3 Accepted in Part

In future negotiations the Government should ensure that its approach to negotiating changes to tariff...

Recommendation
In future negotiations the Government should ensure that its approach to negotiating changes to tariff free access to the UK meat market is more sophisticated than just weight of gross products and can differentiate between different cuts of meat—by using a carcass weight equivalent approach or similar—to mitigate the risk that the focus of new imports entering the UK markets is on the cuts where UK producers make the majority of their profit.
Government Response Summary
The government states each FTA is bespoke and may include equivalence approaches, like Carcass Weight Equivalent, but there is no inherent advantage and final outcomes will depend on negotiations. They cite the UK-Australia trade deal includes an alternative mechanism for sheep meat to give added protections to UK producers.
Paragraph Reference
25
Government Response
Accepted in Part
HM Government Accepted in Part
Each Free Trade Agreement is bespoke and tailored to the countries and markets involved in order to achieve our objectives of securing access to high quality, good value food for consumers whilst managing the impact on UK business. This potentially includes the use of equivalence approaches (such as Carcass Weight Equivalent (CWE)) or similar. Calculating quota volumes using CWE ensures a link to the real weight of produce by adjusting the volume for bone-in or boneless cuts of meat. However, there is no inherent advantage to administering volumes in carcass weight over product weight for example, with these factors needing to be considered alongside others such as quota volumes or product specific safeguard conditions. Final FTA outcomes will depend on the context of negotiations with each trading partner. The UK-Australia trade deal includes an alternative mechanism for sheep meat to give added protections to UK producers. Under this mechanism, sheep meat quota volumes will be reduced by 25% for a year if the quota volumes are filled for two consecutive years in years 1 to 10. Additionally, if the product specific safeguard volume trigger for sheep meat is hit in any of years 11 to 15, all subsequent trigger volumes are reduced by 25%.
Timeline
Recommendation age 4.0 yrs
Report published 17 Jun 2022