Margaret Rodgers

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2025-0096
Date of Report 19 February 2025
Coroner Susan Ridge
Coroner Area Surrey
Response Deadline est. 16 April 2025
All 1 response received · Deadline: 16 Apr 2025
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Pressure ulcer risk assessments are not yet consistently embedded in the Emergency Department, and the ward continues to experience insufficient nursing staff levels for acutely ill patients.
View full coroner's concerns
The court heard that whilst the Trust has implemented a number of recommendations arising out of the patient safety review following Mrs Rodgers death, a number have yet to be resolved in particular: a. NICE and the National Wound Care Strategy guidance is that patients admitted to hospital have a pressure ulcer risk assessment within 6 hours of admission. This means that the first assessment will often need to be undertaken in the Emergency Department (ED). The court heard that the work to ensure that the ED completes such assessments is ongoing and not yet embedded and that there are practical difficulties, for example when ED patients were located on corridors.

b. The court also heard that in December 2023 to January 2024, the period of Mrs Rodgers admission, the hospital was experiencing a high level of operational pressures and that on occasions the ward itself had insufficient nursing staff levels to meet the demand of acutely ill patients with high dependency needs. The Trust is undertaking a review of the staffing template for the ward, but that work is not complete and not yet incorporated into the budget.

The coroner is concerned that in not completing the above recommendations arising out of the patient safety review, the Trust is placing patients at risk of early death.
Responses
Surrey Sussex NHS Trust NHS / Health Body
15 Apr 2025
Action Taken
Surrey & Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust outlines actions already in place: Purpose T training to improve pressure ulcer risk assessment in the ED, monthly pressure ulcer audits, weekly monitoring of patients with extended stays in ED, and safer staffing huddles. It also describes current staffing levels on Nutfield ward with actions to increase staffing based on acuity. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Madam

Re: Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths – Margaret Rodgers

Thank you for your Report to Prevent Future Deaths (hereafter “Report”) dated 19 February 2025 concerning the death of Margaret Rodgers. In advance of responding to the specific concerns raised in your Report, I would like to express my deep condolences to Margaret's family and loved ones. Surrey & Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust are keen to assure the family and the Coroner that the concerns raised about Margaret's care and the circumstances surrounding her death have been listened to and reflected upon.

The first concern raised was as follows: 'NICE and the National Wound Care Strategy guidance is that patients admitted to hospital have a pressure ulcer risk assessment within 6 hours of admission. This means that the first assessment will often need to be undertaken in the Emergency Department (ED). The court heard that the work to ensure that the ED completes such assessments is ongoing and not yet embedded and that there are practical difficulties, for example when ED patients were located on corridors.'

The Trust has considered this concern carefully and we enclose a copy of our Emergency Department action plan, with reference to the pertinent points below. This action plan has been in place since May 2024 and was implemented to assist with extended patient stays in the Emergency Department (ED) in a post-covid environment.

An Associated University Hospital of Brighton and Sussex Medical School

1) Purpose T (Pressure Ulcer Risk Primary or Secondary Evaluation Tool) training

Purpose T is a nationally used tool to identify patients who are at high risk of developing pressure damage. Once a patient is identified as high risk, Purpose T prompts a set of assessments which need to be carried out by the nurse caring for the patient, including history of pressure damage/ulcers, nutritional intake, diabetes, perfusion, moisture damage and sensory perception. It also prompts nurses to consider whether the patient has capacity if they refuse to be assessed, and acting in the patient’s best interests if they are unable to consent to examinations and assessments.

Purpose T is a more in depth tool to use with greater consideration of a patient’s individual risk factors than, for example, the Waterlow score.

2) Cerner prompts and ClinOps

Any patient tasks/assessments that have not been completed are flagged as outstanding and create a pop-up reminder for anyone accessing the patient’s records on Cerner. For example, if the Purpose T assessment has not been completed then Cerner will prompt the nurse that it needs to be carried out when they access the records.

