Malika Shamas and Haider Ali
PFD Report
Historic (No Identified Response)
Ref: 2020-0034
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Inadequate and poorly located beach signage, insufficient surveillance, and lack of warnings contributed to fatalities, suggesting a need for improved information boards and increased beach patrol presence.
View full coroner's concerns
1. The inadequacy of the signage. Tendring District Council asserted that this equates to national standards but the court had qualms about the effectiveness of the existing signage.
2. The Danger sign by the relevant groyne was difficult to read. The wording and layout could be improved and maybe such notices by each groyne would assist. There was vivid evidence from the young victims’ mother of the swirling nature of the currents around the relevant groyne
3. Mindful that there had been a previous teenage drowning fatality at Clacton beach near the pier, warning notices by the pier might assist.
4. The Beach Information notice on Clacton’s West Beach contains a great deal of important information for beach users but some of the information was written in small text and hence difficult to read. The court wondered indeed how many passers by actually read the information. The council could look into the improvement of these notices and whether there should be more of them along this stretch of beach. Perhaps there could be some more child friendly information boards.
5. The beach patrol officer was 395 metres away from the fatality incident and was unable even with the use of binoculars to discern the nature of the incident.. More extensive surveillance would help on such a busy stretch of beach.
6. Perhaps more liaison with the RNLI which provides beach safety measures on some beaches would benefit the council’s efforts to provide beach safety.
2. The Danger sign by the relevant groyne was difficult to read. The wording and layout could be improved and maybe such notices by each groyne would assist. There was vivid evidence from the young victims’ mother of the swirling nature of the currents around the relevant groyne
3. Mindful that there had been a previous teenage drowning fatality at Clacton beach near the pier, warning notices by the pier might assist.
4. The Beach Information notice on Clacton’s West Beach contains a great deal of important information for beach users but some of the information was written in small text and hence difficult to read. The court wondered indeed how many passers by actually read the information. The council could look into the improvement of these notices and whether there should be more of them along this stretch of beach. Perhaps there could be some more child friendly information boards.
5. The beach patrol officer was 395 metres away from the fatality incident and was unable even with the use of binoculars to discern the nature of the incident.. More extensive surveillance would help on such a busy stretch of beach.
6. Perhaps more liaison with the RNLI which provides beach safety measures on some beaches would benefit the council’s efforts to provide beach safety.
Sent To
- Tendering District Council
Response Status
Linked responses
0 of 1
56-Day Deadline
2 Apr 2020
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 12 August 2019 I commenced an investigation into the deaths of 14 year old Malika Shamas and 18 year old Haider Ali. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 17 February 2020. The conclusions of the inquests were that both died as a result of an accident. The causes of death were respectively 1a) Drowning and 1a) Pneumonia and Brain damage 1b) Drowning
Circumstances of the Death
The brother and sister got into difficulties while bathing in the sea, near a groyne, at Clacton-on-Sea on 8 August 2019. They had travelled along with other family members from their home in Luton for a day at the seaside. In 2018 there had been a previous drowning fatality incident on Clacton beach
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Review CCTV monitoring SIA licence requirements
Manchester Arena Inquiry
Unregulated recreation safety
Establish standard for event healthcare services
Manchester Arena Inquiry
Unregulated recreation safety
Mandatory Ambulance Liaison Officer at events
Manchester Arena Inquiry
Unregulated recreation safety
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.