25
Accepted in Part
Review Research Excellence Framework criteria, ensuring transparency and considering 'originality' removal.
Recommendation
The Future Research Assessment Programme (FRAP) is consulting on reforms for the assessment of UK higher education research. It should review the Research Excellence Framework assessment criteria to assure that transparency is a prerequisite of top- scoring research. It should also consider the effects of removing ‘originality’ from the top score bracket.
Government Response Summary
The government partially accepts, stating that decisions on the next Research Excellence Framework (REF) fall to funding bodies, but the new framework will include assessment of integrity, openness, transparency, and research reproducibility, with detailed criteria developed in 2024.
Paragraph Reference
131
Government Response
Accepted in Part
Government Response
Accepted in Part
HM Government
Accepted in Part
We partially accept this recommendation. 59. Decisions on the FRAP outcomes and the shape of the next Research Excellence Framework fall within the remit of the four UK Devolved research funding bodies. The funding bodies have consulted widely within the sector during the FRAP process, both to support evaluation of the REF 2021 exercise and also on different approaches to the evaluation of research in universities. 60. The Higher Education Funding Bodies have recently, on 15 June 2023, announced the high-level framework for the next Research Excellence Framework. This includes new elements on People, Culture and Environment and Contribution to Knowledge and Understanding, where broad evidence on research environment will be sought. This evidence will include an assessment of integrity, openness and transparency and research reproducibility (where appropriate). Detailed criteria will be developed during 2024 with the assessment panels once they are appointed.
Source
Report
Sixth Report - Reproducibility and Research Integrity
10 May 2023
HC 101
Addressee Bodies
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology
Timeline
Recommendation age
3.1 yrs
Report published
10 May 2023