15
Two further groups that were largely excluded from support were freelancers and owner-managers of companies.
Recommendation
Two further groups that were largely excluded from support were freelancers and owner-managers of companies. Freelancers generally have short-term contracts with employers and as a result many might not have been on a company’s PAYE system at the cut-off point for furlough. HM Treasury said that was aware of the issues, but that the lack of data held by HMRC and the fact that the tax system wasn’t designed to regularly capture information on such people made it particularly difficult to bring freelancers into the scheme. Some 0.4 million freelancers may have missed out on support from the 32 C&AG’s Report, para 14 33 Qq 73, 79 34 Public Accounts Committee, Oral Evidence: HM Revenue & Customs 2019–20 Standard Report, HC 690, Q 13 35 Qq 73–75, C&AG’s Report paras 2.9–2.10 14 Covid-19: Support for jobs first schemes.36 We also asked about owner-managers of companies who may have been excluded. HMRC explained that owner-managers qualify for the furlough scheme to the extent that they pay themselves through their PAYE system. It acknowledged that many owner-managers opted to pay themselves a small amount in this way, and rely predominantly on dividend income. HMRC maintained, however, that the schemes were not aimed at supporting investors for the loss of dividend income and that it did not hold sufficient information from tax return data to be able to distinguish between what is investment income and what is income in lieu of salary. We asked HMRC whether other sources of government data could be used to verify the eligibility for the schemes from those groups currently excluded; for example, information held by Companies House might distinguish between different types of dividend income. It said that this was something it had looked at closely over the years from a tax perspective but had not found a way of distinguishing between the different types of dividend income.37 Changes to the schemes created uncertainty
Government Response
A response document is linked to this report, dated 25 March 2021. Response attribution to this conclusion has not been verified. Read the response document.
Source
Committee
Public Accounts Committee
Inquiry
COVID-19: Support for jobs
Report
Thirty-fourth Report - Covid-19: Support for jobs
20 Dec 2020
HC 920
Addressee Bodies
HM Treasury
Timeline
Recommendation age
5.7 yrs
Report published
20 Dec 2020