Andrew Dickson
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2018-0296
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 16 Mar 2019
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Critical information about suicidal ideation from telephone triage is not reliably transferred to the doctor's screen for face-to-face appointments, creating significant safety risks for vulnerable patients.
View full coroner's concerns
In the circumstances it is my statutory to report to you. Notwithstanding the obvious significance of the information provided to the practice by telephone on 12th February 2018 when an appointment with a GP was sought on the basis that Mr Dickson had been having suicidal thoughts, the evidence before the court was that whilst this information is made available to the telephone triage doctor by way of alert note, the same text is not incorporated in to the screen which a doctor subsequently undertaking a face-to-face appointment sees: This raises the following matters of concern:- The safety of the computer system as currently operated appears to be prefaced on the telephone triage doctor the same clinician who sees the patient at a subsequent face-to-face consultation, and remembering the content of the alert note despite having had to undertake a multitude of other tasks in the meantime; In the alternative, the onus is likely to fall on the patient (or his her representative or carer) to repeat information in the course of the consultation which may already be in the practice' s knowledge as a result of an earlier telephone call to an administrative member of staff, and which the patient (carer or representative) is likely to assume is already in the doctor' $ possession; The system a5 currently operated appears likely to create additional risk in a group practice (in circumstances where the telephone triage doctor may be based in a different location from the doctor undertaking a subsequent consultation), and where patients may be vulnerable or reluctant to engage with a doctor for any reason:
Responses
Action Planned
Stockport Medical Group will use a new EMIS template when booking patients onto the triage list to ensure clinical information is visible and auditable. Training on the new template is scheduled for reception supervisors over the next 4 weeks, who will then train staff at each site. The practice has also requested that EMIS automate information transfer from triage slots into clinical notes. (AI summary)
Stockport Medical Group will use a new EMIS template when booking patients onto the triage list to ensure clinical information is visible and auditable. Training on the new template is scheduled for reception supervisors over the next 4 weeks, who will then train staff at each site. The practice has also requested that EMIS automate information transfer from triage slots into clinical notes. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear RECEIVED Re: Andrew Arthur DICKSON 1 9OcT 2018 Your Ref: 9588/CH We write in response to your letter dated 3r September 2018 enclosing a Regulation 28 report following the inquest into the sad death of Mr Dickson: We note the matters of concern stated in report and would like to outline the action Stockport Medical Group has opted to undertake in response in order to ensure patient safety in the future The partners of the practice have discussed this matter at length and we accept the need for a robust system to record clinical information from reception or the triage list in the patient records_ This information needs to be readily visible to any doctor that may then subsequently see the patient after a triage assessment; regardless of their location, to ensure a clear handover of clinical information and that an appropriate assessment is carried out: There also needs to be an audit trail, should there be a need for scrutiny as to individual actions and specific timeframes Currently, the information recorded by receptionists in relation to triage calls is only visible to the triage doctor if he or she specifically finds the patient on the triage list and hovers over the slot with a mouse cursor: The information then briefly appears: This often includes a telephone contact number to help the doctor managing the triage list on that However, this information does not appear in the patient'$ clinical records: The partners' discussion centred around the need to achieve a balance between the need for all pertinent clinical information to be visible in the clinical records on the one hand, and the need to avoid unnecessary or administrative entries that can clog Up the notes and may potentially make it more difficult for a clinician to be able to identify relevant clinical information: We decided that it would be unreasonable and potentially unsafe to expect staff taking these calls, who are not medically trained, to decide what information is clinically relevant: It was therefore agreed that the practice should adopt a policy that all information recorded by reception staff from patients or carers' initial calls, along with any subsequent notes made by the triage doctor, should be recorded in the clinical notes. These notes are available for clinicians to consult across all practice locations: Ite/4 17th Sir, the day.
have instructed staff to use a template that we have added to EMIS for booking patients onto the triage list: An example of this system is enclosed: The template contains free text data which can be saved onto the clinical records: Since do not contain coded problem headings, they can also be used by non-clinical staff. The only aspect that can be coded is if the patient is 'signposted' to other services such as community physiotherapy: Once saved, are readily visible on the clinical notes and subject to an audit trail, should this be required. have organised training with the reception supervisors in order to ensure that this new EMIS template is being used whenever patients are booked onto the triage list. This training is scheduled to take place over the next 4 weeks: Our reception supervisors will subsequently inform and train staff at each of our 3 sites, explaining that this is now the standard format for adding patients onto the triage list; We therefore expect that all notes will now appear on the EMIS clinical records Our practice currently uses the EMIS Web clinical system which is used nationally: This system does not currently have the means to automatically information across from Or appointment slots into the clinical notes. We consider that it would be preferable for this to be automated, removing the manual part of the process outlined above: We have written to EMIS on 21s September 2018 (reference ECR 10381933) requesting this addition to their software. We have highlighted why there is a need for this and the potential implications ofan omission of this software capability, as clearly outlined in your letter: We recognise that software changes and improvements in systems of this scale may take some time. We intend to adhere to the above policy pending a suitable adaptation to the EMIS software. trust the above is satisfactory: Please contact me if you require any further information on the measures we have implemented or this matter in general: This letter has been approved by all members of the partnership.
have instructed staff to use a template that we have added to EMIS for booking patients onto the triage list: An example of this system is enclosed: The template contains free text data which can be saved onto the clinical records: Since do not contain coded problem headings, they can also be used by non-clinical staff. The only aspect that can be coded is if the patient is 'signposted' to other services such as community physiotherapy: Once saved, are readily visible on the clinical notes and subject to an audit trail, should this be required. have organised training with the reception supervisors in order to ensure that this new EMIS template is being used whenever patients are booked onto the triage list. This training is scheduled to take place over the next 4 weeks: Our reception supervisors will subsequently inform and train staff at each of our 3 sites, explaining that this is now the standard format for adding patients onto the triage list; We therefore expect that all notes will now appear on the EMIS clinical records Our practice currently uses the EMIS Web clinical system which is used nationally: This system does not currently have the means to automatically information across from Or appointment slots into the clinical notes. We consider that it would be preferable for this to be automated, removing the manual part of the process outlined above: We have written to EMIS on 21s September 2018 (reference ECR 10381933) requesting this addition to their software. We have highlighted why there is a need for this and the potential implications ofan omission of this software capability, as clearly outlined in your letter: We recognise that software changes and improvements in systems of this scale may take some time. We intend to adhere to the above policy pending a suitable adaptation to the EMIS software. trust the above is satisfactory: Please contact me if you require any further information on the measures we have implemented or this matter in general: This letter has been approved by all members of the partnership.
Sent To
- Edgeley Medical Centre
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 2
56-Day Deadline
16 Mar 2019
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 2"d March 2018, Rachel Galloway, Assistant Coroner, opened an inquest into the death of Andrew Arthur Dickson who died on 15th February 2018 30 years. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest which heard on 13"h August 2018_ At the end of the inquest, determined that Mr Dickson sustained fatal injuries having jumped from a viaduct to his death. recorded a conclusion of Suicide_
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you and vour organisation have the power to take such action.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Healthcare trust risk information visibility
Southport Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records
Improve perinatal mortality recording
Morecambe Bay Investigation
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records
Detainee Capture and Condition Records
Al-Sweady Inquiry
Inaccurate and inaccessible patient records
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.