In addition to individual reminders, an overview of every ward and patient is available on the Ward View Nursing Production Board on ClinOps, which is overseen by Matrons and ward managers. This is a projection board which shows every patient who is breaching for any reason and is mainly utilised by managers to have oversight of the whole ward/department. The board highlights outstanding tasks for each patient, which are seen as an overview bar flagged red.

Matrons monitor the Ward View Nursing Production Board to ensure “every day is a green day”, whereby the expectation is that by the end of a nursing shift all tasks/action for the nurse’s patients should be green (i.e. completed). When commencing a new shift and taking over care of patients from another member of staff, the same list will form the nurses to do list for that patient.

It is important to note that patients receiving “corridor care” are always allocated to a nurse. The allocation is to the same ratio of staff to patients as it is if the patient was in the main Emergency Department. Similarly, the projection board will flag to management any outstanding tasks or assessments for corridor care patients in the same way would if the patient was located elsewhere in the hospital.

3) Train the trainer programme and a targeted teaching approach

All new ED staff receive training on pressure damage and pressure care as part of their mandatory training when they commence work at the Trust. However, it is recognised that nursing staff cannot be removed from ED to attend training sessions as easily as they could be on inpatient wards. When Purpose T was first introduced an intensified training programme was included in ED which allowed nursing staff to be trained alongside their day to day work. This

An Associated University Hospital of Brighton and Sussex Medical School

targeted approach included having a Practice Development Nurse on the shop floor in ED for two weeks to assist staff as they carried out their assessments and familiarised themselves with the new system. Train the trainer allows for clinical staff to be trained in certain competencies and to then train their colleagues utilising their new skills, and has been completed for bands 3-
7.

In addition, Purpose T also has a guidance section to assist in completing the assessments.

All ED staff have completed Purpose T training, including those employed via agency.

4) Nurse Quality Rounds These are designated rounds at 2 hourly intervals involving the band 7 nurse in charge, Matron and PDN (all three are not required for the round). They do an eyeball assessment on every patient, including those receiving corridor care, with the aim of supporting staff to ensure tasks and assessments are completed. The purpose of the round is to provide an additional level of safety netting as they may pick up something that a less experienced nurse might miss. Junior staff can also ask questions and seek guidance on any assessment their patient needs which they are unclear about.

The Practice Development Nurses in ED are supernumerary (do not have their own caseload of patients). They monitor and provide support to nursing staff to complete assessments that are outstanding. PDNs will also look at accuracy of any assessments undertaken.

The expectation is either the Matron or PDN will oversee that all patients are assessed as required and they receive their medication.

5) Planned audits to monitor progress relating to compliance in the ED

At present the systems referred to above are only available as a live version and so we aren’t able to audit compliance currently. We are working with the Trust’s informatics team to build a report whereby compliance can be monitored and audited.

The second concern was as follows: 'The court also heard that in December 2023 to January 2024, the period of Mrs Rodgers admission, the hospital was experiencing a high level of operational pressures and that on occasions the ward itself had insufficient nursing staff levels to meet the demand of acutely ill patients with high dependency needs. The Trust is undertaking a review of the staffing template for the ward, but that work is not complete and not yet incorporated into the budget.'

1) NHS England mandates evidence-based decision making for safe and effective staffing across all NHS organisations. All Trusts are required to conduct a biannual review of their ward establishments using the Safer Nursing Care Tool. At SASH, we have been carrying out this review on all wards for the past 18 months. While the results of the review and any necessary

An Associated University Hospital of Brighton and Sussex Medical School

staffing increases have not yet been reflected in the ward budgets, Nutfield Ward has addressed this by incorporating additional shifts into the roster template and utilising temporary staffing.

2) Staffing levels on Nutfield ward are 5 qualified nurses and 3 non-qualified staff during the day, and 3 qualified and 3 non-qualified at night. We have already increased the night rota to have an extra nursing assistant than the template allows and this was recognised through the need for acuity, and we allow this as a cost pressure to maintain patient safety. The matrons assess the acuity on wards on a daily basis and will use clinical decision making to ensure that wards are safe, if there are any concerns they will escalate to senior management and additional staff will be requested for that shift if necessary. We are also able to move staff to work on different wards if acuity requires it.

