Value for Money

Resilience to animal disease

Published 4 June 2025 10 recommendations nao.org.uk

Recommendations (10)

Source: NAO Recommendations Tracker · PAC follow-up below
8
Accepted
1
Partially Accepted
1
Rejected
9
In Progress
9
NAO Confirmed
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 1 Accepted Work in Progress
Defra should, over the next year: a fully integrate its understanding and assessment of risk into its process for prioritising and allocating resources across the Defra group; for animal disease resilience funding, it should support this by: ? improving its management information to give a more complete picture of what it spends on animal disease resilience; and ? ensuring a consistent approach across the Defra group for estimating the benefits of animal disease resilience investment;
Page 13, paragraph 25, rec a Q4 2026-27
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 10 Accepted Work in Progress
j work with Border Force and Port Health Authorities to ensure there are robust checks on illegally imported animal products coming through ports, both through personal and commercial import routes; this should include particular consideration of goods arriving via both these routes at Dover, due to the volume of traffic there.
Page 14, paragraph 27, rec j Q2 2026-27
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 2 Accepted Work in Progress
b support APHA to improve its systems and processes in ways that will ensure more efficient and effective responses to outbreaks; this could include providing ongoing support for APHA?s Delivering Sustainable Future programme;
Page 13, paragraph 25, rec b Q2 2026-27
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 3 Accepted Work in Progress
c work with the Veterinary Medicines Directorate to identify barriers to animal vaccine availability and develop a plan to address these barriers to ensure availability over the long-term
Page 13, paragraph 25, rec c Q4 2026-27
Animal and Plant Health Agency; Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 4 Accepted Work in Progress
Defra and APHA should, over the next 18 months: d develop a coherent, time-bound strategy and plan that sets out how they will ensure resilience to animal disease within the context of increasing risk from factors such as climate change and antimicrobial resistance; this should specify outcomes for animal disease resilience to support the effective implementation, management and scrutiny of its various commitments in this area; it should include: ? endemic and exotic diseases to ensure an integrated approach and effective use of available resources; ? how APHA?s resourcing model will evolve to cope with more frequent outbreaks; ? how digital transformation will improve efficiency and effectiveness, particularly within APHA; ? investigating alternative models of sharing responsibility and cost between government and industry; and ? dedicated resource to develop this strategy that is not diverted to disease outbreak response
Page 13, paragraph 26, rec d Q2 2027-28
Animal and Plant Health Agency; Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 5 Accepted Work in Progress
e work with stakeholders in the veterinary sector to develop a workforce strategy that addresses the challenges currently facing the veterinary workforce, particularly in government but also considering the private sector;
Page 13, paragraph 26, rec e Q4 2026-27
Animal and Plant Health Agency; Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 6 Accepted Work in Progress
f update their approach to conducting exercises to test their contingency plans so that they fully examine all aspects of the plans, including resources available ?on the ground?, and fully capture and implement lessons learned;
Page 14, paragraph 26, rec f Q4 2026-27
Animal and Plant Health Agency; Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 7 Accepted Work in Progress
g ensure their disease outbreak plans are comprehensive and up-to-date, including updating disease-specific plans where required, ensuring plans cover responding to concurrent large exotic disease outbreaks and a scenario where capacity is insufficient, and developing a contingency plan for an exotic zoonotic disease outbreak.
Page 14, paragraph 26, rec g Q4 2026-27
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 8 Rejected
On border controls, and taking account of the new sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement with the EU, Defra should, as a matter of urgency: h review whether current SPS controls are providing effective biosecurity at our borders;
Page 14, paragraph 27, rec h
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Rec 9 Partially Accepted Work in Progress
i collate and publish regular data on volumes of SPS imports and checks for animal products in each category of risk;
Page 14, paragraph 27, rec i Q4 2025-26

Parliamentary Committee Follow-Up

The Public Accounts Committee examined this NAO report and published its own recommendations. The government responds to PAC recommendations via Treasury Minutes.

52nd Report - Resilience to threats from animal disease
Public Accounts Committee · 5 November 2025 · 19 recommendations