including how it will: • secure the required quality of data for identifying which areas and premises it intends to subsidise;
Page 13, paragraph 24, point d, first bullet point 06/2021
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 5 Accepted Implemented
• replicate local body knowledge and systems; and
Page 13, paragraph 24, point d, second bullet point 12/2021
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 6 Accepted Implemented
• encourage suppliers to set out their plans;
Page 13, paragraph 24, point d, third bullet point 06/2021
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 7 Partially Accepted Implemented
e) set out how it will retain local body expertise in a centralised procurement model, including how it will mitigate the risk of financial pressures on local government leading to broadband teams being disbanded;
Page 13, paragraph 24, point e 12/2021
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 8 Accepted Implemented
f) present a detailed plan and schedule, reflecting on learning from the recent pandemic to pinpoint gaps in current broadband provision, identifying: • how it will meet the proposed timeline together with additional costs and benefits of accelerating the programme;
Page 14, paragraph 24, point f, first bullet point 05/2022
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Rec 9 Accepted Implemented
• the key risks to delivery, costs and outcomes and its proposed mitigation approaches;
Page 14, paragraph 24, point f, second bullet point 06/2021

Parliamentary Committee Follow-Up

The Public Accounts Committee examined this NAO report and published its own recommendations. The government responds to PAC recommendations via Treasury Minutes.

Thirty-fifth Report - Improving Broadband
Public Accounts Committee · 8 January 2021 · 16 recommendations