NHS in England Closed After Initial Enquiries Search on PHSO website

Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust

P-003824 · Statement · Decision date: 25 September 2023 · View Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust scorecard
Complaint (AI summary)
Mr A complained the Trust failed to diagnose and treat a back fracture after a fall, and provided conflicting medical opinions, leading to inability to work and anxiety.
Outcome (AI summary)
The complaint was closed without investigation because the matter was suitable for legal action.

Full decision details

The Complaint

3. Mr A complains about the Trust’s care and treatment on 14 February 2020, after a fall. He says the Trust failed to correctly diagnose a fracture in his back and to give appropriate treatment for his injury. He also complains he had different medical opinions from different doctors in the Trust.

4. Mr A says this had a huge impact on him and his family. He has been unable to work since August 2021 and has struggled mentally, experiencing periods of anxiety.

5. Mr A wants the Trust to recognise that how it treated him was wrong and to realise how this affected him. He also wants financial compensation for not being able to work for the last two years, because a fracture was not properly diagnosed and treated in February 2020.

Findings

7. The Health Service Commissioners Act 1993 says we cannot investigate a complaint if there is (or was) a legal route that the complainant can (or could have) taken, unless it is (or was) not reasonable in the circumstances.

8. Mr A complains the Trust missed a fracture on his spine in February 2020. An old fracture was noted on his CT scan, but the Trust did not tell Mr A about this and he was sent away with advice to take painkillers. In August 2020 Mr A damaged his back while picking up some bags. He went to the Trust again and was told about a historic fracture which he thinks was the injury from February.

9. Mr A says the missed fracture has caused a lot of pain. He has had several meetings with different doctors from the Trust, where he has asked for second opinions.

10. Mr A may be able to make a clinical negligence claim.

11. We discussed the amounts of compensation we typically recommend if we found failings that linked to an injustice (how someone is affected by what happened). Mr A said because of his lost earnings in the last two years he would be looking to claim much more money than we would be likely to recommend. Mr A said he would look to have the case taken legally on a ‘no win no fee’ basis and had spoken to two solicitors.

12. We think Mr A’s case is suitable for legal action as it is more likely to be able to get him the financial payment he wants. It may also be able to get him the apology and service improvements he wants.

13. Mr A has until August 2024 to get legal advice and take legal action (because of the time limits for this type of claim). We do not want him to lose this opportunity. Mr A can bring the complaint back to us if he cannot take legal action or it is unable to achieve all the outcomes he wants.

Our Decision

1. We have carefully considered Mr A’s complaint about Harrogate & District NHS Foundation Trust (the Trust). Mr A could take legal action on the matter he has brought to us, so we will not investigate his complaint further.

2. We understand the events that caused Mr A to complain are very important to him. We recognise the impact the events had on him and on his quality of life.

Other Decisions About Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust

P-004377 · 28 Nov 2025
Mr Y complains on behalf of his son about Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust. He said the Trust incorrectly …
Closed After Initial Enquiries
P-004351 · 26 Nov 2025
Mrs F complains the Trust failed to identify a hepatic vein thrombosis (blood clot) between 2 and 9 January 2024.
Partly Upheld
P-004254 · 12 Nov 2025
Miss A complains that her records show that she likely did have a fracture caused by a car accident in …
Closed After Initial Enquiries
P-004136 · 22 Oct 2025
Mrs E complains about her husband's care between November and December 2023 saying staff did not treat her husband's motor …
Closed After Initial Enquiries
P-003750 · 20 Aug 2025
Mrs H complains about the care and treatment Harrogate and District NHS Foundation Trust provided to her husband, Mr H, …
Closed After Initial Enquiries
View all decisions for this organisation →