Derrick Plater

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2014-0130
Date of Report 21 March 2014
Coroner David Osborne
Coroner Area Norfolk
Response Deadline est. 16 May 2014
All 1 response received · Deadline: 16 May 2014
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
There was no protocol for visiting care homes before placing patients with complex needs, relying solely on assurances. A lack of clear guidelines for when visits should be undertaken during assessment poses a risk.
View full coroner's concerns
was told that it was notat the time normal practice to undertake a visit of (he care home considered for placement; notwithstanding that Mr Plater had complex needs having undergone a laryngectomy and had a stoma. Accordingly there was a total reliance upon assurances given by the care home in considering whether it could in fact meet the assessed needs. It was indicated that if similar circumstances arose it is that a visit would be undertaken, However the witness was unable to confirm whelher lhere were guidelines or protocols for when a visit should be undertaken as part of Ihe assessment and placing process_ being today likely am therefore concerned that: If there are guidelines andlor protocols for when a visit of care home should be considered andlor undertaken as part of the assessment and placement process there may need to be a review of the dissemination and awareness of any such guidelines andlor protocols If (here are no such guidelines andlor protocols there may need to be a review as to whether such should be drawn up
Responses
Response
13 May 2014
Disputed
The council believes that a pre-placement visit by a social worker would not have provided any added assurance and is not and will not be part of the assessment and placement process. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mr Osbourne Re: Derrick Arthur PLATER (deceased) Response to Regulation 28 report concerning the death of Mr D A Plater Thank you for your letter dated 24 March 2014 requesting a response to a Regulation 28 Report: Please accept this letter as that response pursuant to Regulation 29 of the Coroners (Investigations) Regulations 2013. In your report you were concerned that there was a total reliance upon assurances given by the care home, Goodwins Hall; that it could meet Mr Plater's needs. At the Inquest into Mr Plater's death_ Cambridgeshire County Council's witness, tried to explain that under the terms of the care home's registration with the Quality Commission the Registered Manager; in each home, is responsible for determining whether the assessed needs can be met in their care home The decision to accept the placement by the care home is based on the health and social care assessments provided to the home_ That decision is usually supported by staff from the home visiting the person in hospital to complete their own assessment before making a decision to accept the placement: lexplained that the social worker completed a comprehensive assessment of Mr Plater's social care needs to enable the home to reach their decision: Hospital staff were responsible for completing the assessment of Mr Plater's on- going health needs The social worker sought reassurance from the multi- disciplinary team in the hospital that they were confident that the home could meet these needs. Discussions took place between ward staff and staff from the home and the senior nurse from the hospital team confirmed to the social worker that she O15A8L69 Avel Rooe)(aper Chief Executive: Mark Lloyci WwW cambridgeshire gov.uk Care About 0 1

felt that the needs arising from Mr Plater's laryngectomy and stoma could be met at Goodwins Hall: said that the social worker was aware that staff from the home had carried out their own assessment of Mr Plater's needs by visiting him in hospital prior to accepting his placement: As a consequence of repeated questioning on the discharge planning and placement process and the stress of attending the Inquest, lindicated that if similar circumstances arose today it is likely that a visit by a social worker would be undertaken before the placement was made On reflection Trecognises that this response was not correct. Isincerely regrets that she was unable to clearly explain to you the Registered Manager's responsibilities at the care home and assure you that the social worker had fullv carried out their duties to enable the home to make an informed decision_ also apologises for indicating that a visit would be undertaken in future_ In Mr Platter's case where there were complex health and social care needs, a visit to the home by a social worker would not; in my opinion; have provided any added assurance because social workers are not professionally competent to make judgements on whether Mr Plater's health needs were likely to be met at Goodwins Hall: Therefore , believe that it is unlikely that a pre-placement visit in these circumstances would help to prevent future deaths in similar circumstances For the reasons presented above a pre-placement visit by a social worker is not and will not be part of the assessment and placement process and there are no plans to introduce this step am not aware of any Local Authority that routinely undertakes a pre- placement visit in these circumstances. However, please be assured that if we had received information, from any source, that Mr Plater's needs were not being met this would have been investigated immediately and steps taken to ensure that his needs were met at Goodwins Hall or arrangements made to transfer him to another home_
Sent To
  • Cambridgeshire County Council
Response Status
Linked responses 1 of 1
56-Day Deadline 16 May 2014
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 10 June 2011an investigation was commenced'into the death of DERRICK ARTHUR PLATER, AGED 85 The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 10 March 2014. The conclusion of the inquest was as per the attached narrative conclusion: The medical cause of death was, inter alia; 1a Septicaemia and 1b Unstageable sacral pressure sores_
Circumstances of the Death
The circumslances of Mr Plater's death were' that he was a resident at Goodwins Hall in King's Lynn; Norfolk, a Hallmark Care Homes nursing home: On May 2011 he was admitted to hospital and returned the same day wilh a pressure sore. The pressure sore did not respond to treatment and he was readmitted by his GP to hospital on 25 May 2011. His condilion continued to deteriorate and he died on June 2011. Mr Plater had been placed at Goodwins Hall following an assessment by the local authority.
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths ad believe you and your organisation have the power to take such action
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Audit of Young Adults Team transition assessments
Southport Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care leaver transition to adult services
Prevent discharge of hospitalised children with concerns until home is safe
Laming Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care and discharge planning
Require consultant or paediatrician permission for discharging children with protection concerns.
Laming Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care and discharge planning
Require documented future care plan for discharging children with protection concerns.
Laming Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care and discharge planning
Ensure identified GP for children with deliberate harm concerns discharged from hospital.
Laming Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care and discharge planning
Require comprehensive child needs assessment before admission to care
Waterhouse Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care risk assessment failures
Follow emergency child admissions with comprehensive assessment within prescribed period
Waterhouse Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care risk assessment failures
Base care plans on comprehensive assessment, prepared with child consultation
Waterhouse Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care risk assessment failures
Prepare and periodically review leaving care plans for all looked after children
Waterhouse Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care leaver transition to adult services
Extend local authority duty to provide parental-level support for care leavers
Waterhouse Inquiry
Care safeguarding systems Care leaver transition to adult services

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.