Andrew Dean
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2023-0178
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 28 Jul 2023
Sent To
Response Status
Responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
28 Jul 2023
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Coroner’s Concerns
Following his arrival at HMP Lewes on 24 March 2021, Mr Dean was offered and attempted to make his initial ‘first night’ phone call but did not manage to speak to anyone. Over the next 36 hours, he made requests of prison staff for another opportunity to make a phone call, which were refused. During the same period, his partner tried to contact the prison through the prison switchboard, but was not able to make any contact with him. In his suicide note to his partner, Mr Dean wrote “I tried to get to talk to you but these lot here wouldn’t let me.” I am concerned that there are no clearly defined processes to ensure that new prisoners can successfully make first contact with family members (when this does not take place on the first night) and for logging and handling incoming calls to the central switchboard from family members with concerns about a prisoner’s safety and/or requesting a welfare check. Following the inquest, I gave the Ministry of Justice an opportunity to address these concerns by providing further evidence of any new procedures that have been put in place since Andrew Dean’s death, but they declined to do so. In my view, these are matters that require further consideration by the Ministry of Justice and HMP Lewes to avoid a risk of future deaths through self-harm or suicide. I refer to the enclosed letter from the solicitors for Mr Dean’s partner dated 19 May 2023.
Responses
HMP Lewes has a local instruction in place for first-night phone calls and has issued immediate guidance to staff, including a published notice, on recording and acting on welfare calls from families. HMPPS is providing funding to roll out electronic logging of calls to all prisons by March 2024, with HMP Lewes receiving on-site support in December 2023.
AI summary
View full response
Dear Mr Spence,
Thank you for your Regulation 28 report of 2 June 2023 addressed to HMP Lewes and the Ministry of Justice following the inquest into the death of Andrew Dean at HMP Lewes on 26 March 2021. I am responding on behalf of HMPPS as Director General of Prisons. I am grateful to you for granting an extension for the response and apologise for the late return.
I know that you will share a copy of this response with the family of Mr Dean, and I would like to express my condolences for their loss. Every death in custody is a tragedy and the safety of those in our care is my absolute priority.
Following evidence heard at the inquest you have raised two concerns which I will address in turn. Your first concern is about the process for ensuring that new prisoners can successfully make first contact with family members. The national policy provides for an exception to the monitoring arrangements that must be put in place for prisoner calls for “at least one initial phone call to be made by prisoners on the first night in Reception, if available, or else in the first night location, in line with paragraph 2.42 of PSI 07/2015 – Early Days in Custody”, and requires Governors to make local arrangements to facilitate this. I acknowledge that the policy does not cover what to do when contact cannot be made on the first night, but it is clearly within the spirit of the policy that this exception should continue to apply until at least one successful call has been facilitated. I would expect Governors to make sure that this occurs, and we will make this clear in the policy when it is next revised.
I have been assured by the Governor of HMP Lewes that there is now a specific checklist in use for reception and first night processes which includes ensuring that an initial phone call is given to all new arrivals before they are located onto a residential wing. The checklist includes a space to record the reasons why an action has not been completed and what will be done to rectify it. If a prisoner is unable to make their initial phone call or if the call is missed or unanswered, another phone call is facilitated the following day.
Your second concern is about the process for logging and handling incoming calls to the central switchboard from family members with concerns about a prisoner’s safety and/or requesting a welfare check. Whilst there is an existing requirement in our Strengthening Family Ties Policy Framework for prisons to have such a system, I regret to say that many prisons have found this hard to deliver consistently in practice.
In order to rectify this from 2020-22 we funded the charity Pact (through our innovations grant competition) to work with a number of pilot prisons to develop a toolkit of guidance and resources to support consistent and effective family engagement in safety processes, including recording, responding to and acting on safer custody concerns. Electronic logging of safer custody concerns was piloted in three prisons, and the more robust recording process produced significant improvements in recording and an increase in the number and proportion of calls from families that are returned.
In light of this we are providing additional funding to Pact in 2023-24 and working with them to roll out the processes developed during the pilot to all prisons in England and Wales by March 2024. This includes the electronic logging of calls. Pact will be providing on site support to eight (geographically dispersed) prisons and the Group Safety Leads from the relevant and neighbouring prison groups will attend these prisons alongside Pact staff and participate in the upskilling sessions that they offer using the toolkit developed during the pilot, so that they are equipped to share the learning and to support the prisons in their groups that will not be receiving direct support from Pact. HMP Lewes will be one of the prisons receiving on site support from Pact – this is scheduled for December 2023.
