17 Accepted

We note the concerns expressed about indices, in that the most popular may be carbon-intensive,...

Recommendation
We note the concerns expressed about indices, in that the most popular may be carbon-intensive, and those that purport to be green may have carbon-intensive constituents. The risk remains that many consumers are unaware of the carbon- intensity of the indices that their passive investments are tracking. The Treasury and regulators should therefore ensure that all indices (whether conventional or climate- friendly) clearly set out the overall carbon footprint of the assets included within indices.
Government Response Summary
The government states that the existing Benchmarks Regulation, amended in 2019, already places regulatory requirements and disclosure standards on financial indices, including specific low-carbon benchmarks, to enhance transparency and comparability.
Paragraph Reference
137
Government Response
Accepted
HM Government Accepted
The Benchmarks Regulation places regulatory requirements on the provision and use of financial indices that are used as benchmarks. In 2019, the Benchmarks Regulation was amended to enhance the transparency and comparability of low-carbon benchmarks. The Regulation creates specific disclosure requirements and minimum standards to be used within the calculation methodology of benchmarks, and introduces two new categories of climate-related benchmark to support investors who wish to pursue climate-conscious investment strategies. This will help ensure that consumers can make informed decisions about their investments. Funds will also be in scope of the UK green finance taxonomy’s disclosure obligations. Please refer to the FCA’s response for further information.
Addressee Bodies
HM Treasury
Timeline
Recommendation age 5.3 yrs
Report published 22 Apr 2021