Rifky Grossberger

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2020-0070
Date of Report 11 March 2020
Coroner ME Hassell
Response Deadline est. 3 June 2020
All 2 responses received · Deadline: 3 Jun 2020
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Insufficient communication of blind cord dangers to new parents, absence of a national safety leaflet, and missed opportunities for healthcare professionals to provide warnings contributed to the risk.
View full coroner's concerns
Before Rifky became entangled in the metal blind cord, her parents were unaware of its potential danger. The instruction leaflet provided with the blinds had long since been discarded and so they did not see this.

I asked Rifky’s mum what would have been the most useful source of warning, and she thought the leaflets she was given after Rifky was born, and also her healthcare professionals.

Professor Powis, I have attempted to locate a national leaflet, but so far unsuccessfully. It occurs to me that you may have input into local leaflets.

the midwives and district nurses who look after new mums and their babies are well placed to offer advice, but may need a reminder to warn of this particular danger.

I appreciate that new parents receive a lot of paperwork and a lot of information generally. That can be overwhelming of course, but I am sure that methods could be devised of delivering such safety advice that would make this situation less likely in the future.

The NHS website would also be a good place to provide this information, though it might not have assisted in this case, as Orthodox Jewish families do not necessarily access the internet.
Responses
NHS England NHS / Health Body
11 Mar 2020
Noted
NHS England highlights the existing advice available on the NHS Choices website and the role of Health Visitors in delivering the Healthy Child Programme. PHE aims to reduce preventable accidents as part of the national priority on Best Start in Life (2020-2025) through the modernisation of the Healthy Child Programme. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Ms Hassell Re: Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths – Rifky Grossberger who died on 5 August 2019. Thank you for your Regulation 28 Report (hereafter the ‘report’) dated 11 March 2020 concerning the tragic death of Rifky Grossberger on 5 August 2019. Firstly, I would like to express my deep condolences to Rifky’s family and all those touched by her death. Your report concludes that Rifky’s death was a result of an accident. Her medical causes of death were hypoxia and asphyxia. Following the inquest, you asked NHS England and Improvement (hereafter ‘NHSEI’) to address your concern regarding the need to find methods of delivering safety advice in an easily accessible format. This could be in the form of local and national leaflets to provide parents with the safety advice they need to look after their new born baby. There is advice available on the NHS Choices website on ligature risks

specifically mentions blind safety. You also asked NHSEI to address your concern around the need for healthcare professionals such as midwives and district nurses who look after new mums and their babies to be reminded of this particular danger. We have consulted with Public Health England (hereafter ‘PHE’) who have advised that the national Healthy Child Programme (HCP) published by the Department of Health and Social Care, the universal public health programme for 0-19 year olds and their parents/carers, recommends that home safety information is discussed with families from birth and throughout the first 5 years. The Healthy Child Programme (0-
5) is led and delivered by Health visitors. Health visitors are specialist public health nurses, who are the lead professionals working with children 0-5 years. They deliver Professor Stephen Powis National Medical Director NHS England & NHS Improvement Skipton House 80 London Road London SE1 6LH 27th May 2020

evidence based public health interventions and are skilled in identifying issues early, determining potential risks, and providing early intervention to prevent issues escalating. Health visitors deliver the five mandated health reviews which include:
• 28/40 weeks of pregnancy
• 10-14 days post birth
• 6-8 weeks
• 1 year
• 2.5 years

PHE sets out more specific guidance on the role of the health visitor in the Six High Impact Areas which support local delivery of the HCP. High Impact Area five focuses on managing minor illnesses, reducing accidents and outlines how health visitors provide evidence-based safety advice to parents, including through child health clinics, baby groups and other parenting activities. PHE has worked with the RoSPA and CAPT to publish a report on reducing unintentional injuries in and around the home among children in 2018. This highlighted the most prevalent causes of unintentional injury hospital admissions and preventable death and serious long-term harm, including strangulation, and made recommendations around accident prevention at the local level. Moving forward, PHE has outlined an aim to reduce preventable accidents as part of the national priority on Best Start in Life (2020-2025). It aims to achieve this through the modernisation of the Healthy Child Programme which is taking place between 2020-2023. Thank you for bringing these important patient safety issues to my attention and please do not hesitate to contact me should you need any further information.
Royal College of Nursing Education
20 Apr 2020
Action Taken
The RCN has reviewed and strengthened its guidance about the potential risks of strangulation and suffocation on its clinical webpages for Health Visitors, Midwives, School Nurses, Children’s Nurses, Neonatal Nurses and General Practice Nurses. This matter has also been brought to the attention of members through Forums and social media platforms. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mr Hassell