In the meantime, the prison have informed Operational Support Grade (OSG) staff that all calls received from family members, friends and members of the public regarding the welfare of a prisoner must be recorded within the Comms log and the information must be passed to the duty Orderly Officer or the night Orderly Officer immediately so that a welfare check can be carried out. There should always be an OSG working in the Comms room, however, in case of unforeseen circumstances, a notice to all staff has also been published setting out the actions staff must take when a call is received regarding the welfare of a prisoner.
Thank you again for bringing your concerns to my attention. I trust that this response provides assurance that action is being taken to address the matters that you have raised.
Thank you for your Regulation 28 report of 2 June 2023 addressed to HMP Lewes and the Ministry of Justice following the inquest into the death of Andrew Dean at HMP Lewes on 26 March 2021. I am responding on behalf of HMPPS as Director General of Prisons. I am grateful to you for granting an extension for the response and apologise for the late return.
I know that you will share a copy of this response with the family of Mr Dean, and I would like to express my condolences for their loss. Every death in custody is a tragedy and the safety of those in our care is my absolute priority.
Following evidence heard at the inquest you have raised two concerns which I will address in turn. Your first concern is about the process for ensuring that new prisoners can successfully make first contact with family members. The national policy provides for an exception to the monitoring arrangements that must be put in place for prisoner calls for “at least one initial phone call to be made by prisoners on the first night in Reception, if available, or else in the first night location, in line with paragraph 2.42 of PSI 07/2015 – Early Days in Custody”, and requires Governors to make local arrangements to facilitate this. I acknowledge that the policy does not cover what to do when contact cannot be made on the first night, but it is clearly within the spirit of the policy that this exception should continue to apply until at least one successful call has been facilitated. I would expect Governors to make sure that this occurs, and we will make this clear in the policy when it is next revised.
I have been assured by the Governor of HMP Lewes that there is now a specific checklist in use for reception and first night processes which includes ensuring that an initial phone call is given to all new arrivals before they are located onto a residential wing. The checklist includes a space to record the reasons why an action has not been completed and what will be done to rectify it. If a prisoner is unable to make their initial phone call or if the call is missed or unanswered, another phone call is facilitated the following day.
Your second concern is about the process for logging and handling incoming calls to the central switchboard from family members with concerns about a prisoner’s safety and/or requesting a welfare check. Whilst there is an existing requirement in our Strengthening Family Ties Policy Framework for prisons to have such a system, I regret to say that many prisons have found this hard to deliver consistently in practice.
In order to rectify this from 2020-22 we funded the charity Pact (through our innovations grant competition) to work with a number of pilot prisons to develop a toolkit of guidance and resources to support consistent and effective family engagement in safety processes, including recording, responding to and acting on safer custody concerns. Electronic logging of safer custody concerns was piloted in three prisons, and the more robust recording process produced significant improvements in recording and an increase in the number and proportion of calls from families that are returned.
In light of this we are providing additional funding to Pact in 2023-24 and working with them to roll out the processes developed during the pilot to all prisons in England and Wales by March 2024. This includes the electronic logging of calls. Pact will be providing on site support to eight (geographically dispersed) prisons and the Group Safety Leads from the relevant and neighbouring prison groups will attend these prisons alongside Pact staff and participate in the upskilling sessions that they offer using the toolkit developed during the pilot, so that they are equipped to share the learning and to support the prisons in their groups that will not be receiving direct support from Pact. HMP Lewes will be one of the prisons receiving on site support from Pact – this is scheduled for December 2023.
In the meantime, the prison have informed Operational Support Grade (OSG) staff that all calls received from family members, friends and members of the public regarding the welfare of a prisoner must be recorded within the Comms log and the information must be passed to the duty Orderly Officer or the night Orderly Officer immediately so that a welfare check can be carried out. There should always be an OSG working in the Comms room, however, in case of unforeseen circumstances, a notice to all staff has also been published setting out the actions staff must take when a call is received regarding the welfare of a prisoner.
Thank you again for bringing your concerns to my attention. I trust that this response provides assurance that action is being taken to address the matters that you have raised.
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 29 March 2021 I commenced an investigation into the death of Andrew DEAN aged 50. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 31 March 2023. The jury recorded a conclusion of SUICIDE.
Circumstances of the Death
On 26th March 2021 at approximately 10.11am in cell A3-10 at HMP Lewes, Andrew Dean was found with a ligature around his neck . He was treated at the scene by prison staff, healthcare staff and paramedics. Andrew Dean was declared dead at 11.27am at HMP Lewes.
Copies Sent To
3. Practice Plus Group
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes with this PFD
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Computerise system for managing missing persons and casualty information
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Extend computerisation to all police forces for shared information access
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Establish common telephone numbers for public major incident information
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Review railway emergency planning, including survivor after-care and bereaved support
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Ensure readily available designated and trained Family Liaison Officers at local level
Macpherson Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Include racism awareness and cultural diversity training for Family Liaison Officers
Macpherson Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.