Silvia Taylor

PFD Report Partially Responded Ref: 2014-0327
Date of Report 16 July 2014
Coroner Martin Fleming
Coroner Area Surrey
Response Deadline est. 10 September 2014
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The service failed to act promptly on unsuccessful attempts to contact Mrs. Taylor and did not communicate these critical difficulties to her family, delaying potential intervention.
View full coroner's concerns
During the inquest the following concerns arose: ‐ 

 Although initial reports from Mrs Taylor gave no concern for the  need for urgent medical attention, unsuccessful attempts to contact  her were not acted upon for several hours.   The difficulties in establishing telephone contact with Mrs Taylor,  were not conveyed to the family. 

I would ask that you consider giving further consideration to the no  speech call procedures in relation to after hours support.
Responses
Care UK Private Sector
Action Taken
Care UK reviewed and updated its policy regarding procedures when telephone calls to patients needing assessment by the out-of-hours GP service are unanswered. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Sirs Mrs Silvia Taylor (deceased) Regulation 28 report: action to prevent future deaths We are writing in response to HM Coroner's Regulation 28 report following the Inquest into the sad death of Mrs. Silvia Taylor on 7th February, 2013 (copy attached for reference). Paragraph 5 of the report states: "During the inquest the following concerns arose Although initial reports from Mrs Taylor gave no concern for the need for urgent medical attention, unsuccessful attempts to contact her were not acted upon for several hours: The difficulties in establishing telephone contact with Mrs Taylor were not conveyed to the family: would ask that you consider giving further consideration to the no speech call procedures in relation to after hours support Following receipt of the report we have reviewed and updated the policy as to how our current services should proceed if we make a telephone call to a patient and there is no reply (policy attached for reference)_ The policy has addressed two points where a patient may need contact from Care UK's out of hours GP service: Scenario 1 is where a patient's phone number has been received by the out of hours service because the patient needs further assessment over the telephone by a clinician: 2_ Scenario 2 is where the patient s phone number has been received by the out of hours GP service from the NHS 111 service because the NHS pathways algorithm has determined that the patient needs an appointment to be seen face to face Care UK Clinical Services Limited Primary Care Division: Registered In Ergland No 3462881 Registered Office: Connaught 850 The Croscent; Colchester Business Park, Colchester, Essex CO4 9QB Housc,

This policy change has happened in consultation with Care UK's senior doctors: National Medical Directors for Practices and for Health in Justice, Medical Director for Primary Care and the Regional Medical Directors within Primary Care This policy was ratified at the Clinical Quality and Goverance Committee Meeting for Healthcare on 22nd September;
2014.
Sent To
  • Bracknell Forest Council
  • Harmoni South East
  • Woking Borough Council
Response Status
Linked responses 1 of 3
56-Day Deadline 10 Sep 2014
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 14/2/13 I opened the inquest into the death of Silvia Eileen Taylor,  who at the date of her death was 81 years old.   The inquest was resumed  and concluded on 14/7/14.  I found that the cause of death to be: 

1a – Ischaemic Heart Disease 

I concluded with a narrative conclusion as follows:  On 8/2/13, Silvia Eileen Taylor was found to have died at her home  address of ischaemic heart disease.  She had earlier activated her  emergency pendant for the attendance of the doctor, although several  subsequent attempts by the doctors to contact her by telephone were  unsuccessful.  It is found more likely than not, that earlier medical  intervention would not have affected the outcome. 

RT4159
Circumstances of the Death
On 7/2/13 at 10.06pm Silvia Eileen Taylor activated her care alarm at her  home address resulting in an immediate response from the Emergency  Response Officer.  Mrs Taylor complained of stomach pains and  requested a Thamesdoc.  The family was contacted soon after and  informed that a GP was to attend within 25 minutes.    Subsequently  Thamesdoc doctors made several unsuccessful attempts to contact Mrs  Taylor by phone at her home address.  Upon the arrival of the  Thamesdoc doctor at her home address at 2.30am her lack of response  prompted him to contact the family to request a key to the premises.  The  family found upon arrival that they could not enter via the front door  with the key since it had been bolted internally.  The GP left to attend an  emergency call after discussing matters with the family.  Subsequently  the police were called and entry was forced at 4am when Mrs Taylor was  found to have died on her bed.
Copies Sent To
Chief Coroner  Signed: Martin Fleming DATED this 16‐Jul‐2014
Inquest Conclusion
On 8/2/13, Silvia Eileen Taylor was found to have died at her home  address of ischaemic heart disease.  She had earlier activated her  emergency pendant for the attendance of the doctor, although several  subsequent attempts by the doctors to contact her by telephone were  unsuccessful.  It is found more likely than not, that earlier medical  intervention would not have affected the outcome. 

RT4159
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Separate SIO and Family Liaison Officer roles
Daniel Morgan Panel
Emergency family notification
GP Notification of Death Circumstances
Hyponatraemia Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Candour about harm
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Death in Custody Checklist
Baha Mousa Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Computerise system for managing missing persons and casualty information
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Extend computerisation to all police forces for shared information access
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Emergency family notification
Establish common telephone numbers for public major incident information
Ladbroke Grove Inquiry
Emergency family notification

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.