SPSO Individual Decisions

7,958 published decisions from the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman (Jun 2011–May 2026). The Scottish Public Services Ombudsman investigates complaints about public services in Scotland — councils, the NHS, housing associations, and Scottish Government agencies. Source: spso.org.uk.

7,958
Total Decisions
7,733
Investigated
2,215
Upheld
54%
Upheld (of investigated)
Clear

Showing 2 results matching "Perth College UHI"

Perth College UHI (201403349)
Education Other
Decision date: 1 Aug 2015
Subject: special needs - assessment and provision
Mr C complained about the support provided by the college for his disability. Mr C said the college did not set up a personal learning support plan in a timely way, and his lecturers were not told that he had a support plan. Mr C also said the college failed to give him information about the assessment of some of his courses, failed to give him feedback in time, and did not explain the process or deadlines when they gave him the opportunity to study over the summer and take 'assessment on demand' for some courses. Mr C said he was given only one day's warning for one exam, and was not given a resit opportunity for other courses. Mr C also complained that the assessment for one of his courses was reviewed by an independent assessor without his permission, and that the college failed to respond to his questions and give him information he requested on several occasions. The college investigated Mr C's complaints, but did not uphold them, and Mr C complained to us about the college's lack of support and about their investigation of his complaint. While we were investigating Mr C's complaints, we found that Mr C had also complained to the Scottish Qualifications Authority about the same issues, and they were also investigating these. Given that Mr C already had access to an avenue of appeal which could give him the outcome he wished (reconsideration of his grades), we decided not to investigate Mr C's complaint about the support provided by the college. We asked Mr C if he wanted us to continue investigating his complaint about the college's handling of his complaint to them, but he did not respond, and we closed our investigation. Related reading View Decision Report 201403349 as a PDF (11.33 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018
Perth College UHI (201305440)
Education Upheld
Decision date: 1 Feb 2015
Subject: special needs - assessment and provision
Miss C, who has a condition affecting her mobility, complained of a lack of support from the college. In particular, she raised concerns about a fieldwork residential trip, which she was not allowed to attend due to health and safety concerns. Miss C said she was not involved in decisions made about her ability and, although she was provided with notes and recordings from the trip, these were not of a good standard, and she had to seek help from the lecturer to finish the assessment. She also raised concerns about delays in processing changes to her personal learning support plan (PLSP) and personal emergency egress plan (PEEP) in second year. Because she felt she was not receiving the support she needed, Miss C applied to transfer to a new course. However, this took some time and she was ultimately not able to transfer. Additionally, when Miss C asked her tutor why he thought the transfer was not an option, he suggested that the physical aspects of the course might be too challenging for her. In response to Miss C's complaint, the college accepted that the notes from the residential trip were not of a good standard. They also explained that the delays in the PEEP and PLSP were due to the unexpected absence of the additional support coordinator, and apologised for this. However, the college considered that Miss C's request for transfer had been handled reasonably. They said that her tutor had told her within five working days that her transfer request had been refused, and they considered that his comments about the physical aspects of the course being challenging were not intended to make assumptions about Miss C's physical ability. Overall, the college said that they had provided reasonable support to Miss C, and they did not uphold her complaints. Miss C was dissatisfied with their response, and complained to us about the additional support provided, the handling of her transfer, and the college's handling of her complaint. We investigated Miss C's comp
Upheld
2,215
SPSO found fault with the organisation complained about.
Not Upheld
3,569
Complaint investigated but no fault found.
Closed / Other
38
Closed after initial enquiries, resolved early, or withdrawn.

Investigated Decisions Over Time

Excludes 38 closed after initial enquiries. Quarterly, by outcome.

Decisions by Sector

Sectors by Upheld Rate

Which sectors have the highest upheld rate?

Sector Decisions Upheld Rate
Health 4,465 2,490 56%
Local Government 1,975 1,007 51%
Prisons 573 199 35%
Water 331 162 49%
Education 272 123 45%
Health and Social Care 153 82 54%
Scottish Government and Devolved Administration 145 76 52%
Housing Associations 23 13 57%
Outcome: 11 5 45%
Scottish Government 10 7 70%

Organisation Accountability

Top 20 organisations by upheld rate (minimum 5 investigated decisions). Based on 7,733 investigated decisions (excludes 38 closed after initial enquiries). Benchmark: 54% average across all investigated decisions. Sparklines show annual decision volumes 2017–2026.

# Organisation Trend Investigated Upheld Not Upheld Upheld Rate vs avg
1 Heriot-Watt University 9 6 0 100% +46pp
2 An NHS Board 9 5 0 100% +46pp
3 City Of Glasgow College 6 2 1 83% +29pp
4 A Dental Practice in the Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board area 11 7 2 82% +28pp
5 Lothian NHS Board - Acute Services Division 11 6 2 82% +28pp
6 Sanctuary (Scotland) Housing Association Ltd 5 3 1 80% +26pp
7 Lothian NHS Board - Royal Edinburgh and Associated Services Division 5 1 1 80% +26pp
8 A Medical Practice in the Western Isles NHS Board area 9 2 2 78% +24pp
9 Lothian NHS Board - University Hospitals Division 9 1 2 78% +24pp
10 A Council 42 15 10 76% +22pp
11 Clear Business Water 16 9 4 75% +21pp
12 River Clyde Homes 11 5 3 73% +19pp
13 Comhairle nan Eilean Siar 14 7 4 71% +17pp
14 Scottish Environment Protection Agency 10 2 3 70% +16pp
15 Dumfries and Galloway NHS Board 104 38 33 68% +14pp
16 Stirling Council 25 6 8 68% +14pp
17 Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service 22 11 7 68% +14pp
18 Grampian NHS Board 249 87 82 67% +13pp
19 Inverclyde Council 15 5 5 67% +13pp
20 Queen Margaret University 12 2 4 67% +13pp
All-organisation benchmark 54%