31
Accepted in Part
Continue supportive compliance monitoring while boosting comprehensive and frequent farm inspections.
Recommendation
The Environment Agency and the Rural Payments Agency should continue to take an initially supportive approach when monitoring compliance, given the low levels of engagement and the fact that most farmers want to do the right thing for their soils. Follow ups will be essential to ensure that compliance breaches are being adequately addressed. If this “supportive” approach is, however, a key method of spreading awareness of farming regulations, then the inspections regime should also be boosted. We recognise that remote technologies and approaches will be able to help, and we are pleased that the EA has more funding to conduct site visits, but these still need to be more comprehensive and frequent; visiting just 4% of farms every year will not act as a deterrent to bad actors, nor help the farmers that could benefit from the “supportive” approach.
Government Response Summary
The government agrees with advice-led approaches and states enforcement occurs when advice is not acted upon. It highlights the use of earth observation technology for more efficient inspections and targeted advice, building on a successful pilot, but does not explicitly commit to boosting the overall frequency and comprehensiveness of site visits.
Paragraph Reference
107
Government Response
Accepted in Part
Government Response
Accepted in Part
HM Government
Accepted in Part
We agree that advice-led approaches help tackle soil damage by poaching of livestock and risks from soil erosion and compaction. Enforcement action will only be taken when advice isn’t acted on or pollution incidents occur. Technology is enabling more efficient inspections. We can use earth observation techniques to identify land management risks such as bare soil over winter and soil erosion. The Environment Agency can then target advice to highlight the risks of diffuse pollution from these practices. This was successful in a 2023 River Wye catchment pilot project which identified over 400 farms with bare soil over winter and we will continue this approach this year.
Timeline
Recommendation age
2.5 yrs
Report published
05 Dec 2023