First Report - Levelling Up and equality: a new framework for change
Select Committee
Women and Equalities Committee
HC 702
24 September 2021
Government response
Levelling Up and equality: a new framework for change: Government response to the Committee’s first report · published 2 Dec 2021
Recommendations & Conclusions
13 results
54
Recommendation
Accepted in Part
Since 2019, the Government has referred to an Equality Hub within the Cabinet Office but...
Recommendation
Since 2019, the Government has referred to an Equality Hub within the Cabinet Office but to date the Hub has not published any corporate documents. Its structure remains unclear, and it lacks transparency and accountability. This is unacceptable. The Cabinet …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts in part, stating that annual staffing and funding information is already published in the Cabinet Office report, and commits to providing further bi-annual information directly to the Committee to support scrutiny.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
55
Conclusion
Accepted
We welcome the Equality Hub’s understanding of our central role in parliamentary scrutiny of its...
Conclusion
We welcome the Equality Hub’s understanding of our central role in parliamentary scrutiny of its administration, policy and expenditure, and that of its constituent units, including the Government Equalities Office, the Disability Unit, the Race Disparity Unit and its latest …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts the committee's understanding of its scrutiny role and commits to fully engaging with the Committee and maintaining a constructive relationship.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
56
Recommendation
Rejected
We recommend the Government bring forward a revised Standing Order, to make the Women and...
Recommendation
We recommend the Government bring forward a revised Standing Order, to make the Women and Equalities Committee a cross-cutting Select Committee of the House of Commons, appointed to examine cross-government policy on pan-equalities issues, and socio-economic inequality, geographic disparities and …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government rejects the recommendation, stating that the Women and Equalities Committee’s current Standing Order already provides significant flexibility for its work.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
57
Recommendation
Accepted
It is deeply disappointing and unacceptable that officials and ministers were unwilling to be openly...
Recommendation
It is deeply disappointing and unacceptable that officials and ministers were unwilling to be openly scrutinised in this inquiry, which is at the core of our remit. We hope this inquiry and Report can be a watershed in the Government’s …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts the recommendation and commits to fully engaging with the Committee and continuing to build a constructive relationship regarding scrutiny of its equality policies.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
58
Conclusion
Accepted
The Government Equalities Office’s move into the coordinating centre of government, in the Cabinet Office,...
Conclusion
The Government Equalities Office’s move into the coordinating centre of government, in the Cabinet Office, and the potential expansion of its coordinating role with the inception of the Equality Hub, is positive but the benefits are yet to be fully …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government response outlines current achievements and the established structure of the Equality Hub, highlighting its work, including G7 presidency efforts, but does not commit to new actions to address the committee's concerns about fragmentation or the lack of a published cross-departmental equalities strategy.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
59
Recommendation
Rejected
We welcome the Government’s intention to focus more on socio-economic and geographic inequality and look...
Recommendation
We welcome the Government’s intention to focus more on socio-economic and geographic inequality and look forward to the publication of its Levelling Up White Paper. While enactment of the socio-economic duty, section 1 of the Equality Act, is unlikely to …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government rejected the recommendation for a pilot on the voluntary adoption of the socio-economic duty, stating it is not necessary at this time and that they first want to evaluate existing voluntary adoptions in devolved public bodies and some English local authorities.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
60
Recommendation
Rejected
Given some of the Minister for Women and Equalities’ comments in her “new fight for...
Recommendation
Given some of the Minister for Women and Equalities’ comments in her “new fight for fairness” speech about not focusing on groups, we are concerned about a risk of going backwards on important, long-established equality issues for groups of people …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government rejects the recommendation to publish a cross-departmental pan-equalities strategy and annual Action Plans, stating the Equality Hub's objectives are already integrated into the Cabinet Office's Outcome Delivery Plan and existing strategies.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
61
Recommendation
Rejected
In 2018, our predecessor Committee found that allocation of the Minister for Women and Equalities...
Recommendation
In 2018, our predecessor Committee found that allocation of the Minister for Women and Equalities role as an additional responsibility of a Cabinet Minister was sub-optimal. The role was susceptible to Cabinet reshuffles and its allocation seemed like an afterthought. …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government rejects the recommendation to create a full-time Cabinet-level Secretary of State for Equalities and Levelling Up, stating that ministerial portfolios are the Prime Minister's prerogative.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
62
Recommendation
Rejected
We note both the current absence of a cross-departmental equalities strategy and strong coordinating machinery...
Recommendation
We note both the current absence of a cross-departmental equalities strategy and strong coordinating machinery to drive it forward. We therefore recommend the Government establish a dedicated Cabinet Committee for Equalities and Levelling Up, to add further drive to both …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government rejects the recommendation, stating that the portfolios of Ministers and Cabinet Committees are the prerogative of the Prime Minister.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
63
Recommendation
Accepted in Part
Our Reports on Covid-19 have demonstrated that the pandemic has had unequal effects on some...
Recommendation
Our Reports on Covid-19 have demonstrated that the pandemic has had unequal effects on some groups, including women, disabled people and some Black and minority ethnic groups, and exacerbated existing inequalities. The equalities machinery within government has not been sufficient …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts in part, agreeing the Equality Hub should lead on PSED, noting the public inquiry's terms are pending, and confirming the Equality Hub's ongoing involvement in reviewing disproportionate impacts in the National Risk Register.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
64
Recommendation
Rejected
International conventions, including the UN Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against...
Recommendation
International conventions, including the UN Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government rejects the recommendation, asserting that the Equality Hub already works effectively and collaboratively with other departments to meet international equality commitments and provide timely reporting, arguing that the current multi-departmental approach allows for specialized policy expertise.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
65
Recommendation
Accepted
Equality for different groups can raise difficult, balanced rights issues, for example race or religion...
Recommendation
Equality for different groups can raise difficult, balanced rights issues, for example race or religion and belief can sometimes conflict with equal rights on the grounds of sex or sexual orientation. There are lessons to be learned from recent delicately …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government states that the Equality Hub and EHRC already regularly engage a wide range of stakeholders on complex equality issues, including balanced rights, and therefore sees no need for additional or new activity as recommended.
Government Equalities Office
View Details
66
Recommendation
Rejected
The Equality Hub should conduct a review of the Government’s communications on, and management of,...
Recommendation
The Equality Hub should conduct a review of the Government’s communications on, and management of, sensitive and balanced rights issues, drawing in particular on lessons learned from the Gender Recognition Act reform process since 2018 and the Government’s approach to …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government rejects the recommendation for the Equality Hub to conduct a review of communications on sensitive rights issues, stating the Hub already engages regularly with stakeholders and refers to the EHRC's existing considerations.
Government Equalities Office
View Details