Inquiries / Themes / Courts, coroners and justice
Miscarriages of justice and prosecution disclosure
Wrongful convictions, disclosure failures, private prosecutions (for example Post Office Horizon).
25 inquiry recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations
What public inquiries recommended · 25 recommendations
2011
The SPSA should task identified staff with: (i) maintaining up-to-date knowledge of cases, at least in anglophone jurisdictions, in which fingerprint evidence has been disputed; and (ii) monitoring cases in which courts, inquiries or other investigating bodies have made significant criticism of existing fingerprint…
The SPSA should develop a procedure for the provision of information to COPFS where issues have been raised about the performance of an examiner who may be required to report or give evidence. COPFS should provide SPSA with guidance as to the nature and extent of the information that should be provided in order to…
The following information should always be provided to the Crown: (i) a list of names of all examiners who have examined the mark at SPSA and their opinions as to the mark and the comparison; (ii) whether the complex marks process has been invoked; (iii) any discussions between examiners relating to the formulation of…
SPSA and COPFS should agree and implement, as a matter of urgency, a process for the provision of information by SPSA to COPFS. COPFS should provide SPSA with information and advice as to the Crown’s duty of disclosure with a view to informing SPSA’s understanding of the nature and extent of the information that SPSA…
The omission of the SPSA from the statutory scheme of disclosure under sections 117 to 120 inclusive of the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 should be reviewed. The SPSA should be regarded as having the same duties as regards provision of information to COPFS as investigating agencies under those…
Any image(s) studied by the examiner in making an identification should be provided to the Crown on request together with the remainder of the selection of images.
Where third level detail is relied upon in making a comparison this should be included in any note of the examination.
Care should be taken when relying on third level detail in arriving at a finding and practitioners should pay close attention to research on the reproducibility of such detail.
Examiners should consider whether the clarity of the mark is sufficient to support a confident conclusion of identity or exclusion.
A finding of identification should not be made if there is an unexplained difference between mark and print.
Explanations for any differences between mark and print require to be cogent if a finding of identification is to be made.
In comparing a mark and print fingerprint practitioners should pay close attention to the precise type of the characteristics and carefully evaluate differences in the type of characteristic.
The SPSA should consider what limited information is required from the police or other sources for fingerprint examiners to carry out their work, only such information should be provided to examiners, and the information provided should be recorded.
The SPSA should ensure that examiners are trained to be conscious of the risk of contextual bias.
The SPSA should review its procedures to reduce the risk of contextual bias.
Differences of opinion between examiners should not be referred to as disputes.
Examiners should receive training which emphasises that their findings are based on their personal opinion; and that this opinion is influenced by the quality of the materials that are examined, their ability to observe detail in mark and print reliably, the subjective interpretation of observed characteristics, the…
An emphasis needs to be placed on the importance not only of learning and practising the methodology of fingerprint work, but also of engaging with members of the academic community working in the field.
Before a finding of ‘unable to exclude’ is led in evidence, careful consideration will require to be given to (a) the types of mark for which such a finding is meaningful and (b) the proper interpretation of the finding. An examiner led in evidence to support such a finding will require to give a careful explanation…
Subject to any requirement under ISO 17025 and recommendations 50 and 51, note-taking as to the detail found on analysis and the process of comparison, though not mandatory, should become the general practice for all fingerprint comparison work.
The SPSA should develop a process to ensure that complex marks such as Y7 and QI2 [name] are treated differently. Such a process should include the following principal elements: (i) Examination should be by three suitably qualified examiners. (ii) Notes should be taken at each stage of ACE-V by every examiner involved…
Features on which examiners rely should be demonstrable to a lay person with normal eye sight as observable in the mark.
In order to allow the court to assess the strength of their evidence, fingerprint examiners should highlight the variables relevant to their assessment and how they have formed their conclusions in the light of those variables. The conclusion should state if it has been reached through training and personal experience…
Examiners should discontinue reporting conclusions on identification or exclusion with a claim to 100% certainty or on any other basis suggesting that fingerprint evidence is infallible.
Fingerprint evidence should be recognised as opinion evidence, not fact, and those involved in the criminal justice system need to assess it as such on its merits.
Every record on this page is an inquiry recommendation published by the inquiry named on its card, and each card links to the recommendation. The themes, and which recommendations sit under each, are our own classification.