33 Not Addressed

Publish clear, resourced compliance monitoring regime by 2028 for farm visits.

Recommendation
The EA and the RPA should continue with the “supportive” approach to compliance monitoring. By the end of the agricultural transition in 2028, however, Defra and these institutions should publish a clear and transparent regime of comprehensive site visits and other actions that they will take to help farmers comply with rules, prevent fraud and ensure that compliance actions issued are followed. To ensure that any new regulatory soil framework is effective, and let farmers benefit more from the “supportive” approach they are taking, the EA and RPA should be adequately resourced so that farms can expect routine visits every few years. To achieve this, the Department and the EA will need to develop ways to increase funding for compliance monitoring. (Paragraph 109) 54 Soil health Local skills and guidance
Government Response Summary
The government advocates for advice-led approaches and efficient inspections using earth observation technology to identify land management risks. However, the response does not commit to publishing a comprehensive regime of site visits by 2028, ensuring routine visits every few years, or developing ways to increase funding for compliance monitoring.
Government Response
Not Addressed
HM Government Not Addressed
We agree that advice-led approaches help tackle soil damage by poaching of livestock and risks from soil erosion and compaction. Enforcement action will only be taken when advice isn’t acted on or pollution incidents occur. Technology is enabling more efficient inspections. We can use earth observation techniques to identify land management risks such as bare soil over winter and soil erosion. The Environment Agency can then target advice to highlight the risks of diffuse pollution from these practices. This was successful in a 2023 River Wye catchment pilot project which identified over 400 farms with bare soil over winter and we will continue this approach this year.
Timeline
Recommendation age 2.5 yrs
Report published 05 Dec 2023