John Nichols
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2017-0344
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 1 Apr 2018
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The fire drills policy lacked safeguards to adequately monitor residents, especially those with dementia, before, during, and after drills.
View full coroner's concerns
The MATTERS OF CONCERN is as follows: That the Fire Drills Policy currently in place does not include sufficient safeguards to ensure that residents (and in particular those with dementia) are sufficiently monitored before, during, and after fire drills.
Responses
Action Taken
Kings Lynn and Eastgate Residential Care Homes engaged a fire consultant to observe fire drills, amended the pre-assessment form to include questions on distress caused by fire alarms, and revised the PEEP form. They have also amended the Group's Fire Drill Procedure and implemented relevant training. (AI summary)
Kings Lynn and Eastgate Residential Care Homes engaged a fire consultant to observe fire drills, amended the pre-assessment form to include questions on distress caused by fire alarms, and revised the PEEP form. They have also amended the Group's Fire Drill Procedure and implemented relevant training. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Madam Regulation 28 Report: John Nichols refer to the Regulation 28: REPORT TO PREVENT FUTURE DEATHS dated 2 November 2017. In accordance with 'Section 7 , Your response' we set out below details of the action to address your concerns set out in 'Section 5, Coroner' we have taken currently s Concerns' , namely That the Fire Drills in place does not include sufficient safeguards to ensure that residents (and in particular those with dementia) are sufficiently monitored before, and after drills. Background The elements of the fire drill which impact on the routines of residents "normal" operations f a care home are identified over and above the as follows: sounding of the fire alarm , which could cause distress. 2 The automatic closing of fire doors, which could cause distress It should be noted automatic ofthe fire doors takes approximately that physical harm is minimal. This twenty seconds and the risk of time is based on a Doorgard being affixed Staff attending to the Fire Panel for & few minutes, which could delay residents when requested through the call bell system. attendance to We have also considered the sounding of the fire alarm the weekly testing of fire alarm The drill policy of European Healthcare Group PLC currently in place states that before the Home Manager is required to identify those residents that drill; fire drill: need to be looked after during the Action Kings Kings Thorpe Policy during fire key daily The closing during fire fire
Kings Lynn and Eastgate Residential Care Homes Kettlewell Lane, Kings Lynn; Norfolk, PE3O 1PH Tel: 01553 769098 Fax: 01553 818704/818 WWwehgukcom We have taken the following steps: Engaged the services of Steve Wiltshire AIFSM ("SW"), a Fire Consultant to observe and comment on the Group'$ fire drill procedures We enclose a copy of his report for your consideration ( The Report" ). Internally reviewed and amended where necessary the Group' s Fire Drill Procedure, the Pre- Assessment Procedure and the Personal Emergency Evacuation Plan ("PEEP") after carefully considering SW's Report and reviewing the of the residents. Evaluation We would make the following points regarding SW's Report: We consider that the observation of the fire drill at Bay Court; another of the Group'$ homes of the same type as Lynn Residential, was not a problem because the fire procedures are exactly the same across all the homes When the new procedures are bedded in we will undertake an operational audit at Lynn again. SW had seen the Regulation 28 Report prior to his visit and was aware of the concerns We discussed the mistakes observed during the drill set out in the Fire Evacuation Record Tree Court (see Appendix 2) with SW and were considered minor: We will implement his recommendations: Horizontal evacuation is documented in the Fire Risk Assessments ("FRA"). A copy of the FRA for Lynn is attached (Appendix 3). Please note that Lynn Residential Home is a single storey building: The Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans ("PEEPs") have been amended, see below. [The Fire Procedures set out by SW are already incorporated into those set out in our FRAs: We do not call 999 until we have verified that there is a fire:] Residents' bedroom doors are checked on a fortnightly basis to ensure that they close and operate properly as part of the maintenance procedures at the homes: The correct of doors is important at all times and not just during fire drills. We consider that the issue of distress arising from the sounding of the fire alarm should be raised with the next of kin at the pre-assessment stage, before the person is admitted to the home The alarm sounds regularly and should this cause distress, we may be unable to meee the needs of that person: We have amended the Pre-Assessment Form to make the enquiries: We enclose a copy ofthe new Pre-Assessment Form for consaderateoprGeer your (see Appendix 4). During the trial period of a resident stay, we will monitor their reaction to the sounding of the fire alarm and adjust the PEEP as required: We enclose a copy of the revised PEEP for your consideration (see Appendix 5). safety Tree Kings Kings fire Bay they fully Kings Kings fire closing
Lynn and Eastgate Residential Homes Kettlewell Lane, Lynn; Norfolk; PE3O 1PH Tel: 01553 769098 Fax: 01553 818704/818 WWehqukcom For those residents who already been admitted months, into our homes we will, over the next consult with next of kin and residents to see if require fire drill: assistance during a [The Fire Drill Procedures have been amended to make clear that the bells continues as normal:] Consequently, answering of Nursecall to reflect the we have amended the Group's Fire Drill Procedure changes to the above. This will be implemented across all the homes Procecher relevant training at each site. The annual Fire Awareness updaterWill also changes made. We enclose a copy of the revised Fire Drill re-iterate the (see Appendix 6). Procedure for your consideration We would be pleased to receive your comments on the actions addressed your concerns set out in the taken and confirmation that we have Regulation 28 Report.
