21 Rejected

The APHA and Chief Veterinary Officer cited the recent example of Avian Influenza.

Conclusion
The APHA and Chief Veterinary Officer cited the recent example of Avian Influenza. This is likely to be categorised as a level three outbreak. While the APHA said that it had coped well in managing this outbreak it had to deprioritise its other work. In particular, it had meant delaying its ongoing research programme. The APHA set out that it currently has seven long-term research workstreams. It said that 36% of the milestones across these workstreams had been delayed due to challenges with capacity and the need to divert laboratory capacity to meet outbreak requirements.39 The APHA explained the vital importance of this ongoing research in horizon scanning and keeping animal diseases out of the UK.40
Government Response Summary
The government disagrees with the committee’s conclusion, stating that Defra already highlights animal disease threats in the National Risk Register and National Security Risk Assessment, and has various existing risk assessment and surveillance mechanisms in place.
Government Response
Rejected
HM Government Rejected
1.1 The government disagrees with the Committee’s recommendation. 1.2 The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) already highlights the threat from animal diseases in the National Risk Register (NRR). In the most recent Register, Defra has updated with additional threats identified as being the highest impacts for the different livestock sectors, including African horse sickness and African swine fever. Defra will continue to contribute actively to NRR processes. 1.3 The National Security Risk Assessment (NSRA) covers all possible biological threats, risks to infrastructure and security and deliberate threats, including animal health. The same scoring methodology applies to all threats, weighted to prioritise public health and environmental impact. Animal diseases score less highly against threats where high numbers of human fatalities or long-term environmental impacts are likely. 1.4 The effective action provided by Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA) Weybridge is one reason why animal health risk scores as it does. The science that takes place there – and across the country – is a strong mitigation, controlling and reducing threat to the public and environment. These threats are regularly reviewed and added to as new threats emerge. 1.5 Defra has its own risk assessment process for more immediate biological threats and consequential impact. Monthly risk reporting (for animal, plant and invasive species threats) informs the department’s internal risk management processes. 1.6 Defra Chairs the Human and Animal Infections Risk & Surveillance group (HAIRS), which was active throughout the COVID-19 pandemic providing risk assessments for zoonotic and reverse zoonotic threats from SARS-CoV-2. The chair participants in the government’s Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (SAGE), and the Advisory Committee on Dangerous Pathogens where new and emerging zoonotic disease threats are raised. 1.7 Defra co-funds the International Natural Hazard Forward Look, providing weekly expert advice to government on emerging hazards overseas. Defra funds the development of a public facing platform improving international communication of significant threats.
Addressee Bodies
HM Treasury
Timeline
Recommendation age 3.7 yrs
Report published 16 Nov 2022