17 Acknowledged

Establish protocols for Defra's professional information sharing and investigate policy leaks.

Recommendation
Defra should ensure that operational and policy decisions are clearly communicated to its arm’s-length bodies and the farming advice service in advance of them being made public. It should investigate the causes of the leaks of its proposed changes to the Capital Grants and SFI schemes and put protocols in place to support proper and professional information sharing. Details revised protocols should be set out in the response to this report. (Recommendation, Paragraph 62)
Government Response Summary
The government outlined its existing protocols for sharing sensitive information with arm's-length bodies and the Farming Advice Service in advance of public announcements, stating they regularly review these communication protocols. However, it did not commit to investigating the causes of leaks or providing details of revised protocols.
Government Response
Acknowledged
HM Government Acknowledged
Government officials mark communications handling documents with sensitive information OFFICIAL SENSITIVE and only share on a need-to-know basis for colleagues delivering the work. On the day prior to an announcement, we circulate the lines to take and handling approach more widely to Defra and arm’s length body customer/stakeholder-facing colleagues so they can prepare for the announcement. The Farming Advice Service (FAS) is provided with regular updates both in advance and following public announcements. For example, they receive embargoed Press Notices in advance of announcements from Defra’s Press Office Team, and following each announcement, key information is shared from the Farming and Countryside Programme’s Engagement team. Defra’s Farming Communications team submits contributions for the FAS monthly newsletter every month, covering a range of topics for farmers to be aware of, including announcements made in that month. The Environment Agency, Catchment Sensitive Farming (Natural England) and the Forestry Commission all work closely with the FAS; they also submit contributions including on abstraction licenses, water resources, reducing pollution & runoff, and upcoming grants for tree planting available to farmers. Prior to publication, the FAS newsletter is shared round with key external stakeholders and copy providers to ensure information is accurate. We regularly review our communications protocols to ensure we strike the right balance between providing advance information to those who need to manage sector inquiries and that we make announcements in an appropriate and timely manner.
Timeline
Recommendation age 1.0 yr
Report published 16 May 2025