Kings Lynn and Eastgate Residential Care Homes Kettlewell Lane, Kings Lynn; Norfolk, PE3O 1PH Tel: 01553 769098 Fax: 01553 818704/818 WWwehgukcom We have taken the following steps: Engaged the services of Steve Wiltshire AIFSM ("SW"), a Fire Consultant to observe and comment on the Group'$ fire drill procedures We enclose a copy of his report for your consideration ( The Report" ). Internally reviewed and amended where necessary the Group' s Fire Drill Procedure, the Pre- Assessment Procedure and the Personal Emergency Evacuation Plan ("PEEP") after carefully considering SW's Report and reviewing the of the residents. Evaluation We would make the following points regarding SW's Report: We consider that the observation of the fire drill at Bay Court; another of the Group'$ homes of the same type as Lynn Residential, was not a problem because the fire procedures are exactly the same across all the homes When the new procedures are bedded in we will undertake an operational audit at Lynn again. SW had seen the Regulation 28 Report prior to his visit and was aware of the concerns We discussed the mistakes observed during the drill set out in the Fire Evacuation Record Tree Court (see Appendix 2) with SW and were considered minor: We will implement his recommendations: Horizontal evacuation is documented in the Fire Risk Assessments ("FRA"). A copy of the FRA for Lynn is attached (Appendix 3). Please note that Lynn Residential Home is a single storey building: The Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans ("PEEPs") have been amended, see below. [The Fire Procedures set out by SW are already incorporated into those set out in our FRAs: We do not call 999 until we have verified that there is a fire:] Residents' bedroom doors are checked on a fortnightly basis to ensure that they close and operate properly as part of the maintenance procedures at the homes: The correct of doors is important at all times and not just during fire drills. We consider that the issue of distress arising from the sounding of the fire alarm should be raised with the next of kin at the pre-assessment stage, before the person is admitted to the home The alarm sounds regularly and should this cause distress, we may be unable to meee the needs of that person: We have amended the Pre-Assessment Form to make the enquiries: We enclose a copy ofthe new Pre-Assessment Form for consaderateoprGeer your (see Appendix 4). During the trial period of a resident stay, we will monitor their reaction to the sounding of the fire alarm and adjust the PEEP as required: We enclose a copy of the revised PEEP for your consideration (see Appendix 5). safety Tree Kings Kings fire Bay they fully Kings Kings fire closing
Lynn and Eastgate Residential Homes Kettlewell Lane, Lynn; Norfolk; PE3O 1PH Tel: 01553 769098 Fax: 01553 818704/818 WWehqukcom For those residents who already been admitted months, into our homes we will, over the next consult with next of kin and residents to see if require fire drill: assistance during a [The Fire Drill Procedures have been amended to make clear that the bells continues as normal:] Consequently, answering of Nursecall to reflect the we have amended the Group's Fire Drill Procedure changes to the above. This will be implemented across all the homes Procecher relevant training at each site. The annual Fire Awareness updaterWill also changes made. We enclose a copy of the revised Fire Drill re-iterate the (see Appendix 6). Procedure for your consideration We would be pleased to receive your comments on the actions addressed your concerns set out in the taken and confirmation that we have Regulation 28 Report.
Sent To
- Eastgate Residential Care Homes
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 2
56-Day Deadline
1 Apr 2018
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 21/06/2017 14.11 commenced an investigation into the death of John NICHOLS
85. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 27/10/2017 15.00. The conclusion of the inquest was: 1a Intracranial haemorrhage 1b Fall lc
85. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 27/10/2017 15.00. The conclusion of the inquest was: 1a Intracranial haemorrhage 1b Fall lc
Circumstances of the Death
Mr Nichols died on 18th June 2017 at Queen Elizabeth Hospital, King'$ Lynn as a result of sustaining a head injury on 13th June 2017 shortly after a fire drill at his care home, when a fire door closed between him and his carer whilst he was being assisted back to his room:
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you (and/or your organisation) have the power to take such action:
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Require external wall information for fire services
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Fire risk assessment failures
Train fire personnel on external wall fire risks
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Fire risk assessment failures
Require evacuation plans for high-rise buildings
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Fire risk assessment failures
Require compliant flat entrance doors where unsafe cladding exists
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Fire risk assessment failures
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.