The Trust holds twice daily safer staffing huddles, attended by the Head of Nursing or a matron representative. During these meetings, each division reports staffing levels, mitigation actions taken, and any remaining gaps. The staffing situation is reviewed using the Safe Care Live system to identify potential cross-divisional moves or the need for temporary staffing. If these options are insufficient, corporate nursing teams are deployed to provide clinical support. The meeting also reviews staffing for the next day and on Fridays the weekend staffing is also considered. If staffing issues cannot be resolved, they are escalated to the Chief Nurse for further action.

The Trust would like to thank you again for bringing these issues to our attention and should you require any further clarifications, please do not hesitate to contact us via our legal services department.
Sent To
  • Surrey and Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust
Response Status
Linked responses 1 of 1
56-Day Deadline 16 Apr 2025
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
An inquest into Mrs Rodgers death was opened on 25 July 2024. The inquest was resumed on 27 January 2025 and concluded on 19 February 2025.

The medical cause of Mrs Rodgers’ death was:

1a.Congestive Cardiac Failure 1b Aortic Stenosis and Urinary Tract Infection
2. Rib and Spinal Fractures, Decubitus Ulcer (operated) and Frailty of Old Age

A narrative conclusion was recorded at Box 4 of the Record of Inquest as follows:

On 3 December 2023, Margaret Kathleen Rodgers had a fall at her home in Warlingham Surrey. She was taken to hospital the same day and found to have sustained rib fractures and spinal fracture and was admitted to East Surrey Hospital. Mrs Rodgers developed hospital acquired pneumonia during her admission for which she was treated. On 14 December 2023 she was found to have an unstageable or advanced sacral pressure ulcer, its development and progress had not been identified until that point. As a result Mrs Rogers required two surgical procedures, on 21 December and 27 December 2023, under general anaesthetic to treat the infected ulcer. Whilst in hospital Mrs Rodgers developed a urinary tract infection and this together with preadmission aortic stenosis and cardiac failure led to her death from congestive cardiac failure on 12 January 2024 at East Surrey Hospital Redhill. Both Mrs Rodgers trauma injuries which resulted in immobility adding to her risk of pneumonia and the development in hospital of the advanced sacral ulcer which required surgery more than minimally contributed to her death in that they impacted on her physical reserves which were already undermined by her existing heart failure and frailty.
Circumstances of the Death
See narrative conclusion above.
Copies Sent To
10 Signed Susan Ridge S K Ridge H.M Assistant Coroner for Surrey Dated this 19th day of February 2025
Inquest Conclusion
On 3 December 2023, Margaret Kathleen Rodgers had a fall at her home in Warlingham Surrey. She was taken to hospital the same day and found to have sustained rib fractures and spinal fracture and was admitted to East Surrey Hospital. Mrs Rodgers developed hospital acquired pneumonia during her admission for which she was treated. On 14 December 2023 she was found to have an unstageable or advanced sacral pressure ulcer, its development and progress had not been identified until that point. As a result Mrs Rogers required two surgical procedures, on 21 December and 27 December 2023, under general anaesthetic to treat the infected ulcer. Whilst in hospital Mrs Rodgers developed a urinary tract infection and this together with preadmission aortic stenosis and cardiac failure led to her death from congestive cardiac failure on 12 January 2024 at East Surrey Hospital Redhill. Both Mrs Rodgers trauma injuries which resulted in immobility adding to her risk of pneumonia and the development in hospital of the advanced sacral ulcer which required surgery more than minimally contributed to her death in that they impacted on her physical reserves which were already undermined by her existing heart failure and frailty.
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Quarterly assessment of staffing levels against population needs
Brook House Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
Ensure senior manager presence and accessibility to staff
Brook House Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
Pressure damage risk assessment
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Falls prevention plans
Staffing and skills mix review
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
Safe staff numbers and skills
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
Responsibility for regulating and monitoring compliance
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Care home staffing levels
NHS Litigation Authority Improvement of risk management
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Care home staffing levels

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.