Re: Regulation 28 Prevention of Future Deaths report - Rifky Grossberger (died
05.08.19)

This letter is in response to your request to Regulation 28: Prevention of Future Deaths report that was received by the Royal College of Nursing on March16th
2020. I am sorry to hear about the tragic circumstances relating to the death of Rifky Grossberger.

Your report states that ‘ … the midwives and district nurses who look after new mums and their babies are well placed to offer advice, but may need a reminder to warn of this particular danger.’ In preparing this response, we have consulted with our members that span our range of Children and Young People Forums, and our Professional Leads for Public Health, Midwifery, Children & Young People and Primary Care.

Midwives and Health Visitors routinely provide new parents with written information about a range of issues, including safety in the home. Discussions around safety is an integral part of the national Healthy Child Programme of contacts with the family, that is undertaken by the Health Visitor throughout the child’s early years.

Royal College of Nursing 20 Cavendish Square London W1G 0RN Dame Donna Kinnair Chief Executive & General Secretary Telephone 020 7647 3781 Email

Executive Assistant:

Telephone

Email

The Healthy Child Programme for the early life stages focuses on a universal preventative service, providing families with a programme of screening, immunisation, health and development reviews, supplemented by advice around health, wellbeing and parenting. The safety aspects of discussions with parents includes the potential risk of strangulation and suffocation, with Health Visitors highlighting and providing resources from the Child Accident Prevention Trusti and NHS online advice for new parentsii.

In considering your report, we have reviewed and strengthened our guidance about the potential risks of strangulation and suffocation on our clinical webpages for Health Visitors, Midwives, School Nurses, Children’s Nurses, Neonatal Nurses and General Practice Nurses. Further to this, we have also brought this matter to the attention of our members through Forums and their social media platforms.

I trust that our response gives some assurance that safety advice is an integral part of the Healthy Child Programme, and highlights the steps that the Royal College of Nursing has taken to bring this issue to the attention of our members who provide care to babies, children and their families.
Sent To
  • NHS England
  • Royal College of Nursing
Response Status
Linked responses 2 of 2
56-Day Deadline 3 Jun 2020
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 6 August 2019, one of my assistant coroners, Sarah Bourke, commenced an investigation into the death of Rifky Grossberger, aged 1 year. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 14 January 2020. I made a determination at inquest that death was the result of an accident.

I apologise for the delay in sending this prevention of future deaths report. I had some difficulty in identifying the correct recipients. It is my hope that by writing to you both, there is the potential to help parents, carers and their babies across the country, not just locally.
Circumstances of the Death
Soon after 6pm on Wednesday, 31 July 2019, Rifky Grossberger stood up in her cot and became entangled in a metal blind cord. Her mother found her with it around her neck shortly afterwards and called emergency services. She was resuscitated but died five days later. Her medical cause of death was:

1a hypoxia 1b asphyxia
Copies Sent To
Professor Chris Whitty, Chief Medical Officer for England Hackney Safeguarding Children Board Hackney Child Death Overview Panel Health and Safety Executive
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Formalise Community Vaccine Equity Networks
COVID-19 Inquiry
Poor prevention and early intervention
Improve Vaccine Uptake Monitoring and Evaluation
COVID-19 Inquiry
Poor prevention and early intervention
Open Registration
Infected Blood Inquiry
Poor prevention and early intervention
Monitor Brook House contract performance robustly
Brook House Inquiry
Poor prevention and early intervention
Review and reduce cell lock-in periods
Brook House Inquiry
Poor prevention and early intervention

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.