Akua Anokye-Boateng
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2014-0211
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 4 Jul 2014
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The report raises concerns about the use of NSAIDs in children with sickle cell disease, specifically regarding the potential for a single dose to cause GI damage and the lack of clear guidance on gastro-intestinal protection measures.
View full coroner's concerns
In the circumstances it is my statutory to report to you: The MATTER OF CONCERN is as follows_ Expert evidence was heard from an experienced academic pathologist that one dose of NSAID was sufficient to damage (he Gi mucosa in children; which; coupled with a presumed Helicobacter Infection; led in this case to the perforation. The consultant paediatrician with responsibility for haemoglobinopathies was unaware of the risk Of a single dose in the past and gave evidence that Ibuprofen was an important drug in the management of sickle cell patients, having less side effects than opiates_ He reported that it is not current practice to routinely give gastro-intestinal protection when NSAIDs are used briefly in children with sickle disease. Thus it is unclear what is best practice or whether the scientific evidence suggests that guidance is needed for clinicians about further precautions or prevention such as Proton pump inhibitors being routinely used alongside NSAIDs_in children_to minimize the risk of similar deaths day She duty
Responses
Action Planned
The MHRA will publish an article in the September 2014 Drug Safety Update to remind healthcare professionals of existing SPC information regarding GI side-effects of NSAIDs. They will also strengthen the patient information for all NSAIDs regarding GI risk, with changes implemented within 12 months. (AI summary)
The MHRA will publish an article in the September 2014 Drug Safety Update to remind healthcare professionals of existing SPC information regarding GI side-effects of NSAIDs. They will also strengthen the patient information for all NSAIDs regarding GI risk, with changes implemented within 12 months. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Dr Harris Thank you for your letter dated 9th 2014 and bringing to attention the circumstances of the death of Miss Anokye-Boateng (Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths) On reading your Prevent Future Deaths (PFD) report identified two distinct points for MHRA to address_ These are: a) the apparent lack of awareness amongst healthcare professionals that there is the potential for serious gastrointestinal toxicity to occur with short-term use of NSAIDs; and b) whether gastrointestinal protective agents should be routinely used alongside NSAIDs in children. The MHRA has sought the advice of its Pharmacovigilance Expert Advisory Group of the Commission on Human Medicines regarding any necessary actions to address these concerns_ set out below the actions_ a) Healthcare professional awareness of the potential for serious gastrointestinal toxicity to occur with short-term use of NSAIDs: Following a number of national and Europe-wide reviews of the gastrointestinal safety of NSAIDs, a set of elements was agreed for inclusion in the Summary of Product Characteristics (SPC) for all non- selective NSAIDs available as prescription only medicines (POM): These key elements include contraindications to use and extensive warnings in relation to the gastrointestinal side effects_ MHRA also formulated a set of elements for inclusion in the SPC for ibuprofen-containing products available in the UK without prescription as Pharmacy (P) or General Sales List (GSL) medicines_ attach a copy of the key elements for POM non-selective NSAIDs and also for P and GSL ibuprofen: These were implemented for all relevant products (including products authorised for use in children) in the UK in 2008_ CPRD NIBSC MHRA Your May my Akua key key
Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency The SPCs for POM; P and GSL NSAIDs including ibuprofen state the following in section 4.4 (Special warnings and precautions for use): 'GI bleeding, ulceration or perforation; which can be fatal, has been reported with all NSAIDs at any time during treatment; with or without warning symptoms or a previous history of serious Gl events. The MHRA and its independent experts consider that this statement in the SPC is sufficient to alert readers to the possibility of serious gastrointestinal side effects occurring early in NSAID treatment: However we acknowledge that healthcare professionals do not always read the SPC before prescribing, particularly when prescribing commonly used medicines, and your report highlights that there are some healthcare professionals who are unaware of this fact Therefore we propose to inform and remind healthcare professionals about this through an article in the September 2014 issue of our monthly bulletin Safety Update'_ b) Should gastroprotective agents be routinely given alongside NSAIDs in children? The SPCs for all POM non-selective NSAIDs include a recommendation to use gastro-protective agents (proton pump inhibitors or misoprostol) when prescribing NSAIDs to those at high risk of gastrointestinal side-effects, as follows: 'The risk of GI bleeding, ulceration or perforation is higher with increasing NSAID doses, in patients with history of ulcer, particularly if complicated with haemorrhage or perforation (see section 4.3) , and in the elderly. These patients should commence treatment on the lowest dose available. Combination therapy with protective agents (e.g: misoprostol or proton pump inhibitors) should be considered for these patients, and also for patients requiring concomitant low dose aspirin, or other drugs likely to increase gastrointestinal risk (see below and 4.5). This recommendation is also included in the SPCs for POM non-selective NSAIDs authorised for use in children: For non-prescription use of ibuprofen in adults and children, a recommendation for the concurrent use of PPIs is not included in the SPC_ For those NSAIDs available over-the-counter; the authorised doses are lower than prescription-only products, and the indications only cover short term self-limiting conditions which do not require diagnosis & supervision by a medical practitioner_ Patients (or parents of patients) at high risk of gastrointestinal side effects who purchase ibuprofen as an over-the-counter product are advised in the package leaflet to discuss taking these products with their doctor s0 that can be properly advised about the need for gastro-protective medicines to be taken at the same time_ After careful consideration of the details of the case presented in your PFD report; the MHRA and its independent experts do not consider that this case changes the overall benefit-risk balance of ibuprofen in children or warrants a change to the current warnings about the need for gastro-protective agents for prescription only medicines_ However, for all NSAIDs we will be strengthening the information for patientslparents provided in the package leaflet on the risk and recognition of gastrointestinal side effects and the action should take_ In summary, in response to your report under Regulation 28 to Prevent Future Deaths, concerning the death of Miss Akua Anokye-Boateng, MHRA will take the following action to minimise risk from the gastrointestinal side-effects of NSAIDs: CPRD NIBSC MHRA 'Drug they they help
Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency Proposed action Purpose of proposed action Timeline for action Drug Safety Update (DSU) To remind healthcare professionals of information Publication in the article already included in the SPCs for NSAIDs, that: September 2014 issue (wwmhragov ukldrugsafet the GI side-effects of NSAIDs can be serious and of DSU yupdate) life-threatening: Fatalities have been reported: serious Gl side-effects can occur with short-term use of NSAIDs serious Gl side-effects can occur in people who may be considered to be at low risk; including in children Strengthen the Patient To strengthen the NSAID product information Review and implement Information for all NSAIDs provided to patientslparents on the risk changes within 12 with regards to GI risk_ To aid patientlparent recognition of gastrointestinal months. side-effects and provide information on the action they should take if symptoms arise hope that this response addresses your concerns
Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency The SPCs for POM; P and GSL NSAIDs including ibuprofen state the following in section 4.4 (Special warnings and precautions for use): 'GI bleeding, ulceration or perforation; which can be fatal, has been reported with all NSAIDs at any time during treatment; with or without warning symptoms or a previous history of serious Gl events. The MHRA and its independent experts consider that this statement in the SPC is sufficient to alert readers to the possibility of serious gastrointestinal side effects occurring early in NSAID treatment: However we acknowledge that healthcare professionals do not always read the SPC before prescribing, particularly when prescribing commonly used medicines, and your report highlights that there are some healthcare professionals who are unaware of this fact Therefore we propose to inform and remind healthcare professionals about this through an article in the September 2014 issue of our monthly bulletin Safety Update'_ b) Should gastroprotective agents be routinely given alongside NSAIDs in children? The SPCs for all POM non-selective NSAIDs include a recommendation to use gastro-protective agents (proton pump inhibitors or misoprostol) when prescribing NSAIDs to those at high risk of gastrointestinal side-effects, as follows: 'The risk of GI bleeding, ulceration or perforation is higher with increasing NSAID doses, in patients with history of ulcer, particularly if complicated with haemorrhage or perforation (see section 4.3) , and in the elderly. These patients should commence treatment on the lowest dose available. Combination therapy with protective agents (e.g: misoprostol or proton pump inhibitors) should be considered for these patients, and also for patients requiring concomitant low dose aspirin, or other drugs likely to increase gastrointestinal risk (see below and 4.5). This recommendation is also included in the SPCs for POM non-selective NSAIDs authorised for use in children: For non-prescription use of ibuprofen in adults and children, a recommendation for the concurrent use of PPIs is not included in the SPC_ For those NSAIDs available over-the-counter; the authorised doses are lower than prescription-only products, and the indications only cover short term self-limiting conditions which do not require diagnosis & supervision by a medical practitioner_ Patients (or parents of patients) at high risk of gastrointestinal side effects who purchase ibuprofen as an over-the-counter product are advised in the package leaflet to discuss taking these products with their doctor s0 that can be properly advised about the need for gastro-protective medicines to be taken at the same time_ After careful consideration of the details of the case presented in your PFD report; the MHRA and its independent experts do not consider that this case changes the overall benefit-risk balance of ibuprofen in children or warrants a change to the current warnings about the need for gastro-protective agents for prescription only medicines_ However, for all NSAIDs we will be strengthening the information for patientslparents provided in the package leaflet on the risk and recognition of gastrointestinal side effects and the action should take_ In summary, in response to your report under Regulation 28 to Prevent Future Deaths, concerning the death of Miss Akua Anokye-Boateng, MHRA will take the following action to minimise risk from the gastrointestinal side-effects of NSAIDs: CPRD NIBSC MHRA 'Drug they they help
Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency Proposed action Purpose of proposed action Timeline for action Drug Safety Update (DSU) To remind healthcare professionals of information Publication in the article already included in the SPCs for NSAIDs, that: September 2014 issue (wwmhragov ukldrugsafet the GI side-effects of NSAIDs can be serious and of DSU yupdate) life-threatening: Fatalities have been reported: serious Gl side-effects can occur with short-term use of NSAIDs serious Gl side-effects can occur in people who may be considered to be at low risk; including in children Strengthen the Patient To strengthen the NSAID product information Review and implement Information for all NSAIDs provided to patientslparents on the risk changes within 12 with regards to GI risk_ To aid patientlparent recognition of gastrointestinal months. side-effects and provide information on the action they should take if symptoms arise hope that this response addresses your concerns
Sent To
- Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
4 Jul 2014
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 23rd January 2013, opened an inquest into the death of: Miss Akua Anokye-Boateng; aged 7 years, died 16th January 2013, Case Ref: 00154-13. It was concluded on 28th March 2014. The court found that the medical cause of death was: 1a Acute Peritonitis and Shock 1b Perforated Duodenum Ic Non steroidal anti-inflammatory (NSAID) ingestion and Helicobacter associated chronic ulceration of duodenum in sickle cell disease
Circumstances of the Death
The following narrative was recorded: Akua had well managed and well controlled sickle cell disease. She suffered a 3 illness, consulting her GP but collapsing suddenly, unresponsive to prompt resuscitation and dying at 19.16 at KCH on 16.01.13. had ingested a non steroidal anti-inflammatory drug in May 2012 and suffered a GI upset in August Her death was unrelated to sickle disease and was caused by unexpected duodenal perforation, although chronic and multi-factorial.
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe that the general practitioner and medical director have the power to take such action.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.